- #36
Dick
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
- 26,258
- 623
I guess what I'm really after here is asking whether anybody else realizes how fantastically brilliant micromass's suggestion is, especially following Ray Vickson's heroically hard but straightforward solution. It also let's you construct lots of other associative functions that would be equally hard to prove the direct way. Using micromass's suggestion, the first time I worked it out the proof fell out so quickly I didn't even see how it happened, it was that quick. I had to replay it a few times before I really understood it. No real 'calculation' was even needed, much less an intensive computer algebra project. It's that good.