Oil and Water: Investigating Buoyancy and Non-Mixable Liquids

  • Thread starter Thread starter W24JBLV
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Oil Water
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a problem involving oil and water in a beaker, where a block floats at the interface between the two liquids. Participants reference Archimedes' principle, emphasizing that a floating object displaces a volume of liquid equal to its weight. There is confusion regarding the specific gravities of the liquids and the density of the block, with some arguing that the block should sink if its density is greater than both fluids. Clarification is sought on the percentage of the block submerged in oil, with suggestions that the problem may need to be re-evaluated for accuracy. Overall, the conversation highlights the complexities of buoyancy and the need for precise information to solve the problem effectively.
W24JBLV
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
I have 2 liquids, Oil and water together in the beaker.

Assuming both liquids are non mixable

I push a block into the water and it floats at halfway between the Oil and the water

See the attachment and please help me I'm stuck and
passing the class depend on this particular problem ...
 

Attachments

  • problem.JPG
    problem.JPG
    17.4 KB · Views: 377
Physics news on Phys.org
Do you about Archimedes principle ? A body floats at the level where the weight of the submerged part equals the weight of the displaced liquid.

I think you got your specific gravities the wrong way round.
 
Mentz114 said:
Do you about Archimedes principle ? A body floats at the level where the weight of the submerged part equals the weight of the displaced liquid.

I think you got your specific gravities the wrong way round.

Yes I'm talking about Archimedes principle..

The Professor gave us this question as it is.. ireally tried to resolve it without
any success. any suggestions??
 
Mentz pointed out one problem. Another, even if reversed, Water has an sg=1.0, not .3 or .8

Finally as posed and assuming that the block is homogeneous and density greater than either fluid, the object would sink. I'd put this one away until you get clarification.
 
denverdoc said:
Mentz pointed out one problem. Another, even if reversed, Water has an sg=1.0, not .3 or .8

Finally as posed and assuming that the block is homogeneous and density greater than either fluid, the object would sink. I'd put this one away until you get clarification.

I'm sorry it is not water the question was two liquids.
Any liquids. assuming they are 0.3 0.8 i used water and
oil just to clear out which one is on the top and which
one is on the bottom.
So ignore the names.
The question didn't say anything about the object's density
the question only wants to know the % of the part that is
in the oil..
 
My reading of the question is that the block has sg = 0.93. So it would sink in the more dense liquid if it wasn't partly supported by the upper liquid.

Assume the block sinks to a depth x, and has top area A. You get an equation in x because A will cancel out.
 
maybe this is a deep problem after all, but the diagram shows a density greater than either fluid, but adds to it "in water part". If the density is greater than either fluid it will sink as in completely. Now if the density were somewhere between the two, ok, it should sit in between. But what's most confusing is you state that the object is 1/2 in 1/2 out, but the diagram asks for what percentage is in the oil? I personally (and this is without any mean spirited intention), is that you probably should repeat the course. Our bailing you out at the last minute is not apt to be of value to anyone.
 
Can Any One Help me with this Question?
 
by the looks of that picture ( 50%) heh
 
  • #10
Help anyone
HELP
SOS
 
  • #11
help
help help
help
 
  • #12
sorry, I wish I could help, but never took fluids yet. I agree with zenparticle though:shy:
 
Back
Top