Newton’s Second Law applied: F=ma

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around applying Newton's Second Law (F=ma) to a problem involving two blocks with different forces and masses. The original calculations provided by the user resulted in an acceleration of 13.33 units for Block B, which did not align with the given answer options. Participants suggested that the problem statement might be unclear or incorrectly translated, leading to confusion about the expected calculations. They emphasized the importance of using algebraic expressions instead of arbitrary numbers for clarity. Ultimately, the consensus is that the problem needs to be clearly defined to accurately determine the relationship between the forces, masses, and accelerations of the blocks.
adams_695
Messages
16
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
you have block A being pulled with a force. You then have block B which has an increase in mass of half the mass of the original block ( adding another 1/2 mass).

You also double the force block B is being pulled with compared to Block A.

What is the change in acceleration to block B??
Relevant Equations
F=ma
My attempt at solving this written out with random inputs

Block A- F(100)=M(10)A(10)

Block B- F(200)= M(15) A

A=200/15 = 13.33

This was not in line with options.. which were

4x block A
(1/4) block A
Equal to block A
(1/2) block A
2x block A

Much appreciated some help as I am a beginner
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I think your statement of the problem is muddled. Is this a translation?

Also, your answer of 13.33 units is relative to an acceleration of 10 units for A.

It's better to work alebraically in these cases; rather than inventing some numbers for masses and forces.
 
PeroK said:
I think your statement of the problem is muddled. Is this a translation?

Also, your answer of 13.33 units is relative to an acceleration of 10 units for A.

It's better to work alebraically in these cases; rather than inventing some numbers for masses and forces.

Thanks for the response. Just started out with physics and trying to wrap my head around it all.

The question is basically asking if you double the force and increase the mass by another half then what will acceleration increase/decrease by.

My first post on here also and tried to follow the guide appropriately
 
adams_695 said:
The question is basically asking if you double the force and increase the mass by another half then what will acceleration increase by.

Given that the answer to that question is not in the list of options, I doubt that is The question.

What about:

If B has half the mass of A and is subjected to twice the force, how does the acceleration of B compare with that of A?

Might that be the question?
 
PeroK said:
Given that the answer to that question is not in the list of options, I doubt that is The question.

What about:

If B has half the mass of A and is subjected to twice the force, how does the acceleration of B compare with that of A?

Might that be the question?
Just for entire clarity this is the photo I just took of the question. Thanks for helping
E1ED16B1-FBF2-4F3E-BC08-38546919C11D.jpeg
 
PeroK said:
Given that the answer to that question is not in the list of options, I doubt that is The question.

What about:

If B has half the mass of A and is subjected to twice the force, how does the acceleration of B compare with that of A?

Might that be the question?
Sorry didn’t upload properly before. Fixed it above
 
adams_695 said:
Just for entire clarity this is the photo I just took of the question. Thanks for helpingView attachment 247105
Well, the diagram shows the same force in each case, which contradicts the text.

In either case, none of the options answers the question.

Can you do the problem as stated, using symbols for the masses, forces and accelerations?

That might be a good exercise.
 
Back
Top