Discussion Overview
The discussion centers on the net magnetic moment per atom of typical ferromagnetic crystals, exploring how this value may differ from that of isolated atoms due to factors like band formation and electron interactions. Participants inquire about specific values and references related to various ferromagnetic materials.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant questions the net magnetic moment per atom in ferromagnets, suggesting it may differ from isolated atoms due to band formation and other effects.
- Another participant confirms that the magnetic moments can vary, providing an example of silver, which is non-magnetic in its metallic form despite having an unpaired electron as an isolated atom.
- A DFT calculation indicates that the magnetic moment for iron is approximately 2.2 Bohr magnetons, with a discussion on how band formation affects magnetic moments depending on the localization of orbitals.
- Participants express interest in cobalt and alloys, seeking tabulated references for magnetic moments of various materials.
- One participant mentions that the experimental value for iron's magnetic moment is lower than the DFT calculation, suggesting it is around 0.8 Bohr magnetons, but does not provide a general reference for such values.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally agree that the net magnetic moment can differ from that of isolated atoms, but there is no consensus on specific values or a comprehensive reference for various materials.
Contextual Notes
There are limitations in the discussion regarding the availability of databases for solid-state magnetic moments compared to isolated atoms, and the specific conditions under which the values may vary are not fully resolved.