- 22,820
- 14,860
It would be more accurate to say it would accelerate to the right due to the pull of the hanging mass. Of course, if the system starts at rest this will lead to it moving to the right.
The discussion focuses on analyzing a pulley system involving two masses, M and m, and calculating their accelerations (a_1 and a_2) and tensions (T_1 and T_2) in the strings. The participants clarify that for a massless and frictionless pulley, the tensions in the two segments of the string are equal, leading to the equation T_2 = 2T_1. The kinematic equations are utilized to derive the relationships between the forces acting on the masses, emphasizing the importance of accurately labeling forces in free body diagrams (FBDs). The conversation highlights common mistakes in understanding tension and acceleration in pulley systems.
PREREQUISITESStudents studying physics, particularly those focusing on mechanics, as well as educators and tutors looking to enhance their understanding of pulley systems and tension calculations.
I see. Ok, I wrote the sum of forces like this:Orodruin said:It would be more accurate to say it would accelerate to the right due to the pull of the hanging mass. Of course, if the system starts at rest this will lead to it moving to the right.
Sorry, I fixed it now. I'll try to be como careful. Now that it is fixed, is it correct?Orodruin said:No, you mixed up ##T_1## and ##T_2## from one step to the next. It may seem petty, but you have done this several times in this thread alone and you need to take better care with this or you will make mistakes that are relatively easy to avoid.
I guess I need to make both of them somehow equal. But I don't know where I can get that relation from. I guess that since there are two ##T_1## tensions on the right side of the middle pulley, then the second tension must be half ##T_1##?Orodruin said:Yes, but you need to find a relation between ##T_1## and ##T_2## to completely solve your system. Can you imagine where you can get such a relation from?
Yes, this is the FBD of the middle pulley. An ideal (massless pulley) has the force equation ##F = ma = 0 = T_2 - 2T_1##.Davidllerenav said:I guess I need to make both of them somehow equal. But I don't know where I can get that relation from. I guess that since there are two ##T_1## tensions on the right side of the middle pulley, then the second tension must be half ##T_1##?
I didn't knew that. So everytime I have a massless pulley I can assume that?Orodruin said:Yes, this is the FBD of the middle pulley. An ideal (massless pulley) has the force equation ##F = ma = 0 = T_2 - 2T_1##.
I think you need to double check the placement of your fingers on the keyboard ...Davidllerenav said:ecwrytumw
Sorry, I'm from my cellphone and didn't notice. I meant "everytime". So the forces cancel and the tensions also have that relationship?Orodruin said:I think you need to double check the placement of your fingers on the keyboard ...
But yes. Any time you have an ideal massless object, the forces acting on it need to cancel out.
The forces and torques cancel, so they may have a relationship, but not necessarily that one, exactly.Davidllerenav said:and the tensions also have that relationship?