MHB Real Solutions for Equation: a-1

  • Thread starter Thread starter anemone
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The equation $\sqrt{a-1}+\dfrac{\sqrt{a-1}}{a^2}+\dfrac{a^2}{a-1}=\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{a-1}}+\dfrac{a-1}{a^2}+\dfrac{a^2}{\sqrt{a-1}}$ is solved by substituting $b = \sqrt{a-1}$, leading to the equation $b + \dfrac{b}{a^2} + \dfrac{a^2}{b^2} = \dfrac{1}{b} + \dfrac{b^2}{a^2} + \dfrac{a^2}{b}$. After manipulating and factoring, the critical factors are identified as $(b+a)(b-a)(a^2-b)(b-1) = 0$. The only viable solution occurs when $b=1$, which corresponds to $a=2$. Thus, the only real solution to the original equation is $a=2$.
anemone
Gold Member
MHB
POTW Director
Messages
3,851
Reaction score
115
Find all real solutions of the equation $\sqrt{a-1}+\dfrac{\sqrt{a-1}}{a^2}+\dfrac{a^2}{a-1}=\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{a-1}}+\dfrac{a-1}{a^2}+\dfrac{a^2}{\sqrt{a-1}}$.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
[sp]Let $b = \sqrt{a-1}$. Then $b + \dfrac b{a^2} + \dfrac{a^2}{b^2} = \dfrac1b + \dfrac{b^2}{a^2} + \dfrac{a^2}b.$ Also, $b^2 = a-1$, $b>0$ (assuming that we take the square root to be the positive one) and $a>1$ (so that the square root is defined). Multiply through by $a^2b^2$ to get $$a^2b^3 + b^3 + a^4 = a^2b + b^4 + a^4b.$$ Write this as $$b(b^2-a^2) + a^2b(b^2-a^2) - (b^4 - a^4) = 0.$$ That factorises as $(b^2-a^2)(b + a^2b - a^2-b^2) = 0$, and then factorises further as $(b+a)(b-a)(a^2-b)(b-1) = 0.$ The first factor cannot be zero because $a$ and $b$ are both positive. If $b=a$ then the equation $b^2=a-1$ becomes $a^2-a+1=0$, which has no real solutions. Similarly if $b=a^2$ then we get the equation $a^4-a+1=0$, which also has no real solutions. Finally, if $b=1$ then $a=2$, and that is the only solution to the problem.[/sp]
 
Let:

$$0<u^2=a-1$$

After making the substitution and multiplying the result by $$u^2\left(u^2+1 \right)^2$$ we obtain:

$$u^3\left(u^2+1 \right)^2+u^3+\left(u^2+1 \right)^4=u\left(u^2+1 \right)^2+u^4+u\left(u^2+1 \right)^4$$

which can be arranged and factored as:

$$(u-1)\left(u^6+2u^4+2u^2-u+1 \right)$$

Regarding the sextic factor (let's call if $f$), let's look at its derivative:

$$f'(u)=6u^5+8u^3+4u-1$$

Descartes' Rule of Signs tells us there is at most 1 positive real root. We should observe that it will be close to zero. Use of a numeric root finding technique puts this root at about:

$$u\approx0.22602207985644908028$$

We can see that the second derivative will be positive for all real $u$, hence this critical value is at a global minimum. We then find:

$$f_{\min}\approx f(0.22602207985644908028)\approx0.881502759171198736472582>0$$

Hence, we may conclude $f$ has no real roots, and so $u=1$ is the only root, which means:

$$a-1=1^2\implies a=2$$

is the only real root of the given equation.
 
Opalg said:
[sp]Let $b = \sqrt{a-1}$. Then $b + \dfrac b{a^2} + \dfrac{a^2}{b^2} = \dfrac1b + \dfrac{b^2}{a^2} + \dfrac{a^2}b.$ Also, $b^2 = a-1$, $b>0$ (assuming that we take the square root to be the positive one) and $a>1$ (so that the square root is defined). Multiply through by $a^2b^2$ to get $$a^2b^3 + b^3 + a^4 = a^2b + b^4 + a^4b.$$ Write this as $$b(b^2-a^2) + a^2b(b^2-a^2) - (b^4 - a^4) = 0.$$ That factorises as $(b^2-a^2)(b + a^2b - a^2-b^2) = 0$, and then factorises further as $(b+a)(b-a)(a^2-b)(b-1) = 0.$ The first factor cannot be zero because $a$ and $b$ are both positive. If $b=a$ then the equation $b^2=a-1$ becomes $a^2-a+1=0$, which has no real solutions. Similarly if $b=a^2$ then we get the equation $a^4-a+1=0$, which also has no real solutions. Finally, if $b=1$ then $a=2$, and that is the only solution to the problem.[/sp]

Thank you Opalg for participating! I initially thought to share the solution of other that I considered to be a brilliant way to attack this problem but now I see there is no need to do so...:o

MarkFL said:
Let:

$$0<u^2=a-1$$

After making the substitution and multiplying the result by $$u^2\left(u^2+1 \right)^2$$ we obtain:

$$u^3\left(u^2+1 \right)^2+u^3+\left(u^2+1 \right)^4=u\left(u^2+1 \right)^2+u^4+u\left(u^2+1 \right)^4$$

which can be arranged and factored as:

$$(u-1)\left(u^6+2u^4+2u^2-u+1 \right)$$

Regarding the sextic factor (let's call if $f$), let's look at its derivative:

$$f'(u)=6u^5+8u^3+4u-1$$

Descartes' Rule of Signs tells us there is at most 1 positive real root. We should observe that it will be close to zero. Use of a numeric root finding technique puts this root at about:

$$u\approx0.22602207985644908028$$

We can see that the second derivative will be positive for all real $u$, hence this critical value is at a global minimum. We then find:

$$f_{\min}\approx f(0.22602207985644908028)\approx0.881502759171198736472582>0$$

Hence, we may conclude $f$ has no real roots, and so $u=1$ is the only root, which means:

$$a-1=1^2\implies a=2$$

is the only real root of the given equation.

Hey MarkFL, my dearest and sweetest admin, I like your method so much as well! I think this is another great method to crack this problem! Thanks for your solution!(Sun)
 
Hey MarkFL,:) I see there is another way to prove the second factor in $$(u-1)\left(u^6+2u^4+2u^2-u+1 \right)$$ so that it is always greater than zero:

$$(u-1)\left(u^6+2u^4+2u^2-u+1 \right)=0$$

Regarding the sextic factor (let's call if $f$),

$\begin{align*}u^6+2u^4+2u^2-u+1&=(u^6+2u^4+u^2)+(u^2-u+1)\\&=u^2(u^4+2u^2+1)+\left(u-\dfrac{1}{2} \right)^2+1-\dfrac{1}{4}\\&=u^2(u^2+1)^2+\left(u-\dfrac{1}{2} \right)^2+\dfrac{3}{4}\\& >0 \end{align*}$

Hence, we may conclude $f$ has no real roots, and so $u=1$ is the only root, which means:

$$a-1=1^2\implies a=2$$

is the only real root of the given equation.
 
anemone said:
Hey MarkFL,:) I see there is another way to prove the second factor in $$(u-1)\left(u^6+2u^4+2u^2-u+1 \right)$$ so that it is always greater than zero:

$$(u-1)\left(u^6+2u^4+2u^2-u+1 \right)=0$$

Regarding the sextic factor (let's call if $f$),

$\begin{align*}u^6+2u^4+2u^2-u+1&=(u^6+2u^4+u^2)+(u^2-u+1)\\&=u^2(u^4+2u^2+1)+\left(u-\dfrac{1}{2} \right)^2+1-\dfrac{1}{4}\\&=u^2(u^2+1)^2+\left(u-\dfrac{1}{2} \right)^2+\dfrac{3}{4}\\& >0 \end{align*}$

Hence, we may conclude $f$ has no real roots, and so $u=1$ is the only root, which means:

$$a-1=1^2\implies a=2$$

is the only real root of the given equation.

Quite clever, and alleviates the need for any root analyses. (Yes)
 
Suppose ,instead of the usual x,y coordinate system with an I basis vector along the x -axis and a corresponding j basis vector along the y-axis we instead have a different pair of basis vectors ,call them e and f along their respective axes. I have seen that this is an important subject in maths My question is what physical applications does such a model apply to? I am asking here because I have devoted quite a lot of time in the past to understanding convectors and the dual...
Insights auto threads is broken atm, so I'm manually creating these for new Insight articles. In Dirac’s Principles of Quantum Mechanics published in 1930 he introduced a “convenient notation” he referred to as a “delta function” which he treated as a continuum analog to the discrete Kronecker delta. The Kronecker delta is simply the indexed components of the identity operator in matrix algebra Source: https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/what-exactly-is-diracs-delta-function/ by...

Similar threads

Back
Top