Moment of a Couple, making sure answer is reasonable

  • Thread starter Thread starter torchflame
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Couple Moment
AI Thread Summary
To determine the value of F for a couple moment of 200 pound-feet clockwise, the method involves analyzing the moments at point B. The equation derived is F·2√2 - 600√2 = -200, leading to F being calculated as 229 lb. The discussion emphasizes the validity of placing the moments at point B due to the nature of couple moments as free vectors. There is a suggestion to verify the calculations by taking moments about different points. The overall approach appears sound, but attention to detail in calculations is advised.
torchflame
Messages
4
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Given the following structure, determine the value of F such that the resultant couple moment on the structure is 200 pound-feet clockwise.
hncC9NSl.jpg

I'm not looking for help here per se, just if this is a valid method of solution:
Because the moment of a couple is a free vector, it seems to me that the moments of the two couples can be placed at point B without any problem.
Then it would also make sense to me that: M_{\text{couple with F}}=F\cdot 2\sqrt{2} pound-feet clockwise, and M_{\text{150 lb couple}}=600\sqrt{2} pound-feet counterclockwise, which gives me that F\cdot 2\sqrt{2}-600\sqrt{2}=-200, which implies that F=229 \text{ lb}.
Is this a valid method of solution? It makes sense to me, but I'm not sure if it makes sense to anyone else.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
I'm very rusty on this but seems to me that you would need to know force at A to use your method. Perhaps I'm wrong.
 
look again at your root 2. It's not quite right. You can check your answer by taking moments about any point.
 
Back
Top