Resistance Voltage (V) Proportional to Current (I): Why R=V/I?

  • Thread starter Thread starter sreerajt
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Resistance
AI Thread Summary
Voltage (V) is directly proportional to current (I), expressed as V = R * I, where R is resistance. The discussion clarifies that while one could express current as proportional to voltage (I ∝ V), it would require a different constant, known as conductance (G), which is defined as G = I/V. Resistance (R) is a conventionally defined quantity, and its definition is not arbitrary but based on established electrical principles. The units of conductance are Siemens, previously referred to as mhos. The distinction between resistance and conductance highlights their inverse relationship, with resistance indicating how difficult it is for current to flow.
sreerajt
Messages
39
Reaction score
1
Voltage(V) is proportional to current(I). And so V=(a constant)*I. That constant is known as resistance(R), where R=V/I. Why can't we write that I proportional to V and then write R=I/V??
 
Physics news on Phys.org
sreerajt said:
Why can't we write that I proportional to V and then write R=I/V??

We can. We simply have to give this proportionality constant a different name and symbol so that we don't confuse people. :smile:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_conductance
 
sreerajt said:
Voltage(V) is proportional to current(I). And so V=(a constant)*I. That constant is known as resistance(R), where R=V/I. Why can't we write that I proportional to V and then write R=I/V??
We write G=I/V
and the units of G used to be known as mhos (that's Ohms spelled backwards) with symbol an upsidedown Ω (omega).

Nowadays, the units have been renamed an uninteresting "siemens". :frown:
 
Because that is not the reality? I know VR != I. If that were the case, current would increase with resistance. Which completely disagrees with our current definition of resistance!

EDIT:
Oh, I misinterpreted your post. Well, yes, of course you could. But R would be a different quantity, as the right side of the equation implies.
 
Last edited:
Could you please make it clear?
 
Resistance (R) is DEFINED to be what it is. There is no "reason" for it, it is just a convention.

And again, the quantity I/V already has a name of its own: conductance (G), which has the units of Siemens.
 
I think you means 1/R.

Remember: R is 'how hard'
and G is 'how easy'.
 
Thanks f95toli.. i think your answer is quite satisfying for me...
 
Back
Top