Proof of x3+x2y+xy2+y3 = 0: x=y=0 or x=-y

[jgens]

Homework Statement

Prove that if x³+x²y+xy²+y³ = 0, then x = y = 0 or x = -y.

Homework Equations

N/A

The Attempt at a Solution

Assume that x³+x²y+xy²+y³ = 0, in which case, it follows that x³+y³ = -(x²y+xy²) or (x+y)(x²-xy+y²) = -xy(x+y). Equality clearly holds if x+y = 0. Now, suppose that x+y =/= 0, and divide through by x+y. This leaves the equality x²-xy+y² = -xy or x²+y² = 0, which can only happen if x = y = 0. Therefore, if x³+x²y+xy²+y³ = 0, then x = -y or x = y = 0.

Does this 'proof' work?

 

[Mentallic]

Yes, of course it does. Your proof is sound and logical.

 

[jgens]

Thanks! I've been second guessing myself a lot lately, so it's always good to get confirmation that I've done something correctly.

 

[Mentallic]

Yeah, I know the feeling

 

[HallsofIvy]

Excellent! I would have done it a slightly different way: it appeared to me, looking at the first two terms, that x^2+ x^2y= x^2(x+ y) and then that xy^2+ y^3= y^2(x+ y). Since (x+ y) appears in both of those we can factor it out and have x^3+ x^2y+ xy^2+ y^3= (x^2+ y^2)(x+ y).

That will be 0 only if one or the other of those factors is 0. x^2+ y^2= 0 only if x= y= 0 and x+ y= 0 only if y= -x.

 

[jgens]

Thanks Halls! I like the way that your proof works out much better. It looks a lot more like what I typically see.

 

[HallsofIvy]

On the other hand, your proof is much better for you than mine because it is yours!