Queston on workng out Stress in a Beam

  • Thread starter Thread starter a5hl3yi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Beam Stress
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating stress and tensile load in a bar subjected to an axial tensile load, with a given strain measurement and Young's modulus. Participants are exploring the relationships between stress, strain, and tensile load, while clarifying the context of the problem.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the correct application of formulas related to stress and strain, questioning the appropriateness of a bending formula for an axial load scenario. There are attempts to clarify the relationship between stress, strain, and Young's modulus, with some participants expressing confusion over the definitions and calculations involved.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with participants providing insights and corrections to each other's reasoning. Some have made calculations for stress and are seeking guidance on how to determine the tensile load from stress. There is a collaborative effort to clarify concepts and ensure understanding of the relationships involved.

Contextual Notes

Participants are working with limited information and are navigating through assumptions about the problem setup, including the need for an area to calculate tensile load from stress. There is also mention of a textbook that may not be helpful, indicating a search for better resources.

a5hl3yi
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
Question:

A bar has a unknown tensil load. A gauge shows that the strain is 400x10^-5.
Work out the Stress & Tensile Load (there should be an image attached of the beam. Also the Youngs modulus is given as 180GNm^-2, but I believe this is for a later part of the question)

Relevant equations:

The question does not come with any equations, but I believe I have to use the following.
M/I= σ/Y = E/R. However, I never got the hang of using this formula, and so I'm having some trouble.

The attempt at a solution:

So far all of my attempts have come up trumps, mainly because I'm not sure how to use the formula, or if its the correct one to use. Any help is apriciated.

Thanx :D
 

Attachments

  • Untitled.png
    Untitled.png
    745 bytes · Views: 417
Physics news on Phys.org
This is not a bending problem...the bar is under an axially applied tensile load, T, causing tensile stresses T/A. What is the relationship between stress and strain using Young's modulus and a linear curve?
 
a5hl3yi said:
Relevant equations:
The question does not come with any equations, but I believe I have to use the following.
M/I= σ/Y = E/R. However, I never got the hang of using this formula, and so I'm having some trouble.

Well that formula is for bending, it doesn't look like you have bending taking place at the moment.

a5hl3yi said:
Question:

A bar has a unknown tensil load. A gauge shows that the strain is 400x10-5.
Work out the Stress & Tensile Load (there should be an image attached of the beam. Also the Youngs modulus is given as 180GNm-2, but I believe this is for a later part of the question)

If you know the strain, you can get the stress from using the Young's Modulus. Then the force using the definition of stress.
 
First of all, thnx, and in my question the strain measured by the gauge is an axial strain.

Secondly. Soo I need to work out the strain first. Ok. This is a formula that that I found on a different thread asking a similar queston: σ = Eε (Strain = Young's modulus x Axial strain)? Is this the way that I get the Strain? And then after the stress?

Thanx
 
a5hl3yi said:
First of all, thnx, and in my question the strain measured by the gauge is an axial strain.

Secondly. Soo I need to work out the strain first. the strain is given[/color] Ok. This is a formula that that I found on a different thread asking a similar queston: σ = Eε ([strike]Strain[/strike]Stress[/color] = Young's modulus x Axial strain)? [strike]Is this the way that I get the Strain?[/strike]this is the way you get the stress[/color][strike] And then after the stress?[/strike]

Thanx
See corrections in red[/color] above
 
Thanx, don't know what I was going on about then. The more I go into it, the more it all seems the same to me. Ill use this n put what i get on
 
Ok, so I'v worked out the stress in the beam :

Stress = Young's modulus x Axial strain
Stress = 400x10^-5 x 180
Stress = 0.004 x 180 = 0.72 (dont know what units to put it in though :S)

Now I have to work out the tensile load that is applyed. Is there a formula for doing this, because rock.freak667 says to use the deffinition of stress but I am not sure what that is.

Thanx for all your help :)
 
a5hl3yi said:
Ok, so I'v worked out the stress in the beam :

Stress = Young's modulus x Axial strain
Stress = 400x10^-5 x 180
Stress = 0.004 x 180 = 0.72 (dont know what units to put it in though :S)

Now I have to work out the tensile load that is applyed. Is there a formula for doing this, because rock.freak667 says to use the deffinition of stress but I am not sure what that is.

Thanx for all your help :)

Stress is measured in N/m2, which is a force/area :wink:
 
a5hl3yi said:
Stress = Young's modulus x Axial strain
Stress = 400x10^-5 x 180
Stress = 0.004 x 180 = 0.72 (dont know what units to put it in though :S)
Be careful with your math. Strain is a dimensionless quantity given as 400(10^-5). Young's modulus is given as 180 GN/m^2, which is 180(10^9) N/m^2.
 
  • #10
Right. thanx. So this is what I have now:

(400x10^-5) x (180x10^9) = 720000000N/m^2

Now this is correct I hope, how do I go about workng out the magnitude of the tenslile load? (dont really want to keep asking loads of questions, sounds like I'm just leaching but I'm soo stuck :S)
 
  • #11
That stress looks a bit height, but you'll need to multiply by the area where the force is acting to get the force.
 
  • #12
Great thanks the both of you, I think I understand it now :D

Just wondering, is there a textbook or something along those lines that ether of you would recommend that covers this kind of physics? I spent £35 on one that a tutor recomended and its not very good at all :)

Thanx

(also I am assuming that when you say "force is acting" its the 720000000N/m^2 answer I gave and the "get the force" force is the tensile load)
 
  • #13
a5hl3yi said:
Great thanks the both of you, I think I understand it now :D

Just wondering, is there a textbook or something along those lines that ether of you would recommend that covers this kind of physics? I spent £35 on one that a tutor recomended and its not very good at all :)

Thanx

I am not sure about books, but if you know what topic your question covers,you can try searching that topic on Google. If not, post on PF and we'll help if we can.

a5hl3yi said:
(also I am assuming that when you say "force is acting" its the 720000000N/m^2 answer I gave and the "get the force" force is the tensile load)

My words did sound quite confusing.

Your stress= Force/Area so that the tensile load is the force. So multiply by the area.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
8K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
8K