Quantity of buffer solution needed to resist pH change

  • Thread starter Thread starter miniradman
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Buffer Change Ph
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the amount of buffer solution needed to maintain a pH of 7.0 in a swimming pool when faced with an increase in hydrogen ions. Participants express confusion over the appropriateness of chlorine as a buffer and suggest alternatives like sodium carbonate, which can help neutralize excess hydrogen ions. The need for clarity in the problem statement is emphasized, as the relationship between buffer capacity and pH change is complex. The stoichiometry of the reaction is noted, with a 2:1 ratio of carbonate to hydrogen ions, but the vagueness of the original question remains a significant barrier to finding a definitive answer. Overall, the discussion highlights the intricacies of buffer solutions and the importance of precise problem formulation in chemistry.
miniradman
Messages
191
Reaction score
0
Hello there,

I've got a question here which asks me to calculate how much (in mol/L) of buffer solution to add to 1 litre of solution to resist the change away from a pH of 7.0.

a) if there was an increase of 3.99367 x 10-8 of [H+] ions

Because the question is talking about pH in a swimming pool, I'm going to assmume that the buffer solution is chlorine.

I have no idea how to approach this?

any assitance will be appreciated :smile:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The way it is worded now it doesn't make sense and can't be solved. First of all, answer depends on the buffer identity (more precisely - on the pKa of the acid used), and I don't like the idea of chlorine being called "a buffer solution". Then, when you add acid to the buffered solution pH goes down - always. Magnitude of the change depends on the amount of acid and on the buffer capacity, so as long as you are not told by how much pH can change, you can't give any answer.
 
No :smile:

Well, I just assumed that Chlorine could react with the extra hyrogen ions in solution, by forming hydrochloric acid, thus, lowering the concentration of [H+] ions?
 
If anything, Cl2 reacts with water undergoing disproportionation and producing two acids, so it lowers the pH.
 
Heh... I didn't actually think about that.

How about something like Sodium Carbonate? Na2CO3

The sodiums will ionise in solution and what's left should be Carbonate, which will form Carbonic Acid? will that increase the pH?
 
Now you are just throwing compounds around. Yes, solution of sodium carbonate has pH above 7. Does it change the fact question as stated doesn't make sense?
 
Well I figured that the disociation of carbonic acid was what put in hydrogen ions in solution to begin with (in an earlier part of the same question), I just needed to do the reverse to push the pH back. Plus, Soda Ash is something used in Pools...

What I'm trying to figure out is: How much Sodium Carbonate do I need to neutralize 3.99367 x 10-8 of H+ ions

I know that Carbonic acid is di-protic
and the pka values are
pKa1 = 6.367
pKa2 = 10.329

Although I'm not sure what units they'd be in, and I'm pretty sure this is for the forward reaction
 
miniradman said:
How much Sodium Carbonate do I need to neutralize 3.99367 x 10-8 of H+ ions

Technically you can answer that they react 2:1 so you need 2x10-8M of carbonate. However, it doesn't work this way in the real solution, and the problem is still so vague there is no way to make it solvable.
 
why is it 2:1 ?
 
  • #10
Write reaction equation, the simplest and the most obvious one.
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
3K
Back
Top