# Question regarding an integral

Tags:
1. Jul 4, 2016

### Paumi

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
I've got an equation which I need to integrate. However, integrating it and checking with the solutions, I get two different results. I get the same result as using wolfram alpha, but a different result from the book.
If I differentiate both results, I get back to the orginal equation, so I don't know why they are different.

2. Relevant equations
Equation which I need to Integrate by seperation of variables: $$\frac{d\dot{x}^2}{dx} = \frac{2l^4 a^2 x}{(12x^2+l^2)^2}$$

Result from Book: $$\dot{x}^2 = \frac{ l^2 a^2 x^2}{12x^2+l^2}$$
Result from Wolfram-Alpha: $$\dot{x}^2 = -\frac{(a^2 l^4)}{(12 (l^2+12 x^2))}$$

3. The attempt at a solution
If I differentiate both, I'll both get the same equation back which I integrated, I just don't understand why thats the case, since it doesn't look like they differ by a additive constant.

Last edited: Jul 4, 2016
2. Jul 4, 2016

### Ray Vickson

(1) Please clarify: does
$$\frac{d\dot{x}^2}{dx}$$
mean
$$\frac{d( d(x^2)/dt)}{dx}$$
or
$$\frac{d (dx/dt)^2}{dx}$$
or
$$\left( \frac{d (dx / dt) }{dx}\right)^2 \:?$$
(2) Show the steps you used in obtaining your answer.

Last edited: Jul 4, 2016
3. Jul 4, 2016

### Paumi

It means :$$\frac{d\dot{x}^2}{dx} = \frac{d}{dx}\left(\frac{dx}{dt}\right)^2$$

For the result from the book there where no steps shown.

For my result: $$\frac{d\dot{x}^2}{dx} = \frac{2l^4a^2x}{(12x^2+l^2)^2} \Longrightarrow \int d\dot{x}^2 =2 l^4a^2\int \frac{x}{(12x^2+l^2)^2} dx$$

Apply Substitution: $$u = 12x^2 +l^2 \,\,\,\,\,\,\, \frac{du}{dx} = 24x \Rightarrow dx = \frac{1}{24x}du$$

$$\int d\dot{x}^2 = \dot{x}^2 = l^4a^2 \int\frac{1}{24u^2}du = -2l^4a^2\frac{1}{24} u^{-1} + c = -l^4a^2\frac{1}{12}\frac{1}{12x^2+l^2}+c$$

There were some starting conditions which would lead to c = 0

4. Jul 4, 2016

### Ray Vickson

You are correct, and the book is wrong (as can be checked by differentiating the answer---a step you should always perform).

5. Jul 4, 2016

### Paumi

I did perform that step as I wrote in my post and I get the same equation, though my derivative might be wrong.

Let's differentiate the solution from the book with respect to x:

$$\frac{d}{dx}\left(\frac{l^2a^2x^2}{12x^2+l^2}\right) = l^2a^2 \frac{d}{dx}\left(\frac{x^2}{12x^2+l^2}\right)$$

Using the quotient rule I get: $$l^2a^2 \frac{2x(12x^2+l^2)-24x^3}{(12x^2+l^2)^2} = l^2a^2\frac{24x^3-2xl^2-24x^3}{(12x^2+l^2)^2} = \frac{2l^4a^2x}{(12x^2+l^2)^2}$$ which is the same as the orginal function which I integrated

6. Jul 4, 2016

### vela

Staff Emeritus
Even though it doesn't look like it at first glance, the two results do, in fact, differ by just an additive constant:
$$\frac{a^2l^2}{12}-\frac{a^2l^4}{12(12x^2+l^2)} = \frac{l^2a^2x^2}{12x^2+l^2}$$

7. Jul 4, 2016

### Ray Vickson

Oops, my mistake in #4.

8. Jul 5, 2016

### Paumi

Ah I see, thanks very much both of you!

Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Have something to add?
Draft saved Draft deleted