Plotting expectation value of spin vs. time

14 replies · 4K views · last reply
Graham87
Messages
72
Reaction score
16
Homework Statement
Problem e). See picture
Relevant Equations
See picture
Typeset physics problem on spin-1/2 particle: spin up and down column matrices, state |alpha> = A(1+2i, 2), and parts a to e on normalization, S_z and S_x probabilities, time evolution in a magnetic field, and sketching <S_x> versus time.

I have found an answer to all of them (a-e) but I don’t know how to plot the function.
Handwritten quantum mechanics derivation on grid paper: Hamiltonian H = beta B0 Sz, state chi(0) = (1+2i, 2)/3, time-evolved state chi(t) with phases e^(i beta B0 t/2), and the expectation value of Sx equal to 2 hbar.


Thanks!
 
It looks like you forgot to take the complex conjugate when writing down the adjoint.

But in any case, are you really asking how to plot a constant as a function of time?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: malawi_glenn and Graham87
vela said:
It looks like you forgot to take the complex conjugate when writing down the adjoint.

But in any case, are you really asking how to plot a constant as a function of time?
Aha ! Like this?
Hand-drawn graph on grid paper of the expectation value of spin x-component, labelled <S-hat_x>, against time t, with tick marks at h-bar and 2h-bar and horizontal lines drawn at both levels.
 
Yes, if your original answer is correct, but like I said, I think you didn't calculate the adjoint correctly.

Also, doesn't ##2\hbar## seem awfully big for a spin-1/2 particle?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71, PeroK, malawi_glenn and 1 other person
I can second that this is wrong
Handwritten derivation of the expectation value of spin x: a row vector of complex entries times the Pauli-type matrix (0 1; 1 0) times a column vector, with the first row's terms (1+2i)e^(iβB₀t/2) and 2e^(-iβB₀t/2) highlighted in a pink box.

you need to take the complex conjugate here
Remember that the ##\dagger## (hermitian conjugate) in linear algebra means transpose ##T## and complex conjugate ##*##, i.e.
a matrix ##A## when you do the hermitian conjugate, you do this ##A^\dagger =( A^*)^T##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Graham87
vela said:
Yes, if your original answer is correct, but like I said, I think you didn't calculate the adjoint correctly.

Also, doesn't ##2\hbar## seem awfully big for a spin-1/2 particle?
Aha, thanks. I get after correction ##(2/3)\hbar##.
 
Graham87 said:
Aha, thanks. I get after correction ##(2/3)\hbar##.
🤔 Aren't you suspicious that the expectation value of spin in the x-direction is constant in a z-direction magnetic field?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71, Graham87 and hutchphd
Do you know the motion of a classical "rotating" charged particle in this situation? The correct solution is (perhaps surprisingly) similar.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and Graham87
PeroK said:
🤔 Aren't you suspicious that the expectation value of spin in the x-direction is constant in a z-direction magnetic field?
Aha, true. I think I get it. Should it look like a trigonometric function?
I will try again later.
 
hutchphd said:
Do you know the motion of a classical "rotating" charged particle in this situation? The correct solution is (perhaps surprisingly) similar.
Not really. But I’m guessing something like sin(x)cos(y)?
I will try again later.
Thanks!
 
Graham87 said:
Aha, true. I think I get it. Should it look like a trigonometric function?
I will try again later.
Also,the Hamiltonian drives the time evolution of the system. You should expect something to change over time in this case.
 
Graham87 said:
Aha, thanks. I get after correction ##(2/3)\hbar##.
Still not correct.
Could you show how you did that calculation so maybe we can spot another error?
 
malawi_glenn said:
Still not correct.
Could you show how you did that calculation so maybe we can spot another error?
I used Euler formula to convert e, but I get something messy. Might my d-answer be wrong too (see pic at beginning) ?
Handwritten derivation on grid paper: <S_x> = chi-dagger S_x chi = (a* b*)(hbar/2)(0 1; 1 0)(a; b) = (hbar/2)(a*b + b*a) = hbar Re(ab*).

Handwritten derivation on graph paper of the spin state vector and expectation value <S_x> = (hbar/2) Re(ab*), with the algebra simplified to 2hbar/9 times Re(cos^2 theta - sin^2 theta - 4 cos theta sin theta).
 
Last edited:
That looks right, although if you had used the exponential form you would see that is equal to:
$$\frac{2\hbar}{9}\big (\cos(2\theta) - 2\sin(2\theta)\big )$$And note that ##\theta## is a function of ##t## here.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: malawi_glenn and Graham87
PeroK said:
That looks right, although if you had used the exponential form you would see that is equal to:
$$\frac{2\hbar}{9}\big (\cos(2\theta) - 2\sin(2\theta)\big )$$And note that ##\theta## is a function of ##t## here.
Ah! I got the same now. Big thanks !