Need working checked for limits question

  • Thread starter Thread starter shan
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Limits
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around evaluating the limit of the expression (sqrt(n))^-n as n approaches infinity. The initial approach involved simplifying the expression to n^(-n/2) and using logarithmic properties, but the user miscalculated the limit of the logarithm, mistaking negative infinity for positive infinity. The correct limit is e^(-infinity), which equals 0, indicating that the original limit approaches 0. Additionally, there was confusion regarding differentiating exponential functions, with clarification that 5^n is an exponential function and its derivative is not simply n*5^(n-1). The conversation highlights the importance of distinguishing between power and exponential functions in calculus.
shan
Messages
56
Reaction score
0
My algebra's shocking so I'm not sure if I found the limit correctly... (sorry, I can't figure out this latex thing )

lim n tends to infinity of (sqrt(n))^-n

Using the rules of indices, I simplified it so that it became
n^(-n/2)

And then I used the log rule thing on it.

e^ lim (-n/2 * ln(n))

This is where I'm not sure: lim (-n/2 * ln(n))
I took the limit of the numerator (-n * ln(n)) to be infinity as n tends to infinity and the limit of the denominator would be 2. Infinity/2 is infinity so e^infinity is infinity...

Could someone please confirm or correct? Thanks :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
shan said:
My algebra's shocking so I'm not sure if I found the limit correctly... (sorry, I can't figure out this latex thing )

lim n tends to infinity of (sqrt(n))^-n

Using the rules of indices, I simplified it so that it became
n^(-n/2)

And then I used the log rule thing on it.

e^ lim (-n/2 * ln(n))

This is where I'm not sure: lim (-n/2 * ln(n))
I took the limit of the numerator (-n * ln(n)) to be infinity as n tends to infinity and the limit of the denominator would be 2. Infinity/2 is infinity so e^infinity is infinity...

Could someone please confirm or correct? Thanks :)
LIM{n → ∞} (√n)(-n) = LIM{n → ∞} 1/{(√n)(n)} =
= LIM{n → ∞} 1/{(n)(n/2)} =
-----> 1/∞ -----> 0
LIM{n → ∞} (√n)(-n) = 0

~~
 
As xanthym showed you, it was not necessary to rewrite the expression as a power of e in order to evaluate the limit.

That having been said, there's nothing wrong with doing so per se, it's just an unnecessary extra manipulation. You had it almost all right. Your only error was here:

shan said:
I took the limit of the numerator (-n * ln(n)) to be infinity as n tends to infinity

Wouldn't that be negative infinity? And so:

e^{-\infty} = \frac{1}{e^{\infty}} = 0

I just thought I would point that out, since I always find it helpful to see not only the correct solution, but where exactly I went wrong in my attempt. :smile: You should have been suspicious when you got the result that: \frac{1}{(\sqrt{n})^n} increases as n increases. It's clear the opposite must be true.
 
Thanks very much cepheid for explaining about the negative infinity thing :) We're supposed to use these 'rules' we were taught to solve the problem, one of which is finding the limit of the logarithm first.

Anyway... sorry to be a pain but there's another question I'm not too sure on ^^;

lim (n tends to infinity) of n^3/5^n

As it is indeterminant, I used l'hopital's rule and differentiated the top and bottom.
(3n^2)/(n*5^(n-1))
I'm not too sure if I can differentiate 5^n to n*5^(n-1) using the indice method though...
but I simplified the above to
3n/5^(n-1)
and because it is an indeterminant, I used l'hopital's rule again.
3/((n-1)*5^(n-2)
The limit of that as n tends to infinity would be 0.

My big question is... Can I differentiate 5^n to n*5^(n-1) ?
 
shan said:
My big question is... Can I differentiate 5^n to n*5^(n-1) ?

Nooooo...

Okay: what kind of function is this?

f(x) = xc

c = const.

It is a power function, right? Because the variable (x) is the base, and it is being raised to some constant exponent c. Being a power function, it can be differentiated using the power rule:
d/dx (xc) = cxc-1
______________________________________________________________
Now, what kind of function is this?

f(x) = cx

c = const.

Well, that's wacky! Now the base is a constant, and the variable (x) is in the exponent! This is not a power function at all! It is a totally different type of function. Not surprisingly, it is an exponential function. Do you remember how to differentiate exponential functions such as f(x) = 5x (the one in your problem)?

Hint: the answer has something to do with our favourite exponential function: f(x) = ex

You must be sure to distinguish between these two types of functions, as they are completely unrelated. So...just to be sure:

f(x) = x2 is a(n) ___________ function

g(x) = 3x is a(n) ___________ function
 
Last edited:
lol ok point taken :)

So x^c is a power function and c^x is an exponential function...

So if I differentiated 5^n, it would still be 5^n?
 
No...what's the definition of a derivative? How would you apply it here?

I'd recommend looking this up. It should be covered in your calculus book.
 
For simplicity
(5^{x})'=[(e^{\ln 5})^{x}]'=...

Daniel.
 
Thanks guys, I found it on the net afterall ^^
 

Similar threads

Back
Top