Question about analyzing forces

  • Thread starter Thread starter jaja1990
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Forces
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a physics problem involving three objects and their interactions based on Newton's laws. The initial attempt to calculate the resultant forces is flawed, particularly regarding the application of Newton's third law, which states that for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. Specifically, the assertion that Object B pushes back on Object A with 30N contradicts this law, as the forces should be equal. The conclusion drawn from the calculations is therefore invalid, as it misrepresents the fundamental principles of force interactions. The problem's incorrect setup leads to confusion and misunderstanding of Newtonian mechanics.
jaja1990
Messages
27
Reaction score
0
In a try to test my knowledge of Newton's laws, I have posed the following question to myself.

Object A | Object B | Object C

Object A pushes on B by an amount of 60N

Object B pushes on A by an amount of 30N

Object C pushes on B by an amount of 10N

What is the resultant force of each object?

My attempt:

(The arrows indicate direction.)

Considering A and B:
A pushes on B by 60, so F_AonB = 60→
B reacts on A by 60, so F_BonA = 60←
B pushes on A by 30, so F_BonA becomes 90←
A reacts on B by 30, so F_AonB becomes 90→

Considering B and C:
C pushes on B by 10, so F_ConB = 10←
B reacts on C by 10, so F_BonC = 10→

Considering A and B (after considering C on B):
B pushes on A by 100, so F_BonA = 100←
A reacts on B by 100, so F_AonB = 100→

Conclusion:
A pushes 100→
B pushes 100← and 10→
C pushes 10←

I have been informed that the solution is invalid, and that the question itself is wrong. Can you tell me why the problem is wrong/invalid?
Someone tried to explain to me, but I didn't really understand.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
jaja1990 said:
I have been informed that the solution is invalid, and that the question itself is wrong. Can you tell me why the problem is wrong/invalid?
For one thing:
Object A pushes on B by an amount of 60N

Object B pushes on A by an amount of 30N
This contradicts Newton's 3rd law.

A and B will exert equal and opposite forces on each other.
 
Thanks for the simple answer.
 
Hello! Let's say I have a cavity resonant at 10 GHz with a Q factor of 1000. Given the Lorentzian shape of the cavity, I can also drive the cavity at, say 100 MHz. Of course the response will be very very weak, but non-zero given that the Loretzian shape never really reaches zero. I am trying to understand how are the magnetic and electric field distributions of the field at 100 MHz relative to the ones at 10 GHz? In particular, if inside the cavity I have some structure, such as 2 plates...
Back
Top