Magnet's force on a metal ball

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
1 reply · 3K views
sergiokapone
Messages
306
Reaction score
17
As one know, the force on mangnetic dipole in magnetic field is
$$ \vec F = (\vec p_m\cdot \nabla) \vec B_0$$,
where [itex]B_0[/itex] -- external field.
Let consider a some magnetic matherial with permeability [itex]\mu[/itex]. The magnetization of matherial is $$M = (\mu - 1) H$$ (in SI units) and by deffinition $$M = \frac{\sum p_m}{V},$$
where [itex]H[/itex] -- field inside matherial, [itex]H = \frac{B}{\mu\mu_0}[/itex], [itex]B[/itex]-- field inside matherial.

Let suppose, the material is magnetized so that $$\vec p_m \uparrow \uparrow \vec B_0$$, so the force on magnetic matherial is
$$ F = (\mu - 1) \int H \frac{dB_0}{dr} dV.$$

For the ball, we know the dependence between external and internal field:
$$B = \frac{3\mu}{\mu+2} B_0,$$
and
$$H = \frac{3}{\mu_0(\mu+2)} B_0.$$

Thus, the force on metall ball in a magnetic field:
$$ F = \frac{3(\mu - 1)}{\mu_0(\mu + 2)} \int B_0 \frac{dB_0}{dr} dV = \frac{3(\mu - 1)}{2\mu_0(\mu + 2)} \int \frac{dB_0^2}{dr} dV.$$

If the ball is made of feromagnetic matherial, then [itex]\mu \gg 1[/itex], then the force does not depend on [itex]\mu[/itex]:
$$ F = \frac{3}{2\mu_0} \int \frac{dB_0^2}{dr} dV.$$

Is the formula correct? Or, can be, I somewhere essentially made a mistake?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
sergiokapone said:
... so the force on magnetic matherial is $$
F = (\mu - 1) \int H \frac{dB_0}{dr} dV.$$
I don't see how that follows from ##\vec F = (\vec p_m\cdot \vec{\nabla}) \vec B_0.##
It's not clear whether you are using spherical or cylindrical coordinates, but even if ##\vec B_0## has azimuthal symmetry, there should be a ##\theta## dependence in spherical coordinates and a ##z## dependence in cylindrical coordinates.