Power Electronics: Choppers RLE Load

11 replies · 3K views · last reply
jaus tail
Messages
613
Reaction score
48

Homework Statement


Circuit schematic of a chopper: a 200 V DC source, a switch marked t=0, a freewheeling diode FD, and an RLE load with R, L and E in series.


Homework Equations


I rms for triangular waveform = I(max)/ (1.732)
R = V/I

The Attempt at a Solution


Since there is RLE load, current waveform is triangular. It is
Hand-drawn graph of I(load) against time showing a triangular-style waveform with peaks labelled 32.75A and a trough labelled 26.05A.


Source current is
Two stacked waveform plots: top, I(load) a triangular ripple peaking at 32.75A and dipping to 26.05A; bottom, I(source) pulses rising to 32.75A and 26.05A, with zero current between pulses.

Average of I source. I used integration. Assumed Time period = 10 seconds. So T on = 5 seconds. (question says duty = 0.5)

So integrating I got average source current = 14.7 A
Average source voltage = 200 V
So input resistance = 200 / 14.7 = 13.6A

But I'm not able to get the first one. I get answer as 26.33 A But that is not even in the option.
I used formula square I(load) = square dc component (26.05) + square (rms of triangular waveform)
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic of a chopper: a 200 V DC source, a switch marked t=0, a freewheeling diode FD, and an RLE load with R, L and E in series.
    upload_2018-1-3_13-45-55.png
    10.2 KB · Views: 1,270
  • Hand-drawn graph of I(load) against time showing a triangular-style waveform with peaks labelled 32.75A and a trough labelled 26.05A.
    upload_2018-1-3_13-47-48.png
    1.4 KB · Views: 586
  • Two stacked waveform plots: top, I(load) a triangular ripple peaking at 32.75A and dipping to 26.05A; bottom, I(source) pulses rising to 32.75A and 26.05A, with zero current between pulses.
    upload_2018-1-3_14-6-51.png
    2.1 KB · Views: 678
Last edited:
It says minimum is 32.75A and maximum is 26.05A. Something seems wrong, since we expect max > min.

So I'd say there's a printing error, maybe two, and in either the data or the answer options. Would (A) 26.17A satisfy you? If not, you could play around with various changes in the answers to see whether you can stumble across consistent values.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jaus tail
Yes the printing error occurred to me as well. I guess only the max n min words should be exchanged. Cause I'm getting right answer for second part of question.
How do you get 30.17A as answer?
 
I looked for a single digit to change that would turn what's printed into something close to what you're looking for.
 
Book says answer is A.
Is this correct method?
Handwritten sketch of a periodic current waveform i(t) against t, peaking near 32.75 A and dipping to 26.05 A, with a derivation below giving Irms² = 26.05² + ((32.75 − 26.05)/√3)² and a result of 26.34 A.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten sketch of a periodic current waveform i(t) against t, peaking near 32.75 A and dipping to 26.05 A, with a derivation below giving Irms² = 26.05² + ((32.75 − 26.05)/√3)² and a result of 26.34 A.
    upload_2018-1-3_19-34-30.png
    49.6 KB · Views: 553
Your calculations are probably right. You answered while I was still adjusting my comment. I settled on 26.17 as a likely option.

Maybe if you worked it out exactly, using the exponentials instead of approximating to straight lines, it might match the 26.17A answer exactly?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jaus tail
So instead of triangular ur saying exponential waveform? e-Rt/L?
 
jaus tail said:
So instead of triangular ur saying exponential waveform? e-Rt/L?
Well, only if you want to test whether my hunch is right. :oldsmile: The homework would not expect you to, the triangular approximation is fine. Though in the real world you should show that the triangular approximation is justified and not simply assume it is, i.e., not just hope it is.
 
I got something like this:
Handwritten notes on lined paper: a sketch of a pulse-shaped current waveform rising to 32.75 and falling, with 26.05 marked on the axis, and T1 and T2 labels; beside it, equations for i(t) in two intervals, solving for A = 0.023, and an integral expression for the average current.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten notes on lined paper: a sketch of a pulse-shaped waveform with peak 32.75 and base level 26.05 over intervals T1 and T2, with equations for current I(t) for 0 to 5 s and 5 to 10 s, a solved value of A = 0.023, and an integral expression.
    upload_2018-1-3_19-59-56.png
    37 KB · Views: 632
  • Handwritten notes on lined paper: a sketch of a pulse-shaped current waveform rising to 32.75 and falling, with 26.05 marked on the axis, and T1 and T2 labels; beside it, equations for i(t) in two intervals, solving for A = 0.023, and an integral expression for the average current.
    upload_2018-1-3_20-4-23.png
    38.3 KB · Views: 513
I guess triangular waveform is justified when the inductance is very big. If resistance is very big then waveform of current = waveform of voltage = square.
I'm getting integrating value as 27.6A
How did you integrate so fast?
 
I haven't worked out an answer. I see insufficient information given to do so, in this instance.

The rising exponential, A(1-e-t/T) has magnitude A = (200-E)/R – 26.05
and T = L/R = unspecified
and passes through the point 6.7 at t=?? (5ms your nomination)

Too many unknowns to evaluate to a number, I think.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jaus tail
I assumed T to be 10 seconds and since duty cycle is 0.5 we get inductor storing energy for 5 seconds and releasing energy for 5 seconds.