Re-taking a failed semester in collage and dropping the previous recorded one?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hypo
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Semester
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the challenges faced by a university student who is considering dropping a semester due to poor academic performance following the death of a close relative. Participants explore the implications of university policies regarding term cancellation and the emotional impact of personal loss on academic success.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Meta-discussion

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes the emotional turmoil experienced by their friend after the death of a relative, which significantly affected his academic performance.
  • Another participant suggests that universities generally recognize a death in the family as a valid reason for poor academic performance, but emphasizes that policies may vary by institution.
  • Some participants argue against the idea of transferring to a different university, citing the additional stress of adjusting to a new environment as potentially detrimental.
  • There is a consensus among some participants that the student should communicate openly with his advisor and request a second chance.
  • Concerns are raised about the possibility of the university refusing the request to drop the semester, despite the strong emotional circumstances presented.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that a death in the family is a significant reason for academic struggles, but there is no consensus on the likelihood of the university granting the request to drop the semester. Multiple views on the best course of action remain, particularly regarding whether to stay at the current university or transfer.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the variability of university policies and the subjective nature of emotional distress, which may affect the outcome of the student's request.

Who May Find This Useful

Students facing similar emotional challenges, academic advisors, and individuals interested in university policies regarding academic performance and personal circumstances.

Hypo
Messages
58
Reaction score
0
Hallo everyone!Ok, my best friend and I are in the same university together. We know each other for 7 years...

The guy is smart and he pretty much can get a very good gpa 3.5 - 4/4. Problem is! His a undeclared undergrad majoring in Electrical Engineering.

So he just passed his freshmen year.
Unfortunately with bad scores, in his first semester(fall) he didn't really get used to the lifestyle overseas (were both foreign in the states) and to the collage lifestyle. He then said I'll push myself in the next semester(spring)!

Ok, he started off all good... Getting all good grades and such. Until he heard the news of a dear relative whom passed away... That news came in the beginning of the second month of the second semester(spring).

That really effected him I mean I know the guy as a brother never seen him like that...
He was crying all day and night for days and days! I was with him in the same classes and he skipped a lot of them! He was really in a bad emotional state of mind...

The guy change dramatically he didn't care about anything! He traveled back to his home and stayed with his family for a weekend then came back still depressed as hell! I don't blame him honestly. His relative was really someone important in his life that he loved so so so much. Man I almost cried listening to his father telling me the awful news(He was too afraid to even tell his son! Worrying a lot about his reaction).

So at the end of the semester he started to get better... He did go to his classes but didn't really give it his "all". Do you blame him? I really felt bad for the guy...

So we met up after a few months and his ok now.

Now here's his problem that I am worried about too... His advisor said: "That during the last semester's spring & fall you got terrible grades(below 2.00) and that would effect you're chances of getting in you're major and getting a total good GPA in the long run."

So his options are: Dropping the semester because of the bad grades and his grandmother's death...
Or leaving the university and re-applying for other universities... Because of his grades... And starts all over again.

His advisor: "Said we can take the term cancelation/withdrawal/drop as an option but you have to have a good reason for it". Since my buddy already used the repeat/delete option that allows him to re-take the classes he failed in the first semester again in the second semester with the intentions of getting a better grade.

Death of a relative he loved so much is strong reason right?
So my friend has to meet up with his advisor and take the option and give him the reason why the "council" should agree.

I hate when the "council" are envolved I feel like they would brutally say NO! But, why should they? The guy wants to repeat or drop or cancel his term... He has no other option since he used most of them for the "spring semester".

What do you guys think would happen? Would they agree and let him repeat the term and start over? Or should he really start considering other universities...

Man I've been thinking about a lot! Could anyone give me the chances for my friend here?

Since were in a state university I don't recall them being very strict so I honestly I think he would get that chance, but he really needs to show them his persistent about it! I understand he should have informed them earlier but he was in a very bad emotional state that bringging up the topic would break him again... He tried to finish that semester(spring) but really you can't expect someone to do well on his priorities when someone very very dear to his heart passes away without seeing them and being thousands and thousands of miles away... Not even going to the funeral... That really really bad for him.

What do you all think? Do universities take "death" as a major excuse and would allow him to re-take his term? I mean they lose nothing... Why should't they?

Thanks!

Hyp,
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org


Each university will have its policies and protocols - we really can't say what is right or not, and there's no way to tell what your specific school will do about this situation. But in general, yes - a death in the family is a recognized reason for poor performance.

In my opinion: he should not try to start over at a different school. He's already been through a very tough time. Moving and re-adjusting to a new place will only add to his stress. I know it seems like a "fresh start" would be as good idea, but I think going to where no one knows him would be much harder than he thinks.

He should talk openly and honestly to his advisor. He should ask for a second chance.

Best of luck to him, whatever he decides!
 


lisab said:
Each university will have its policies and protocols - we really can't say what is right or not, and there's no way to tell what your specific school will do about this situation. But in general, yes - a death in the family is a recognized reason for poor performance.

In my opinion: he should not try to start over at a different school. He's already been through a very tough time. Moving and re-adjusting to a new place will only add to his stress. I know it seems like a "fresh start" would be as good idea, but I think going to where no one knows him would be much harder than he thinks.

He should talk openly and honestly to his advisor. He should ask for a second chance.

Best of luck to him, whatever he decides!

Thank you so much! The thing is, he has so many doubts about this topic and thinks he won't be given another chance! I told him "death" isn't something that's common! Its a very very very! Serious issue and also considered as a STRONG EXCUSE. I mean were human at the end of the day so they'll understand "hopefully".

Thanks again!
 


lisab said:
Each university will have its policies and protocols - we really can't say what is right or not, and there's no way to tell what your specific school will do about this situation. But in general, yes - a death in the family is a recognized reason for poor performance.

In my opinion: he should not try to start over at a different school. He's already been through a very tough time. Moving and re-adjusting to a new place will only add to his stress. I know it seems like a "fresh start" would be as good idea, but I think going to where no one knows him would be much harder than he thinks.

He should talk openly and honestly to his advisor. He should ask for a second chance.

Best of luck to him, whatever he decides!


One thing though... Do you think there is a chance they would refuse? I mean he has a very strong excuse. If you have any point that could possibly effect his chances of getting that old term dropped could you share it? Thanks.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • · Replies 32 ·
2
Replies
32
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
84K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 25 ·
Replies
25
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 45 ·
2
Replies
45
Views
9K