Ok, hello for starters I have a question about water/electrofishing

  • Thread starter Thread starter Iseepotential
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Hello
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around using an electric fence controller to reduce crappie populations in a private pond through electrofishing. The user successfully tested the setup at home but faced issues with grounding and signal strength when attempting it in the pond. Participants highlighted the importance of using the correct type of current, suggesting that pulsed DC is more effective for stunning fish, as opposed to the low current high voltage typical of electric fences. Safety concerns were raised regarding the risks of using mains electricity near water, emphasizing the need for proper protocols. Ultimately, the thread was closed due to the dangerous nature of the proposed activity and the user's lack of experience.
Iseepotential
Messages
25
Reaction score
0
I have a private pond and want to reduce the number of crappie. I took a model 57 hold 'm electric fence controller and via inverter connected it to a 12v deep cycle battery. I tested it at home in a 1 gallon mason jar of water with two "hot" leads in water and the ground to a cabinet hinge and it worked great(both lights saying good power and ground. Took it the lake today with a 10 foot devider and silver solder 4 pronged things off each end connected to the two hot wires and tried about twenty ways of grounding it. The power light comes on but the light that signals signal strenth won't light up.

What am I missing?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Iseepotential said:
What am I missing?

hi there
welcome to PF ")

... a better explanation of what you are trying to achieve

Iseepotential said:
I have a private pond and want to reduce the number of crappie

I cannot even begin to imagine what on Earth you are talking about ??

would you like to try again ?

cheers
Dave
 
davenn said:
I cannot even begin to imagine what on Earth you are talking about ??
Crappie are fish. I think he wants to electrocute them.
 
  • Like
Likes davenn
Iseepotential said:
I have a private pond and want to reduce the number of crappie. I took a model 57 hold 'm electric fence controller and via inverter connected it to a 12v deep cycle battery. I tested it at home in a 1 gallon mason jar of water with two "hot" leads in water and the ground to a cabinet hinge and it worked great(both lights saying good power and ground. Took it the lake today with a 10 foot devider and silver solder 4 pronged things off each end connected to the two hot wires and tried about twenty ways of grounding it. The power light comes on but the light that signals signal strenth won't light up.

What am I missing?
Do you have a drawing? Have you considered the conductivity of the water? Have you considered that the electrodes have to be close to each fish? 10 feet seems a bit far. I am thinking that since the fence charger is designed to give a jolt without killing something and that a sustained lethal current should be used because it is the amount of current through the body that kills.
 
Last edited:
phinds said:
Crappie are fish. I think he wants to electrocute them.

Yikeees :frown:
 
It does not kill them if done right. that's how fisheries biologist check the health of a body of water. it just stuns them for about 30 seconds. Heres a patent for something similarhttps://[URL="http://www.google.com/patents/US8091269"]www.google.com/patents/US8091269[/URL] It takes a pulsing charge to achieve the desired results. Crappie are indeed a fish and they are extremely prolific breeders. A 3 year old female will lay up to 100,000 eggs and a first year fish around 25,000. I don't want to kill anything really. Just get a handle on the overpopulation problem. The fence thing may not work...I just can't understand why I can't ground it. I am open for any suggestions. Even taking the damn thing apart or starting from scratch. I hate buying premade stuff...I'd rather learn by doing it myself. Thanks for the replies fellas!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't know how to make a drawing on a pc. I'm sure its simple but I still have a flip phone.
 
Only guessing here

i searched on "electric fence grounding"

and it looks to me like one side of the HV winding should be tied to earth
and the other side of HV winding expects to be tied to an insulated wire.
http://www.fs.fed.us/eng/pubs/htmlpubs/htm99232321/
http://www.fs.fed.us/eng/pubs/htmlpubs/htm99232321/fig1.jpg

i couldn't find a "holdem" manual. Who knows what names they gave to their two HV terminals.
Iseepotential said:
Took it the lake today with a 10 foot devider and silver solder 4 pronged things off each end connected to the two hot wires
What's a devider? A wire screen?
If you connected both HV terminals to same piece of wire i would guess that places a dead short across HV winding.

Pond water itself might conduct enough to overload the charger. Check by tryng the same length wires that you used in the mason jar for starters..
 
like a T mounted to the bow of the boat with the same wires I used in the jar. I just added the 4 pronged solder things to try to disperse the current better. The only difference I can come up with is a greater volume of water so its not completing the circuit?
 
  • #10
would the amount of water being conducted make a difference? Stupid question I am sure. Of course it will, does anyone know how to make an electric pulse generator? I am certain I am going to do this one way or another and I figure you guys are as smart a bunch as I am likely to find.
 
  • #11
So what is the point of stunning the fish, if not to make them rise to the surface to be harvested? Is it going to scare them away or something? What is the end goal?
 
  • #12
to selectively harvest fish with a net. I want to keep the florida strain largemouth bass in thye pond as well as the coppernose bream and blue and channel catfish and reduce the population of crappie. The end goal is a healthy lake we have invested about 30,000 in creating and stocking. And yes for about 30 seconds they come to the surface and can be netted. If I understand this whole thing correctly it(the hot leads)creates a magnetic field that screws with their internal compass as the leads pass over them. You have heard of cranking a military grade telephone to stun fish right? Same idea.
 
  • #13
The crappie are so prolific they eat all the forage fish and it turns into a pond of small crappie. They eat everything else.
 
  • #14
Iseepotential said:
It does not kill them if done right. that's how fisheries biologist check the health of a body of water.

Iseepotential said:
to selectively harvest fish with a net. I want to keep the florida strain largemouth bass in thye pond as well as the coppernose bream and blue and channel catfish and reduce the population of crappie. The end goal is a healthy lake we have invested about 30,000 in creating and stocking. And yes for about 30 seconds they come to the surface and can be netted. If I understand this whole thing correctly it(the hot leads)creates a magnetic field that screws with their internal compass as the leads pass over them. You have heard of cranking a military grade telephone to stun fish right? Same idea.

So what equipment do the fisheries biologists use? Do you have any pictures? It would seem that you should just try to duplicate what they are using already, no?
 
  • #15
thats what I'm trying to do. I'll look up some pics. They use a generator and a controller of some sort. I don't understand what it does. I'm a 100 ton master captain but electricity has always thrown me off.
 
  • #16
Electric fences are low current at high voltage. Surplus phone generators are common and a better answer. How about a hot side 120 VAC from the mains, maybe with a light bulb current limiter. Dip the lead momentarily and shut off the supply.
 
  • #18
where would I find one? Could I make one? Thanks for your input and knowledge!
 
  • #19
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-HAND-CRANK-5-BAR-MAGNETO-Western-Electric-TELEPHONE-GENERATOR-48-A-Nice-/321699786017
 
  • #20
wow, cheaper than I thought. Thanks alot! I still want to understand how it works and try to build one. I'll order one of those and take it apart, thanks Doug!

Mike
 
  • #21
would the magneto work better or do they all have magnetos? I can catch any fish that swims and now run a finance company but electricity has always given me a headache...I appreciate you guys help more than you realize.
 
  • #22
Magneto is a technical-ish name for a permanent magnet alternator, a generator of alternating current. That's the pulses that you want to stun your fish. The contrary is a dynamo a similar device but with commutator bars to making DC.

You might have noticed the change from dynamos to magnetos, from generator to alternators, in automobile motors.
 
  • #23
knew I should have paid more attention in school
 
  • #24
so I could run wires off an alternator in theory?
 
  • #25
LOL If you're still sailing on your 100-ton ticket you're making better money than the rest of your classmates.

When we were moving into our beautiful cottage, we found the builder's AB ticket from when he went sailing on the Great Lakes when he was 16 y.o. He could build anything.
 
  • #26
alternating current is what I want right? Direct won't work right? So I can't just rig something off of 12v?
 
  • #27
Like in your car? Yeah, but in the car its regulated to about 12 volts and rectified to DC. There are kits to modify them to 120 VAC.
 
  • #28
Nope. Like I said, 120 VAC from the house-mains might be simplest. Talk to your neighbor the electrician.
 
  • #29
I fish, captain(sportfishing mostly) and would have starved after potus was elected. Dying industry. I didnt have any wish to be a bus driver for rig people(dying industry with oil prices as well) Its easy to sell money;) plus i have a 1 year old son...need steady income
 
  • #30
had it rigged from 12v to a 100 amp inverter
 
  • #31
Maybe that might work.
 
  • #32
it didnt, lol
 
  • #33
something about my set up was off
 
  • #34
D'you mean the fence charger? No. Just dip the 120 VAC 100 Amp leads momentarily and far apart, across the pond from each other.
 
  • #35
Iseepotential said:
alternating current is what I want right? Direct won't work right? So I can't just rig something off of 12v?

Please do a bit more reading, now that we know the correct term is "electrofishing". Wikipedia has a good article about it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrofishing Including links to more information. It appears that the waveform probably should be pulsed DC, with the waveshape having an effect on the size of the fish that are attracted/stunned.

And here is a regulation from the Fish & Wildlife Service about electrofishing, although it appears to be mostly about safety aspects for its own F&WS employees when they are electrofishing as part of their conservation work: http://www.fws.gov/policy/241fw6.html

:smile:
 
  • Like
Likes zoki85
  • #36
Its a private pond, what's a waveshape? Not trying irritate you smart people just enjoy expert advice straight from the "horses mouth"
 
  • #37
private as in not under government control...thank the good lord
 
  • #38
berkeman said:
Please do a bit more reading, now that we know the correct term is "electrofishing". Wikipedia has a good article about it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrofishing Including links to more information. It appears that the waveform probably should be pulsed DC, with the waveshape having an effect on the size of the fish that are attracted/stunned.
Very interesting about galvanotaxis. I admit I didn't know that. I thought they just stun the fish by currents between electrodes.
 
  • #39
I have read about these taxi's...what the hell does that mean? I assume not a mode of transportation.
 
  • #40
I was being sarcastic what is taxis?
 
  • #41
nevermind, wikipedia told me and gave me a headache
 
  • #42
I got it to work with a 12v and an inverter with a chain cathode and a grappling hook shaped silver solder anode. Measured 97 volts on a meter and could only get 24v on dc with two batteries in sequence. The problem is ac makes them sink where dc creates "taxis" and makes them come to the surface. I'm stumped, I think I need a "multiplier" for the dc. I just don't have a clue how to achieve it. Is that what a transformer does?
 
  • #43
Doug Huffman said:
Electric fences are low current at high voltage. Surplus phone generators are common and a better answer. How about a hot side 120 VAC from the mains, maybe with a light bulb current limiter. Dip the lead momentarily and shut off the supply.
That's what I was thinking. The basic requirement is fairly different for an electric fence and a fish electrocutor so I suspect the same device wouldn't do both jobs well.
As this is PF, I need to point our the Health and Safety issues here. Getting even a small electrical belt when you're in a tiny boat could turn a nice day out into a disaster. Make sure you use the right protocols for using such gear. I really don't like the idea of dipping a mains lead into water!
 
  • #44
Yes, this thread has become a discussion of a dangerous activity by a person who does not know that they are doing. As such, it violates the PF rules and is now closed.
 

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top