Overwhelmed Student Struggling to Pass Quantum Mechanics

AI Thread Summary
Struggling with a first Quantum Mechanics class, a student expressed concerns about failing after scoring only 20% on the first exam, while the class average was around 40%. The student enjoys the theoretical aspects but finds the fast-paced math challenging, particularly due to a lack of prior Linear Algebra knowledge. Suggestions from peers included either continuing with the course while simultaneously learning necessary math concepts or dropping the class to take Linear Algebra first, with the understanding that graduate schools would likely be forgiving of a retake. Emphasis was placed on "damage control," advising the student to focus on doing the best possible in the current situation, whether that means aiming for a passing grade or considering a pass-fail option. Ultimately, the student managed to achieve a C+, which was seen as a positive outcome given the circumstances. The discussion highlighted the importance of foundational math knowledge in successfully navigating Quantum Mechanics.
Fjolvar
Messages
156
Reaction score
0
Hello.. I'm taking my first Quantum Mechanics class and I've already failed my first exam (20%) although the class average was about 40%, I feel that I may fail this semester which would set my graduation date back a year, ruin my gpa, and my chances of getting into a grad school I've picked out. I really enjoy the theory behind Quantum but I am lost by some of the math. The professor will go through the material very fast and do math techniques I cannot follow. I have another exam in about 10 days, but I feel like that won't be enough time to learn the material. I feel overwhelmed and I'm not really sure where to start since there is so much to learn. I did really well in my math courses receiving A's in my Calc classes and differential equations but I never took a Linear Algebra course specifically which may be part of the reason. Any words of advice would be greatly appreciated.. Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Fjolvar said:
I never took a Linear Algebra course

I don't know much about QM, but I think it uses linear algebra and functional analysis very intensively. So the fact that you never took linear algebra, may account for the fact that you're not succeeding.

In my opinion, you got two options:
- continue with QM, and study hard to learn the linear algebra and functional analysis that you need. This will probably be quite heavy.
- drop the course, take the necessary linear algebra and functional analysis courses and take the course again next year. If you do well in the course next year, then I'm sure the grad schools will understand and they won't make a very big deal about it. But you will be losing a year...
 
I was in the exact same position. The prof was this German guy with a really thick accent. He went through the math at light speed, assigned no textbook, and had illegible writing. I went into a 45% final with an 83% and came out with a 59% in the course, my lowest mark ever, by far. I think I got 6% on the final exam...

I felt helpless. It seemed that no matter how much time I wanted to spend learning concepts, that I was ill equipped. I have no real advice for you, but I've been there done that.
 
Fjolvar said:
Hello.. I'm taking my first Quantum Mechanics class and I've already failed my first exam (20%) although the class average was about 40%, I feel that I may fail this semester which would set my graduation date back a year, ruin my gpa, and my chances of getting into a grad school I've picked out.

Two words. "Damage control."

If you can drop the class now, consider doing it.

If you can't then do as well as you can, and don't dwell on the past. If it looks like you are going to fail the class, then try for a D. If it looks like you are going to get a D, then put your effort into getting a C. The important thing is that if you mess up, you accept that you've messed up, and try to do the best with what you have. The problem is that if you dwell on how badly you did, then its going to make your performance worse than if you just let it slide and try to do the best with what you have.

I feel overwhelmed and I'm not really sure where to start since there is so much to learn. I did really well in my math courses receiving A's in my Calc classes and differential equations but I never took a Linear Algebra course specifically which may be part of the reason. Any words of advice would be greatly appreciated.. Thanks.

Calm down, and get really familiar with the drop deadlines or rules on taking courses pass-fail. If you can drop the course or take the course pass-fail, consider doing it. If you can't drop the course, then absorb as much material as you can, and make the best of the situation, and if you fail the course, you'll should do better the next time.
 
Fjolvar said:
but I never took a Linear Algebra course.

That's where your problem lies! Quantum mechanics relies on the use of eigenspace and eigenfunctions which is taught in Linear Algebra. While some calculus is used in QM, Linear Algebra pops up more often.
 
Just wanted to follow up with this.. I ended up with a C+, my only C grade :( But I am relieved I didn't end up with a D or worse.
 
Congratulations! Could've been worse - could've been a C- :) I think you did very well, all things considered. It'd be like me taking my diff EQ's class without knowing how to calculate sequences and series.
 

Similar threads

Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
32
Views
394
Replies
2
Views
2K
Back
Top