Snell's law for an interface with variable refractive index

In summary: I'm not quite sure what has to be done inside the medium. It appears that the next refraction will be from a surface perpendicular to the plane we considered i.e. x = 0 if I consider the medium to be divided into planes with the same refractive index.That's right, the next refraction will be from a surface perpendicular to the plane we considered. If the medium has a variable index, then the angle to be considered is the angle between the direction of the light path and the surface with the variable index.
  • #1
Vaibhav Sahu
6
0
Consider an interface along x-axis which separates two media. The medium below y = 0 is air or vacuum and light is incident from this medium onto the surface. The refractive index of the medium above y = 0 varies with x as some function of x : μ = f(x). Does the Snell's law still hold good ??
If so please prove it using Huygen's principle. Also specify the path of the refracted ray.
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
Set up not totally clear to me. Can we say that the plane z=0 (which of course includes the x-axis and y-axis) separates the media? Do you really mean that mu = f(x) rather than f(z) ?

What happens will depend on whether mu varies substantially over a distance of one wavelength, or whether the variation is small over a wavelength. The first case will be difficult to deal with, and, I'd guess, beyond the capabilities of Huygen's principle and calling for Maxwell's equations. The second case might be easier…

Now let wiser heads respond ...
 
  • #3
Considering the setup in a plane might not be different. Still I'll clear it a bit. Here's an image.https://scontent-sin1-1.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xaf1/v/t34.0-12/12167417_906070652794805_1640112228_n.jpg?oh=c670e33f48bae9df45946b176414dfe5&oe=5626B2E8
 
  • #4
I note that you've now changed x=0 to y=0 on your original post! Your post now makes more sense!
 
  • #5
Vaibhav Sahu said:
Consider an interface along x-axis which separates two media. The medium below y = 0 is air or vacuum and light is incident from this medium onto the surface. The refractive index of the medium above y = 0 varies with x as some function of x : μ = f(x). Does the Snell's law still hold good ??
If so please prove it using Huygen's principle. Also specify the path of the refracted ray.
If the refraction index varies, which value do you take to verify Snell's law?

--
lightarrow
 
  • #6
I'm not quite sure about it. But if the ray strikes the surface at some point x = a, shouldn't the refractive index to be considered be the value μ = f(a) while applying Snell's law, if it is applicable.
 
  • #7
  • #8
Vaibhav Sahu said:
I'm not quite sure about it. But if the ray strikes the surface at some point x = a, shouldn't the refractive index to be considered be the value μ = f(a) while applying Snell's law, if it is applicable.
Ok, but if you do this you cannot use the initial (when the beam enters the material) and final (when the beam exit the material) values of the angles (*), you have to use the (variable) angles at every point of it; then Snell's law should (maybe :-) ) written as: ##n(\theta) sin(\theta) = n(\theta+d\theta) sin(\theta+d\theta)##.

(*) Edit: actually it seems possible.

##n(\theta) sin(\theta) = n(\theta+d\theta) sin(\theta+d\theta)##

means, developing at first order ##n(\theta+d\theta), sin(\theta+d\theta)##, making the product and neglecting the second order differential:

##n(\theta) sin(\theta) = n(\theta) sin(\theta) + [n'(\theta) sin(\theta) + n(\theta) cos(\theta)]d\theta##

where ##n'(\theta) = dn(\theta)/d\theta##

and simplifying:

##n'(\theta) sin(\theta) + n(\theta) cos(\theta) = 0##

Solving the differential equation:

##n(\theta) sin(\theta) = n(\theta_0) sin(\theta_0)##

which is really amazing, at least for me!
--
lightarrow
 
Last edited:
  • #9
You've retrieved the well known result [tex]n_1\ sin \theta_1 = n_2\ sin \theta_2[/tex]
 
  • #10
Even after we consider that the Snell's law holds, I still face problems drawing the path of the ray inside the medium. I am not sure of what has to be done inside the medium. It appears that the next refraction will be from a surface perpendicular to the plane we considered i.e. x = 0 if I consider the medium to be divided into planes with the same refractive index.
 
  • #11
Yes, that's the way to go. You can then also let the thickness of sheets got to 0 with the difference in refractive index also scaling to 0 to obtain the continuous distribution.
 
  • #12
Philip Wood said:
You've retrieved the well known result [tex]n_1\ sin \theta_1 = n_2\ sin \theta_2[/tex]
Yes, it's what I said. Isn't amazing that Snell's law is valid even considering the initial and the final values of angles and refractive indexes for a medium with variable index?

--
lightarrow
 
  • #13
Yes, it's a nice result. Can be thought of as :

n
sin θ = constant for a given light path

in a medium through which n varies in one direction only (θ being the angle between that direction and the direction of the light path). But you knew that!
 
  • #14
We can indeed take μ sin θ = constant for the whole path. But as I was saying, the next refraction that takes place inside the medium is through a surface that is perpendicular to the surface we had considered earlier (y = 0). This makes the angle to be considered different.
 

Related to Snell's law for an interface with variable refractive index

What is Snell's law for an interface with variable refractive index?

Snell's law is a formula that describes the relationship between the angle of incidence and the angle of refraction at an interface with varying refractive indices. It is also known as the law of refraction.

What is an interface with variable refractive index?

An interface with variable refractive index refers to a boundary or surface where the refractive index changes. This can occur when light passes through materials with different densities, such as air and water.

How is Snell's law for an interface with variable refractive index calculated?

Snell's law is calculated using the following formula: n1sinθ1 = n2sinθ2, where n1 and n2 are the refractive indices of the two materials and θ1 and θ2 are the angles of incidence and refraction, respectively.

What happens to light when it passes through an interface with a varying refractive index?

When light passes through an interface with a varying refractive index, it changes direction due to the change in speed caused by the change in refractive index. This is known as refraction.

What are some real-life applications of Snell's law for an interface with variable refractive index?

Snell's law has many practical applications, including in the design of lenses for glasses and cameras, the creation of optical fibers for telecommunication, and the production of lenses for microscopes and telescopes.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
42
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
305
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
209
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top