Resonance frequency of heating coil

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around finding the resonance frequency of a heating coil used in an induction heater, specifically without the use of a frequency generator. Participants explore various methods and considerations related to measuring resonance frequency, the implications of frequency on the operation of the heating coil, and the technical challenges faced in the design and testing process.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Experimental/applied

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses frustration with inconsistent frequency measurements (17.44 MHz to 35.71 MHz) while attempting to find the resonance frequency of their heating coil using an oscilloscope and a 9-volt source.
  • Another participant questions the relevance of resonance frequency in the context of the heating element's AC power, suggesting that the typical frequency is 60 Hz.
  • A participant clarifies that they are building an induction heater with a power source of 100 kW and 30 kHz, emphasizing the importance of achieving resonance within the 30-40 kHz range to avoid damaging IGBTs.
  • Concerns are raised about the safety and complexity of constructing a 100 kW inductive heating source, with suggestions that the participant should have a solid understanding of electrical engineering principles.
  • Discussion includes the need for impedance matching between the generator and the heating coil, with emphasis on the potential risks of incorrect matching leading to generator damage.
  • Another participant shares an example of a similar application involving an ink drying heater operating at 27 MHz, suggesting the incorporation of the heating coil into the oscillator circuit for better frequency control.
  • There is mention of dielectric heating of plastics and the operational frequency ranges for different heating applications, highlighting the differences in power requirements and frequency usage.
  • Participants note the necessity of a tuning capacitor to achieve resonance and discuss the role of coil design (number of turns and size) in determining inductance.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying opinions on the appropriate frequency ranges for different heating applications and the methods for measuring resonance frequency. There is no consensus on the best approach to test the heating coil without a generator, and multiple competing views remain regarding the technical requirements and safety considerations of constructing a high-power induction heater.

Contextual Notes

Participants reference various technical aspects such as impedance matching, tuning networks, and the importance of safety in high-power applications. Some assumptions about the participant's setup and knowledge level are not explicitly stated, leading to potential gaps in understanding the full context of the discussion.

CaptainRaker
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
I am doing R&D and have been hit by a problem. I want to find the resonnce frequency to my heating coil without having to hook it up to the rest of my oven. I fall into the problem because I don't have the stray funds to buy a frequency generator. I heard that with capacitors and an oscilloscope that I could find my frequency.

I have tried to use an oscilloscope, the coil, and a 9volt. My results are varying from17.44MHZ to 35.71MHZ. The non-consistency is what is frustrating me.

If anyone knows the backdoor way to test without a generator, the information would be greatly appreciated.

-Raker
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF.
What frequency will the heating element AC power be ? 60Hz ?
What is the relevance of heating coil resonance ?
Are you building an induction heater ?
 
Thanks for the welcome, I'm glad to have found this site.

An induction heater is exactly what I am making. My power source is 100kW and 30kHZ.

a major reason I am having problems is because my machine is built for multiple coils (round stock, flat stock etc etc etc) I am in no way a professional at any of this. I have notes from a dead guy, and good work ethic to carry me through all of this.
The relevance is for my IGBTs. I'm looking for about 30-40kHZ resonance. If my numbers are below or above that they blow out.

I just want to be able to check my frequency without having to hook up each coil I make to the machine. It's a real butt pain.
 
Years ago, amateur constructors used all sorts of ruses to measure quantities because test equipment was very expensive. These days you can use computers to drive cheap waveform synthesisers and DMMs to measure components and Frequency.

But this is not a typical home constructor project.
If you really are considering constructing a 100kW inductive heating source then I suggest you need to get well up to speed with more than just the basics of EE. 100kW of any sort of power (steam engine or internal combustion, as well as electrical) is a serious amount of Power. (Think of your modern saloon car, and the engineering involved in that) What would be your electrical supply, for a start?

I may have read this wrong, of course. If you are only wanting to test some existing components and check they are within-spec, then a DMM and signal generator card could show you the resonance peak. But what will you do if the resonance peak is at the right frequency? But, if you want to do this all safely, then you should not even be considering doing your own assembly of such meaty stuff.
 
The output impedance of the generator needs to be matched to the heating coil. If that match is incorrect, then energy will be reflected back from the load to the generator. That may easily destroy the generator.

I believe you must adjust the coupling network of the heating coil to the generator output lines at the operating frequency of the generator. There should be a low power mode for use while initially adjusting the match. There should also be some simple way to monitor the reflected power or SWR.

The self-resonant frequency of the coil will not be important without the coupling between the generator and coil in circuit. It will be very hard to make a coil without a tuning capacitor that will radiate 100 kW at 30 kHz. At 30 MHz it might be possible.

Does the heater coil have an adjustable tuning network connected?
Or is the only adjustment on the generator?

What is the make and model of the generator so I can look up the output specifications?
 
CaptainRaker said:
I am doing R&D and have been hit by a problem. I want to find the resonnce frequency to my heating coil without having to hook it up to the rest of my oven. I fall into the problem because I don't have the stray funds to buy a frequency generator. I heard that with capacitors and an oscilloscope that I could find my frequency.

I have tried to use an oscilloscope, the coil, and a 9volt. My results are varying from17.44MHZ to 35.71MHZ. The non-consistency is what is frustrating me.

If anyone knows the backdoor way to test without a generator, the information would be greatly appreciated.

-Raker

CaptainRaker said:
Thanks for the welcome, I'm glad to have found this site.

An induction heater is exactly what I am making. My power source is 100kW and 30kHZ.

a major reason I am having problems is because my machine is built for multiple coils (round stock, flat stock etc etc etc) I am in no way a professional at any of this. I have notes from a dead guy, and good work ethic to carry me through all of this.
The relevance is for my IGBTs. I'm looking for about 30-40kHZ resonance. If my numbers are below or above that they blow out.

I just want to be able to check my frequency without having to hook up each coil I make to the machine. It's a real butt pain.

Welcome to the PF.

30MHz or 30kHz? Makes a big difference.
 
I watched the installation of an ink drying heater in a printing plant. The paper was printed with water based ink and had to be dried before it was wound up in a roll. The dryer operated at 5kW and 27MHz. The machine used a tuned plate, tuned grid, tube oscillator and the web of paper passed between the plates of the capacitor of the oscillator. Since the capacitor was part of the oscillator, the frequency was always at the resonant frequency of the oscillator.

Would it be possible for you to have an RF engineer incorporate your induction heating coil as part of oscillator in the generator?
 
Dielectric heating of plastics would use maybe 1 to 20 kW on the ISM bands at 27 MHz or 40 MHz.
Induction heating of metals would use 30 kHz. Skin effect, time and thermal conduction set treatment depth.

IGBTs would be hard pressed to work efficiently above 1 MHz.
Like switching inverters, a bridge of IGBTs would operate best at about 30 kHz.

The number of turns and size of the heating coil sets the inductance. But the load would need a tuning capacitor.
There must be a high voltage capacitor somewhere that brings it close to resonance.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 51 ·
2
Replies
51
Views
5K
  • · Replies 42 ·
2
Replies
42
Views
6K
  • · Replies 37 ·
2
Replies
37
Views
7K
  • · Replies 51 ·
2
Replies
51
Views
5K