Primary winding and secondary winding wraped around a iron core

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the operation and connections of transformers, specifically focusing on the primary and secondary windings wrapped around an iron core. Participants explore the implications of connecting the primary winding to a high voltage source and grounding the secondary winding, as well as the resulting voltage outputs and safety considerations.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants assert that connecting a wire to the center of the secondary winding would yield 0 volts at that point, with 120 volts measured between the center tap and one line, questioning if grounding the center tap is solely for protection.
  • Others argue that without a connection to ground, the potential difference between the secondary coil and ground is undefined, and grounding creates a symmetrical relationship between the coil ends.
  • A participant seeks clarification on whether the potential difference (PD) being the same refers to the center tap and one phase, and questions the implications of connecting a tap 3/4 of the way in the coil to ground.
  • Some participants clarify that the voltage at the ends of the secondary winding remains the same regardless of grounding, and that connecting the center tap to ground does not alter the total PD between the ends of the coil.
  • Concerns are raised about the primary winding connection to a high voltage source and whether it constitutes a short circuit, with some asserting that primary inductance prevents this from being the case.
  • Another participant emphasizes that the transformer will not draw significant current unless a load is connected to the secondary, indicating that the design of the transformer allows it to operate without short-circuiting the primary winding.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the implications of grounding the secondary winding and the nature of the connections to the primary winding. There is no consensus on the safety and operational characteristics of the transformer connections discussed.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention various assumptions regarding the design and operation of transformers, including the number of turns per volt and the behavior of alternating current in relation to grounding. Some discussions also touch on the potential for misunderstanding the nature of the connections involved.

deakn
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
I got a few questions about transformers..

I understand there is a primary winding and secondary winding wraped around a iron core.

Now for the primary connection - take 7.2kv 1 phase line and connect it to one side of the winding and take ground (earth) to the other winding end.

On the secondary winding if the windings are set up right by amount of turns i can get 240 volts correct. -120v one line and +120v on the other

If i connect a wire in the center of the secondary winding the voltage would be 0 here? and i get 120 between center tap and line? connecting the middle of the winding to ground is just for protection? ( just making sure that the connection from the middle of the winding to ground is what's making it get 120)
 
Engineering news on Phys.org


deakn said:
I got a few questions about transformers..

I understand there is a primary winding and secondary winding wraped around a iron core.

Now for the primary connection - take 7.2kv 1 phase line and connect it to one side of the winding and take ground (earth) to the other winding end.

On the secondary winding if the windings are set up right by amount of turns i can get 240 volts correct. -120v one line and +120v on the other

If i connect a wire in the center of the secondary winding the voltage would be 0 here? and i get 120 between center tap and line? connecting the middle of the winding to ground is just for protection? ( just making sure that the connection from the middle of the winding to ground is what's making it get 120)

Give this a read: http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/HBASE/electric/hsehld.html

It should answer your questions.

CS
 


deakn said:
I got a few questions about transformers..



If i connect a wire in the center of the secondary winding the voltage would be 0 here? and i get 120 between center tap and line? connecting the middle of the winding to ground is just for protection? ( just making sure that the connection from the middle of the winding to ground is what's making it get 120)
If there is no connection / path to ground from your secondary then the Potential Difference between the coil and ground is totally undefined. (It 'floats'; there is no DC connection via a magnetic coupling) If you choose to connect the centre tap to Earth then the extremities of coil will be in antiphase, symmetrical about Earth. The PD between the two is the same whatever part of the coil you connect to Earth. (Needless to say, you can only connect one part if you don't want a smoke making machine)
 


sophiecentaur said:
If you choose to connect the centre tap to Earth then the extremities of coil will be in antiphase, symmetrical about Earth. The PD between the two is the same whatever part of the coil you connect to Earth. (Needless to say, you can only connect one part if you don't want a smoke making machine)

Just need one thing cleared up when you are talking about the PD between the two is the same do you mean between one phase an the center tap?

What if i where to connect a tap 3/4 of the way in the coil to Earth what would the voltages be from each phase to earth?
And also does this connection i mention make sense at all or does it work? Now for the primary connection - take 7.2kv 1 phase line and connect it to one side of the winding and take ground (earth) to the other winding end. (from powerlines don't undersstand if they take one phase and Earth or use two phases to make 240 volts in the end)

On the secondary winding if the windings are set up right by amount of turns i can get 240 volts correct. -120v one line and +120v on the other (like showed in the link)
 
Last edited:


Steady on - we don't have two "phases" yet; that's a bit of shorthand which supply engineers use. All we have is the ends of two wires. The volts on end A are alternating positively and negatively relative to end B (the PD) - each turn of the secondary is providing a small PD, which adds up to the total. If you connect the centre to Earth, the same PD exits across AB as before but relative to Earth the voltages at A and B will be half the original PD and in antiphase. If you put a tap 3/4 of the way between A and B, the Volts on A will be three times that at B and still in antiphase. Again, the total PD between A and B is the original value.

But what you are suggesting is only the equivalent of having two separate secondary windings and connecting them in series to get a higher output voltage. The Volts per turn are the same everywhere in the transformer and you can just add up all the turns (carefully connecting so that the Volts to add and not subtract).

Whether or not there is one leg of the input connected to Earth makes no difference to the secondary volts - why should it? There is no difference in the magnetic flux change - linking to the secondary (i.e. no DC involved). If the supply is floating then you should leave it floating or your Neutral conductor is being shorted by the Earth return which may not be what the supplier wants. You can do what you want as regards Earth connections in the secondary once you are isolated with a transformer - as discussed above.

In your last sentence, you don't really mean +120 and -120V, do you? You surely mean 120V AC and 120V(@180degrees) AC.
 


If you connect one lead of the primary winding to 7.2k volts and the other lead of the primary to Earth isn't this a short circuit?
Isn't it like connecting a hot wire in your house to ground what am i missing here
 


I think you are missing the Primary Inductance.
By your argument, all transformer primaries would be short circuits to AC.
 


sophiecentaur said:
I think you are missing the Primary Inductance.
.

Can you explain in more detail please
 


Assuming the transformer is designed correctly (enough turns per volt) the reactance of the primary will mean that it will not constitute a short circuit to the AC. The only current that the transformer will draw will be due to current in the load placed across the secondary.
That's how all (conventional) transformers work. Look in Wiki.
I think the OP is describing conventional use.
 

Similar threads

Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
8K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
4K
Replies
64
Views
8K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 50 ·
2
Replies
50
Views
9K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K