No graduate level electromagnetism? (Oh Jackson where art thou)

AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights the surprising absence of graduate-level electrodynamics courses, specifically those based on Jackson's textbook, at several institutions, including the Perimeter Institute and the Math Tripos III program. Participants express concern about the rarity of such courses in graduate curricula, questioning whether electrodynamics is undervalued in theoretical physics education. While some universities, like Warwick and Southampton, do offer electrodynamics content, the general consensus is that a Jackson-level course is considered essential in many U.S. physics PhD programs. The conversation suggests that self-study of Jackson may be a viable alternative for those lacking formal coursework in this area.
nonequilibrium
Messages
1,412
Reaction score
2
Next year I'm doing the one year master program at Perimeter Institute, and I was surprised to realize that there is no grad-level electrodynamics class (level Jackson, I would suppose?). I then checked the Math Tripos III (applied math, aka theoretical physics) course list (where I also considered going) and no grad level electrodynamics class either! Also, in my current university, I checked the master's program: no grad level electrodynamics.

So far I've only had a Griffiths level class, and when going through that it became clear that Jackson was the next step-up, for a grad level class, and I kind of assumed that at one point there would be a grad level class using that book, about electrodynamics. But the above seems to suggest that a grad level electrodynamics class is rare? What's the deal? Is it not important enough to be part of the grad curriculum (not even optional!)? Or are the above three universities the odd ones out?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
There is some electrodynamics in the master's at my old university (warwick). And I checked out another university (southampton) and they have some electrodynamics in their masters. So it seems common... I'm guessing since you mentioned maths tripos 3, that you were considering cambridge, so you are from the uk as well?
 
Nope, Belgium. Hm, odd... Especially since both Tripos III and Perimeter seem to focus on theoretical physics, and I would think that E&M is a non-negligible part of that.
 
That does seem odd. In physics PhD programs in the U.S., a Jackson-level E&M course is pretty much de rigeur AFAIK.
 
Every university I looked at required at least 1 quarter of graduate level E&M.
 
every physics grad student should have to suffer through jackson not once, but twice...it builds character
 
Dr Transport said:
every physics grad student should have to suffer through jackson not once, but twice...it builds character

We had to take two semesters of Jackson as undergrads.
 
George Jones said:
We had to take two semesters of Jackson as undergrads.
Where did you go?
 
We had to take two semesters of Jackson as undergrads.
That sounds harsh, but perhaps also an indication that I should simply try to self-study Jackson.
 

Similar threads

Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
9K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
20
Views
2K
Replies
0
Views
2K
Replies
32
Views
3K
Back
Top