Need Double Check on a question

  • Thread starter Thread starter silentcoder
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a problem involving electrostatics, specifically focusing on the interactions between three point charges arranged in a triangle. Participants are tasked with calculating forces, electric field strengths, electric potential energy, and electric potential at specific points in relation to these charges.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants attempt to calculate the force acting on charge C due to charges A and B, as well as the electric field strength at a midpoint between charges B and C. There are also attempts to determine the total electric potential energy of the system and the electric potential at a midpoint between charges B and C.
  • Some participants question the correctness of their calculations and the assumptions made regarding the signs of the charges and the distances used in the formulas.
  • There is discussion about the direction of electric fields and forces, with some participants seeking clarification on how to incorporate direction into their calculations.
  • Confusion arises regarding the distinction between electric potential and electric potential energy, with some participants correcting their understanding of these concepts.

Discussion Status

The discussion is ongoing, with participants providing feedback on each other's calculations and reasoning. Some guidance has been offered regarding the need to consider the direction of electric fields and the importance of correctly applying the formulas for potential energy and potential. Multiple interpretations of the problem are being explored, particularly concerning the calculations for electric potential and the effects of charge signs.

Contextual Notes

Participants have noted discrepancies in the units of the charges and the need to clarify the distances used in their calculations. There is also a recognition that the total electric potential energy between certain charges may be zero, which adds to the complexity of the discussion.

silentcoder
Messages
18
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Given the following information:
611124_P5_U4263122123_G.gif

Givens:

A = +2.0mC
B = +4.0 mC
C = - 4.0mC
All of the sides of the triangle are 1.0 m
The inside angles are 60°


1. Determine the force acting on charge C as a result of A and B. Be sure to include a direction.
2. Determine the electric field strength and direction at a point half way between B and C. IGNORE A in this question.
3. Determine the total electric potential energy of the system of charges. Be sure to include all possible charge interactions.
4. Determine the total electric potential as a result of charges B and C at a point halfway between them. Ignore A in your thinking.


2. The attempt at a solution
1. Fb = kQq/d^2
Fb = (9x10^9) (4x10^-6)(4x10^-6) / 1^2
Fb = 0.144 N

Fa = kQq/d^2
Fa = (9x10^9) (4x10^-6) (2x10^-6)
Fa = 0.072 N

x = 0.144 + 0.072 cos 60
y = 0.072 sin 60

Therefore, resultant = 0.079 N[19 degree above horizontal]

2. Eb = kq / d^2
Eb = (9x10^9)(4x10^-6) / 0.5^2
Eb = 144000 N/C

Ec = kq / d^2
Ec = (9x10^9)(4x10^-6) / 0.5^2
Ec = 144000 N/C

E = Eb + Ec
E = 144000 + 144000
E = 288000 N/C

Therefore, electric field strength is 2.9x10^5 N/C

3. Pe = k(qa qb / rab + qa qc / rac + qb qc / rbc)
Pe = (9x10^9)(2x10^-6 * 4x10^-6 / 1^2 + 2x10^-6 * 4x10^-6 / 1^2 + 4x10^-6 * 4x10^-6 / 1^2)
Pe = (9x10^9) (8x10^-12 + 8x10^-12 + 1.6x10^-11)
Pe = 9.216 x 10^-24 J

Therefore, total electric potential energy of the system of charges is 9.2 x 10^-24 J

4. Needs help solving this question.

Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
silentcoder said:

Homework Statement


Given the following information:
611124_P5_U4263122123_G.gif

Givens:

A = +2.0μC
B = +4.0 μC
C = - 4.0μC
All of the sides of the triangle are 1.0 m
The inside angles are 60°


1. Determine the force acting on charge C as a result of A and B. Be sure to include a direction.
2. Determine the electric field strength and direction at a point half way between B and C. IGNORE A in this question.
3. Determine the total electric potential energy of the system of charges. Be sure to include all possible charge interactions.
4. Determine the total electric potential as a result of charges B and C at a point halfway between them. Ignore A in your thinking.


2. The attempt at a solution
1. Fb = kQq/d^2
Fb = (9x10^9) (4x10^-6)(4x10^-6) / 1^2
Fb = 0.144 N

Fa = kQq/d^2
Fa = (9x10^9) (4x10^-6) (2x10^-6)
Fa = 0.072 N

x = 0.144 + 0.072 cos 60
y = 0.072 sin 60
You're fine up to this point

Make sure your calculator is in degree mode for the following, which isn't correct.

Therefore, resultant = 0.079 N[19 degree above horizontal]

2. Eb = kq / d^2
Eb = (9x10^9)(4x10^-6) / 0.5^2
Eb = 144000 N/C

Ec = kq / d^2
Ec = (9x10^9)(4x10^-6) / 0.5^2
Ec = 144000 N/C

E = Eb + Ec
E = 144000 + 144000
E = 288000 N/C

Therefore, electric field strength is 2.9x10^5 N/C
That looks like the correct magnitude.

What's the direction?
3. Pe = k(qa qb / rab + qa qc / rac + qb qc / rbc)
Pe = (9x10^9)(2x10^-6 * 4x10^-6 / 1^2 + 2x10^-6 * 4x10^-6 / 1^2 + 4x10^-6 * 4x10^-6 / 1^2)
Pe = (9x10^9) (8x10^-12 + 8x10^-12 + 1.6x10^-11)
Pe = 9.216 x 10^-24 J

Therefore, total electric potential energy of the system of charges is 9.2 x 10^-24 J

4. Needs help solving this question.

Thanks!
I assume those charges are in units of μC .

For part (3) -- Two mistakes.

You ignored the signs of the charges.

You should divide by the distance between charges, not the square of the distance.


For part (4): This is similar to part(2), except you're to find electric potential at the mid-point, rather than finding electric field.
 
SammyS, after your suggestions I get the following answers:

1. Resultant = 0.19 N[19 degrees above horizontal]

2. Electric Field Strength: 2.9x10^2 N/C [WHAT WILL BE THE DIRECTION?]

3. Is this correct?
Pe = k(qa qb / rab + qa qc / rac + qb qc / rbc)
Pe = (9x10^9)(2x10^-6 * 4x10^-6 / 1 + 2x10^-6 * -4x10^-6 / 1 + 4x10^-6 * -4x10^-6 / 1)
Pe = (9x10^9) (8x10^-12 + -8x10^-12 + -1.6x10^-11)
Pe = -0.144 N/C

4. My Attempt:
Vtotal = 9x10^9 * 4x10^-6 / 1 + 9x10^9 * -4x10^-6 / 1
Vtotal = 39600 V

Please let me know if these are correct, Thanks!
 
I see you've learned to use colors on this site.
silentcoder said:
SammyS, after your suggestions I get the following answers:

1. Resultant = 0.19 N[19 degrees above horizontal]

That's correct.

2. Electric Field Strength: 2.9x10^2 N/C [WHAT WILL BE THE DIRECTION?]
I asked you the direction first. How can you add the electric field from each charge, without knowing the direction for the field from each?

3. Is this correct?
Pe = k(qa qb / rab + qa qc / rac + qb qc / rbc)
Pe = (9x10^9)(2x10^-6 * 4x10^-6 / 1 + 2x10^-6 * -4x10^-6 / 1 + 4x10^-6 * -4x10^-6 / 1)
Pe = (9x10^9) (8x10^-12 + -8x10^-12 + -1.6x10^-11)
Pe = -0.144 N/C
The above is correct.

Notice that the potential energy due to the interaction of charges A & B cancels with the potential energy due to the interaction of charges A & C .

4. My Attempt:
Vtotal = 9x10^9 * 4x10^-6 / 1 + 9x10^9 * -4x10^-6 / 1
Vtotal = 39600 V
No.
Check the final result.

Please let me know if these are correct, Thanks!
 
Sorry, I found out that the total potential energy between B and C is 0 V.

I am still confused on number 2.
 
Last edited:
silentcoder said:
Sorry, I found out that the total electric potential [STRIKE]energy[/STRIKE] midway between B and C is 0 V.

I am still confused on number 2.
Those corrections above are important. You're finding electric potential, not finding potential energy.

Regarding part (2):

What is the direction of the electric field due to charge B ?

What is the direction of the electric field due to charge C ?
 

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
6K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
6K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
16K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K