Portfolio Feedback: Get an Expert Opinion

  • Thread starter Pithikos
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Feedback
In summary, the design of the portfolio is pretty juvenile and the English is poor. However, the portfolio can still be used for a CV for a serious job.
  • #1
Pithikos
55
1
I opened this thread under General Discussion but it got closed without me knowing why. So I repost it here(assuming that it was in the wrong place).

So I am a soon under-graduate in computer science and I've put up a portfolio to stick out from other candidates when I apply for internships or jobs.

I would just like to hear what you people think and if I should change something. All criticism is good so hit me ruthlessly :biggrin:

Do you think the design is a bit too juvenile?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I don't know what that is, but no, you could not use this instead of a CV for a serious job. The English is very poor, some words aren't even English, (wanna is poor slang, something you should never use with a CV/resume).
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Evo said:
I don't know what that is, but no, you could not use this instead of a CV for a serious job. The English is very poor, some words aren't even English, (wanna is poor slang, something you should never use with a CV/resume).

Thank you for your reply. I read it also on my previous thread but couldn't answer because the thread got closed.

Portfolio is pretty much a way to show your work. In this case as a coder and designer, I try to show some of my coding projects and some of my graphics.

I agree, "wanna" is a bit informal, but it's quite commonly used even by high class people(did research on it) so I put it in there just to sound like I am talking directly to the viewer. I thought the rest of the English was pretty fine. I mean I am just an undergraduate in computer science, not a lawyer so how formal should it be? I don't want to sound cold either.
 
  • #4
Pithikos said:
I agree, "wanna" is a bit informal, but it's quite commonly used even by high class people(did research on it)

Your research is faulty. "Wanna" is used by five year olds and illiterates. You need to change it.
 
  • #5
I can't speak as a hiring manager, but..

I agree with above. Unless you're hiring into some sort of casual computer programming company that doesn't have politics and professional standards, you'll need to change it. Most of industry acts professionally, especially in the hiring stage. Slang, whether used by high class people or not, is not professional in a business sense. They will view slang as you not taking the position seriously.

As far as how this compares to a CV, I have no idea. But if it were me, I would use the standard CV/Resume and then potentially use something like this during an interview, not in place of a CV.
 
  • #6
Pithikos, you are obviously creative, but you need to consider who will be reviewing your CV/resume. For some positions, such as an artist, a creative approach can be appropriate and even give you an edge, but for a computer science graduate, you need to be more "mainstream". Most employers get deluged with applications. A lot of companies now even require that you upload your CV/resume in plain text for starting positions. They want to view everything the same way. Some even use software that searches for key words and having the wrong words can mean it won't even get to a human.

Perhaps it would help you to check out a few CV/resume websites that can give you ideas and information about what works in the industry you wish to enter. Does your University offer career counseling? Take advantage of any free help you can get.

I have been on the hiring end for a huge multinational company before and I was shocked at how brutal the process is. People were flinging resumes into the corner of the room and laughing. Anything with designs, textures, colors or unusual font got pitched without even being read, and these were the ones that got past the initial screening and forwarded to us. I would suggest doing some research and taking advantage of any help you can get. I wish you good luck, I don't envy anyone that has to go through a job search in today's environment.
 

Related to Portfolio Feedback: Get an Expert Opinion

1. What is portfolio feedback and why is it important?

Portfolio feedback is the process of receiving expert opinion and constructive criticism on your portfolio, which is a collection of your work. It is important because it allows you to improve and refine your portfolio, making it more effective in showcasing your skills and achievements to potential employers or clients.

2. How can I get an expert opinion on my portfolio?

There are various ways to get an expert opinion on your portfolio. You can reach out to professionals in your field, such as teachers, mentors, or colleagues, and ask for their feedback. You can also seek feedback from online communities or through professional portfolio review services.

3. What should I expect from a portfolio feedback session?

In a portfolio feedback session, you can expect an in-depth review of your portfolio, including both its strengths and weaknesses. The expert will provide constructive criticism and suggestions for improvement, as well as praise for elements that stand out. You can also expect to receive specific and actionable feedback that you can use to enhance your portfolio.

4. How often should I seek portfolio feedback?

It is recommended to seek portfolio feedback at least once a year, or whenever you make significant updates or changes to your portfolio. However, if you are actively looking for employment or clients, it may be beneficial to seek feedback more frequently to ensure your portfolio is up-to-date and effective.

5. Can I use portfolio feedback to improve my skills?

Yes, portfolio feedback can be an excellent tool for skill development. By receiving expert opinions on your portfolio, you can identify areas where you may need to improve and work on refining those skills. Additionally, the feedback can also help you identify your strengths and use them to your advantage in your future work or projects.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
1K
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • STEM Career Guidance
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Feedback and Announcements
Replies
1
Views
581
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • STEM Career Guidance
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • STEM Career Guidance
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • STEM Career Guidance
Replies
10
Views
1K
Back
Top