Max Distance & Time Til Sky Nearly Black

  • Thread starter Thread starter Charlie G
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The maximum distance we can see any object is limited by the cosmic microwave background, which marks the point where light and matter separated in the early universe. As the universe expands, the visibility of distant objects is influenced more by time than distance, with the sky remaining bright until most nearby stars burn out. The Milky Way galaxy is not expanding, and its eventual merger with the Andromeda galaxy will lead to an increase in visible stars rather than a decrease. The discussion also touches on the concept of objects receding faster than light, which complicates the understanding of visibility in an expanding universe. Ultimately, the sky will not become nearly black until the stars in our vicinity exhaust their lifetimes.
Charlie G
Messages
115
Reaction score
0
I was wondering, since the universe is expanding, what is the maximum distance that we will ever be able to see any object?

Also, how long do we have before the sky becomes nearly black?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
At the moment 46.5 billion light years*
The 'furthest' object you can see is the cosmic microwave background. This is the point at which light and matter separated in the early universe so you can't see further back than this because there was no light.
So ironically the 'edge of the universe' (if you like) isn't black but white (at least in the microwave band).

The limit isn't so much distance as time - as we look further out, we are looking further back in time.
There is a distance before the first stars formed where you could consider it black in the visible.

*The rate that this is increasing depends on the cosmological model of the day so is a little complicated to work out.
 
Charlie G said:
Also, how long do we have before the sky becomes nearly black?

Our galaxy is not expanding. We are surrounded by stars and they are not thinning out.
For the sky to become starless, we would have to wait until most of the stars in our neighborhood burn out (and the formation of new stars ends)

So your question has nothing to do with expansion.

The way to answer it would be to look up wikipedia facts about stellar lifetimes.

Actually our galaxy is scheduled to merge with the large Andromeda galaxy. That should be pretty exciting. The sun and planets might accidentally be ejected from the main merger bulk by some fluke, some largescale gravitational slingshot effect. If not we might find ourselves surrounded by more stars than before.

I forget how long before the merger happens. Maybe something on the order of a billion years. Definitely something to look forward to.

Anyway, expansion is real enough, but it affects the distances to remote galaxies, not distances like a few thousand lightyears! So the sky will remain beautiful at least until the combined stars of Milky and Andromeda burn themselves out.
 
Charlie G said:
Also, how long do we have before the sky becomes nearly black?
Sorry, I took that to mean - how far out do we have to look for everything to be black.
 
Charlie G said:
...what is the maximum distance that we will ever be able to see any object?...

I'm curious. What distance do you mean? The distance away the object was back THEN when the light left it and started towards us?

Or the distance away the object is NOW on the day when the light gets here and scoots down the telescope?

For hands-on definiteness you should take an example? Like suppose you see a galaxy today that has redshift z = 4. How far away was it when the light left? How far is it now?
To find out, google "wright calculator" and type in 4 and press the button.

the distance then is what Ned Wright calls angular size distance.
the distance now is what he calls comoving radial distance.

Check it out.
http://www.astro.ucla.edu/~wright/CosmoCalc.html
 
mgb_phys said:
Sorry, I took that to mean - how far out do we have to look for everything to be black.

I thought your response was informed and helpful--I wouldn't contradict what you said, just add more information of a different sort. AFAICS everything you said was correct.
 
Thanks for the replies! What I mean by asking how far is the distance that is the maximum that an object can be visible is, how far is the point at which space expands faster than light between us and an object? Making it impossible for the objects light to ever reach us.
 
Charlie G said:
Thanks for the replies! What I mean by asking how far is the distance that is the maximum that an object can be visible is, how far is the point at which space expands faster than light between us and an object? Making it impossible for the objects light to ever reach us.

Have a look at the Lineweaver SciAm article in my signature----where it says "princeton.edu".

There is a fine point here. Most of the galaxies we can see today were receding faster than light (the distance to the galaxy was increasing at a rate greater than c) at the time that the light left them and began its journey to us. And nevertheless the light still got here!
 
Thanks for the help marcus:)
 
Back
Top