Nonlinear spring made from many different linear springs in series?

9 replies · 2K views · last reply
MechaNick
Messages
5
Reaction score
1
Can I create a nonlinear spring, for a nonlinear oscillator, by putting many linear springs in series and parallel?
 
No. Since each spring has linear response, the overall response will be linear.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: tech99 and MechaNick
However, if individual series springs are allowed to reach their end-stops, it seems a good way of tailoring a non linear response. Rather like the log-amp in electronics.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: MechaNick and berkeman
So individual springs must reach a full compression? So eben the cone-shaped springs are only nonlinear if compressed maximally?
 
You may find nonlinearities even without hard stops. But the actual nature of the nonlinearity would depend strongly on the shape and the materials. It would be hard to say anything general about them.

So if you want to make a nonlinear spring with specified properties, that is not much help.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: MechaNick
Is it really that complex? I mean it is true that nonlinearities are mathematically tedious and often almost unsolvable, but aren't there any experiences or rough maths for something like this? The basic problem is how must a spring look in order to create an anharmonic oscillator?
 
MechaNick said:
Summary:: Nonlinear spring by creating different springs a at different ks?

Can I create a nonlinear spring, for a nonlinear oscillator
I did a Google search on nonlinear spring and got several good hits, including this one:

https://www.acxesspring.com/non-linear-springs.html

Conical/tapered spring: side view of a cone-shaped coil spring on the left and a top-down view of the same spring on the right, both in blue.

Two side-by-side diagrams under the heading Barrel Springs (Convex and Concave): on the left a red convex barrel spring with coils that narrow toward the bottom, on the right a green concave barrel spring with coils that widen toward the bottom, each hanging from a plate with a downward arrow.

Diagram of a dual pitch compression spring on a teal background, with a red label reading More Pitch = More Force beside the closely wound coils and an orange label reading Less Pitch = Less Force beside the widely spaced coils.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lnewqban
Yes, but they are exactly representing the model I posed. It is a series of springs. And they must block in order to become nonlinear.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: tech99
I mean, in reality, most springs will be non-linear. It is just that those non-linearities are usually assumed to be small and often are to good approximation.
 
Yes, it is said that all oscillators are probably containing some nonlinearity. But the thing is that they aren't measurable until one reaches a certain amplitude. In order to reduce that amplitude I thought I can create a cone shaped spring analogy by putting several linear springs in series. Like this:
Photo of a metal extension spring with a closed-coil body and a small wire loop hook at each end, lying on a wooden surface.
Photo of a metal extension spring with a closed-coil body and a small wire loop hook at each end, lying on a wooden surface.