Sampling With The Normal Distribution

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around determining the smallest sample size n for a random sample from a normal distribution such that the probability of the sample mean deviating from the population mean by more than 0.5σ exceeds 0.05. Participants derive that the distribution of the sample mean, denoted as \bar{X}, follows a normal distribution with variance σ²/n. Through calculations involving the error function, it is established that the minimum value of n must be greater than 16 to satisfy the probability condition. The discussion also includes an alternative method that confirms this finding. Ultimately, the consensus is that the minimum sample size required is 16.
ƒ(x) → ∞
Messages
24
Reaction score
0
I have been puzzling over this problem for about a week now and cannot find the answer. In my opinion it is very theoretical, but I know I ma not the best mathematician on here so maybe someone else could look at this.

The mean of a random sample of n observations drawn from an N(\mu,\sigma2) distribution is denoted by \bar{X}.

Given that p(|\bar{X}-\mu|>0.5\sigma)>0.05

(a) Find the smallest vaule of n
(b) With this value of n find p(\bar{X}<\mu+0.1\sigma)

Thank you.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You need to derive the probability distribution for \bar{X}. This is possible, since it is a sum of n quantities for which you know the distribution. Tthe distribution for \bar{X} willl depend on n. You can then calculate the probability that |\bar{X}-\mu|&gt;\sigma/2 in the ordinary way. This gives you an inequality for n. Then find the smallest n that satisfies the inequality.

When you know n, you have completely specified the distribution for \bar{X}, and you can do part (b).

So the first step is to find the distribution of a sum of quantities, expressed in terms of their individual distributions.

Torquil
 
Do you mean \bar{X}~N(\mu,\sigma2/n)

Where do I go from here if I knew the probability then I think I could manage.
 
Cool, that's the same thing I got. From that you can write the explicit gaussian probability density for e.g. u:=\bar{X}-\mu. Call it e.g. \rho_n(u). It will depend on n of course. It will simply the usual normalied gaussian centered around u=0, with variance \sigma^2/n I think.

Then the probability P(n) that |u|&gt;\sigma/2 is given as a integral that you can solve using the error function:

<br /> P(n) = \int_{-\infty}^{-\sigma/2} \rho_n(u)du + \int^{\infty}_{\sigma/2} \rho_n(u)du<br />

Then find the smallest n such that P(n)>0.05. Then fix this value of n, and just do another simple integral to get the answer to part b.

Agree?

Torquil
 
Got it now. It comes out n>16 so at least n=16. I used a different method which I will post now.
 
p(\mu-(\sigma/2)\leq\overline{X}\leq\mu+(\sigma/2)>0.95

=p(-\sqrt{n}/2\leqz\leq\sqrt{n}/2)>0.95

=\phi(\sqrt{n}/2) - (1-(\phi(\sqrt{n}/2))>0.95

=2\phi(\sqrt{n}/2)-1>0.95

=2\phi(\sqrt{n}/2)>1.95

=\phi(\sqrt{n}/2)>0.975

=(\sqrt{n}/2)>(\phi-1)(0.975)

=(\sqrt{n}/2>1.96

=\sqrt{n}>3.92

=n>15.3664

But n is integer
Therefore n>16

The minimum value of n is therefore 16
 
I was reading documentation about the soundness and completeness of logic formal systems. Consider the following $$\vdash_S \phi$$ where ##S## is the proof-system making part the formal system and ##\phi## is a wff (well formed formula) of the formal language. Note the blank on left of the turnstile symbol ##\vdash_S##, as far as I can tell it actually represents the empty set. So what does it mean ? I guess it actually means ##\phi## is a theorem of the formal system, i.e. there is a...
Back
Top