Saturday Giggle --- Flat Earth Society
- Thread starter davenn
- Start date
-
- Tags
- Earth Flat Flat earth
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
21 replies · 4K views
Discussion
Earth sciences news on Phys.org
Mentor
- 15,788
- 10,671
Ahh so they all live on the edge of the world.
Science Advisor
- 3,766
- 2,215
Long ago, I briefly knew a guy who was a full-on genuine member of the Flat Earth Society. His explanation for why planes can travel around the world and end up where they started is that "it's like following a circle around a flat disc". I never could get an explanation out of him for what happens if another plane flies in a direction initially at 90 deg to the first. 
But there are worse things in life. His wife was a full-on schizophrenic who "actually saw" woodland fairies and sprites when walking in a nature reserve. One of their friends could "talk to animals" and... (wait for it...) hear them talking back in plain English.
Yet, for the most part, they all carried on lives that would appear superficially normal to a casual observer.

But there are worse things in life. His wife was a full-on schizophrenic who "actually saw" woodland fairies and sprites when walking in a nature reserve. One of their friends could "talk to animals" and... (wait for it...) hear them talking back in plain English.
Yet, for the most part, they all carried on lives that would appear superficially normal to a casual observer.
Evo
Staff Emeritus
- 24,114
- 3,277
Whoa.strangerep said:Long ago, I briefly knew a guy who was a full-on genuine member of the Flat Earth Society. His explanation for why planes can travel around the world and end up where they started is that "it's like following a circle around a flat disc". I never could get an explanation out of him for what happens if another plane flies in a direction initially at 90 deg to the first.
But there are worse things in life. His wife was a full-on schizophrenic who "actually saw" woodland fairies and sprites when walking in a nature reserve. One of their friends could "talk to animals" and... (wait for it...) hear them talking back in plain English.
Yet, for the most part, they all carried on lives that would appear superficially normal to a casual observer.
Well I worked with a Young Earth Creationist that would explain dinosaurs as "you can create anything you want from a pile of bones. He actually believed that scientists created the bones and buried them to be "found". You just don't argue reason with people like this, you just nod and walk away.
I'm currently watching "The Story of God" with Morgan Freeman on National Geographic. Sad, so much misinformation. He just said that the Big Bang was formed from a single point.
He admitted that he is a Christian and holds Christian beliefs. Oh well. maybe they should have found someone with an open scientific mind for this series. He seems to not believe in other religious beliefs, not open towards them. He tells the stories of other religions with an "are they joking?" attitude. Like the hindu pantheon of gods.
OMG, he just said that scientists say the Earth is 14 billion years old.
I can't watch this anymore.
Last edited:
DennisN
Gold Member
- 2,194
- 10,281
When I was younger I thought the idea of Flat Earthers was just a fun joke and that they did not exist in reality. Oh, how I miss the naivety of my youthstrangerep said:Long ago, I briefly knew a guy who was a full-on genuine member of the Flat Earth Society.
ooohkay...Evo said:He actually believed that scientists created the bones and buried them to be "found".

ProfuselyQuarky
Gold Member
- 857
- 588
Evo said:He actually believed that scientists created the bones and buried them to be "found".
Actually, that’s not too crazyDennisN said:ooohkay...![]()
Read the blog post and watch the Sixty Symbols video (I love Sixty Symbols, btw)!
http://blog.chembark.com/2013/08/14/some-very-suspicious-tem-images-in-nano-letters/
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 9,737
- 11,929
that's dreadful informationEvo said:I'm currently watching "The Story of God" with Morgan Freeman on National Geogrpahic. Sad, so much misinformation. He just said that the Big Bang was formed from a single point.
He admitted that he is a Christian and holds Christian beliefs. Oh well. maybe they should have found someone with an open scientific mind for this series. He seems to not believe in other religious beliefs, not open towards them. He tells the stories of other religions with an "are they joking?" attitude. Like the hindu pantheon of gods.
OMG, he just said that scientists say the Earth is 14 billion years old.I can't watch this anymore.
Lord Anoobis
- 131
- 22
Evo said:Well I worked with a Young Earth Creationist that would explain dinosaurs as "you can create anything you want from a pile of bones. He actually believed that scientists created the bones and buried them to be "found". You just don't argue reason with people like this, you just nod and walk away.
I had that honour as well and he said the very same thing about dinosaur bones. On the other hand he provided amusement of a level not easily found outside of the circle of professional (and top notch) comedians, so in some small and obscure way my life was enriched.
1oldman2
- 1,456
- 1,209
Just goes to show that there is "someone for everyone" in the world.strangerep said:But there are worse things in life. His wife was a full-on schizophrenic who "actually saw" woodland fairies and sprites when walking in a nature reserve. One of their friends could "talk to animals" and... (wait for it...) hear them talking back in plain English.![]()
1oldman2
- 1,456
- 1,209
But in the context of "misinformation" it's dead on.davenn said:that's dreadful information![]()
newjerseyrunner
- 1,532
- 637
The Earth is a flat plane on the back of a turtle, I don't see how anyone could dispute that. You can even see the turtle if you take enough drugs.
Evo
Staff Emeritus
- 24,114
- 3,277
It's turtles...all the way down.Hepth said:I thought it was supported by 4 elephants that rode on its shell, no?
Hornbein
Gold Member
- 4,145
- 3,306
Hepth said:I thought it was supported by 4 elephants that rode on its shell, no?
Right. Then there are two serpents that twine around the shell. Their bodies keep the dirt from sliding off.
I used to live in Bali, where there are thousands of models of this. But no, it's just symbolic, they don't really believe it.
Science Advisor
- 3,766
- 2,215
If it were harmless, I'd agree. But it's not: such people tend to validate and deepen each other's psychopathy. Eventually reality intervenes and their worlds implode, leading to severe mental breakdowns and hospitalization. I've had the misfortune of observing this process a few times at (reasonably) close range. Not pretty.1oldman2 said:Just goes to show that there is "someone for everyone" in the world.strangerep said:[...schizophrenics...]![]()

Like most illnesses, schizophrenia and associated delusions need to be treated when still in the mild stage. Easy to say...
Pamtastic67
Today i met a pilot for Alaska Airlines. I have been debating with my son on the flat Earth theory for years. So i asked this pilot if he thinks the Earth is flat and he laughed at me and said that it would be impossible to land an airplane on a spinning ball, "Impossible!" he said and this guy has been flying 737s in and out of southeast Alaska for the last 15 years. I just wonder what you guys have to say about that. This guy wasn't a schizophrenic, or married to one or delusional.
256bits
Gold Member
- 4,271
- 2,283
Could be he thought you were the flat-earther, and humored you to get on with his life.
A possibility is that he is right now he's telling a story of meeting someone who wanted to talk to him about the Earth being flat.
A possibility is that he is right now he's telling a story of meeting someone who wanted to talk to him about the Earth being flat.
Science Advisor
- 3,766
- 2,215
If we replied in detail to every piece of crackpot nonsense on the Internet, we'd never get any actual work done.Pamtastic67 said:I just wonder what you guys have to say about that.

Mentor
- 38,145
- 10,746
I think he was pulling your leg.Pamtastic67 said:Today i met a pilot for Alaska Airlines. I have been debating with my son on the flat Earth theory for years. So i asked this pilot if he thinks the Earth is flat and he laughed at me and said that it would be impossible to land an airplane on a spinning ball, "Impossible!" he said and this guy has been flying 737s in and out of southeast Alaska for the last 15 years.
Pilots land on aircraft carriers, which are moving around a lot more erratically than is the earth.
Similar threads
Is the Flat Earth Society a Joke?
- Link-
- · Replies 2 ·
- Earth Sciences
- Replies
- 2
UK Guardian: Flat Earth Ocean Cruise
- diogenesNY
- · Replies 13 ·
- Earth Sciences
- Replies
- 13
Why does flat Earth belief still exist?
- jedishrfu
- · Replies 55 ·
- Earth Sciences
- Replies
- 55
Is YouTube Responsible For Creating Flat-Earth Believers?
- ZapperZ
- · Replies 86 ·
- Earth Sciences
- Replies
- 86
How does the Flat Earth Society defy modern day physics?
- deaninator
- · Replies 1 ·
- Introductory Physics Homework Help
- Replies
- 1
Fun experiments to disprove Flat Earth
- accelerandom
- · Replies 67 ·
- STEM Educators and Teaching
- Replies
- 67
Debating a Flat-Earth 'Devil's Advocate'
- Myriad209
- · Replies 15 ·
- Earth Sciences
- Replies
- 15
Flat earth arguments don't hold up to parallax
- Alkatran
- · Replies 38 ·
- Earth Sciences
- Replies
- 38
Displacement Question: Flat Earth vs. Spherical Earth
- Emethyst
- · Replies 1 ·
- Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
- Replies
- 1
What is the displacement from Dallas to Chicago using a flat Earth model?
- sneeterpop
- · Replies 3 ·
- Introductory Physics Homework Help
- Replies
- 3
