Model developed from performance curves are dynamic models?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
6 replies · 1K views
Nikhil N
Messages
80
Reaction score
2
I am trying to model a real heat exchanger in simulink. I don't have the geometry data. But I have UA curve with me. If I have developed the model with UA curve, will it be dynamic in nature?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
BvU said:
Nope.
Do you think, is it because the test data gives the details of only at steady state ?
 
I do. UA is an instantaneous value, a curve makes it a function of something.

On the other hand, dynamics of heat exchangers aren't often a focus (except perhaps in textbooks): I've always seen them treated as instantaneously reacting devices because the heat content of vessels, columns and reactors and such was so much greater. Do you have a particular application in mind ?

@Chestermiller : any experience ? -- and shouldn't we let the OP add some more context ?
 
BvU said:
I do. UA is an instantaneous value, a curve makes it a function of something.

On the other hand, dynamics of heat exchangers aren't often a focus (except perhaps in textbooks): I've always seen them treated as instantaneously reacting devices because the heat content of vessels, columns and reactors and such was so much greater. Do you have a particular application in mind ?

@Chestermiller : any experience ? -- and shouldn't we let the OP add some more context ?
I agree. I think we need to hear more details. But it might be a decent approximation if UA where used in a dynamic case based on the instantaneous conditions. It depends.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BvU
BvU said:
I do. UA is an instantaneous value, a curve makes it a function of something.

On the other hand, dynamics of heat exchangers aren't often a focus (except perhaps in textbooks): I've always seen them treated as instantaneously reacting devices because the heat content of vessels, columns and reactors and such was so much greater. Do you have a particular application in mind ?

@Chestermiller : any experience ? -- and shouldn't we let the OP add some more context ?
My end objective is to make complete simulink model for rotory air compressor. So this heat exchanger will become one of the subsystem in my model. Can you tell me, if I am using a heat exchanger modeled with this approach can mimic the actual system functionality?