fresnelspot
- 29
- 0
Hi , i need some scientific source (book, article etc.) on phonon condensation in solids. Google scholar seems to fail in this topic. Can anyone advice me some source ?
The discussion revolves around the concept of phonon condensation in solids, exploring its theoretical implications, the conservation of phonons, and the conditions under which such a phenomenon might occur. Participants seek sources for further research while debating the nature of phonon condensation, particularly in relation to temperature and conservation laws.
Participants express differing views on the concept of phonon condensation, particularly regarding conservation laws and the conditions necessary for its existence. There is no consensus on the interpretation of phonon condensation or its implications in equilibrium versus non-equilibrium states.
Participants highlight the complexities of phonon behavior in relation to temperature and conservation principles, noting that assumptions about conservation may vary in different contexts. The discussion remains open-ended with unresolved questions about the nature of phonon condensation.
The number of atoms in the condensate is itself not conserved. Besides, at a given temperature isn't the total phonon density conserved too? In any case, I'm not aware of the need for total particle number conservation.wdlang said:I can not understand what phonon condensation means
Atoms can condense to a single wavefunction because they are conserved, but phonon and photon are not conserved!
This does not preclude the possibility of a phonon condensate at T>0. Keep in mind also, that the common method of cooling alkali atoms in traps necessarily results in the total particle number decreasing monotonically with temperature, and vanishing at T=0.If you lower the temperature of a solid to zero, the number of phonons decrease monotonically and vanishes identically at zero temperature, how can there be a phonon condensate?
Gokul43201 said:The number of atoms in the condensate is itself not conserved. Besides, at a given temperature isn't the total phonon density conserved too? In any case, I'm not aware of the need for total particle number conservation.
Gokul43201 said:This does not preclude the possibility of a phonon condensate at T>0. Keep in mind also, that the common method of cooling alkali atoms in traps necessarily results in the total particle number decreasing monotonically with temperature, and vanishing at T=0.