Pressure diagram labelled incorrectly?

5 replies · 1K views · last reply
needingtoknow
Messages
160
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



At the point specified in the diagram, isn't pressure coming from all directions, namely gauge pressure. So wouldn't some of the gauge pressure be used to counteract the effects from the atmospheric pressure. Doesn't this mean the equation Ptotal = Patsurface + Pgauge is wrong?
 
Attachments
  • Two open tanks of water with a dot marking a point below the surface; left tank shows atmospheric pressure P_atm and gauge pressure P_gauge pushing down, right tank shows gas pressure P_gas and P_gauge; equations P_total = P_atm + P_gauge and P_total = P_gas + P_gauge, and boxed P_total = P_at surface + P_gauge.
    pressure.PNG
    10.2 KB · Views: 466
You are correct that at any point, the pressure is the same in all directions. But I believe you are misinterpreting the diagram. What they are calling Pgauge is just that portion of the pressure due to the weight of the fluid itself. So the equation holds.
 
So but if it's only due to weight then by that saying wouldn't water at the bottom of the container have the greatest Pgauge because it is under the most fluid and the weight of a fluid is F = Pvg right so more volume = larger weight?
 
needingtoknow said:
So but if it's only due to weight then by that saying wouldn't water at the bottom of the container have the greatest Pgauge because it is under the most fluid and the weight of a fluid is F = Pvg right so more volume = larger weight?
It's the pressure of the fluid, not the volume, that counts. But yes, at the bottom of the container the pressure due to the fluid is greatest. The pressure at any point below the surface is given by ρgh, regardless of volume.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
All right great then that makes sense! Thank you very much!