So today I found out that some of my classmates haven't bought a

  • Thread starter Thread starter InvalidID
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the reliance on textbooks for learning in academic settings. Many participants express disbelief that students can pass courses without reading textbooks, emphasizing their own dependence on these resources for understanding course material. Some argue that alternative learning methods, such as taking detailed notes during lectures or utilizing online resources, can suffice for passing exams. The conversation also touches on issues of textbook accessibility, with some students sharing experiences of borrowing books from libraries or friends, while others mention the prevalence of free online textbooks. Concerns are raised about the necessity of textbooks for certain subjects, particularly those requiring practice problems or specific content not covered in lectures. Additionally, there are anecdotes about the questionable practices of students borrowing or using textbooks without proper attribution, highlighting the complexities of textbook usage in education. Overall, the thread reveals a divide in learning preferences and the varying roles textbooks play in academic success.
InvalidID
Messages
84
Reaction score
3
single textbook.

Mind=blown. How is this even possible? I rely so heavily on my textbook for learning. How is it even possible to NOT read a textbook and still manage to pass? Is there some sort of secret to learning without a textbook that I'm missing here? I literally rely on the textbook for 100% of my learning. In fact, lectures are almost pointless for me. I just go there to waste time, listen to what the prof has to say and get a nice break from studying.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You sure they didn't procure it by "other means"? I don't know how either. I live and die by my textbooks when it comes to learning.
 
You can pass without the need to have a textbook. One may write notes during lectures and find it sufficient to achieve the desired goal, which is 'passing' the course. Of course, that isn't the case if you want to excel in the subject, having more than one book is pretty much expected too.
 
InvalidID said:
single textbook.

Mind=blown. How is this even possible? I rely so heavily on my textbook for learning. How is it even possible to NOT read a textbook and still manage to pass? Is there some sort of secret to learning without a textbook that I'm missing here? I literally rely on the textbook for 100% of my learning. In fact, lectures are almost pointless for me. I just go there to waste time, listen to what the prof has to say and get a nice break from studying.

They probably pick up another person's textbook "by accident" from time to time. I have seen a few classmates do this and one actually took mine. When he returned it, I knew that he had been using it because it looked so abused lol. Throughout the class I noticed he felt a strange entitlement to it.
 
HeLiXe said:
They probably pick up another person's textbook "by accident" from time to time. I have seen a few classmates do this and one actually took mine. When he returned it, I knew that he had been using it because it looked so abused lol. Throughout the class I noticed he felt a strange entitlement to it.

That's *censor*ed up.
 
I am one of these people. I take in everything that was said and will remember it. Reading is useless for me. People just have different ways of leaning
 
I don't buy textbooks unless I intend to keep the book as a reference, which is very rare. If I absolutely need to know something that isn't in the course notes (and I for some reason can't just derive it myself), then I'll do the obvious thing and just go to a library.
 
JackRohr said:
People just have different ways of leaning
Langauge learner proves the routes.

Like, can read and write but not hear or speak, or vice versa.
 
You don't have to buy a book to read it, you can borrow it from a library or a friend!
And yes, it's possible to pass an exam without reading a textbook. I know plenty of people who do that.
 
  • #10
Not buying textbooks isn't equivalent to not reading one.

There are numerous free online textbooks and websites which cover a great many things in a lot of depth. My university has access to the MyiLibrary service and a lot of our recommended texts can be viewed in full with unlimited access as long as we're students.

When it comes to "reading around" the subject, I use the internet, i.e. blogs and twitter for that since books don't normally cover the latest science.
 
  • #11
My daughter rents her textbooks when she can.
 
  • #12
JackRohr said:
I am one of these people. I take in everything that was said and will remember it. Reading is useless for me. People just have different ways of leaning

A lot of classes will have homework assigned from practice problems in the textbooks. What do you do then?

Some classes won't go through everything that is in the textbook, like language classes. Like in my Chinese class, you're expected to learn the characters. You can't just listen to the characters and see them once during a lecture and memorize them. And not all of the characters that will be on the test will be covered in class, so your notes won't suffice.

I've also had a couple of classes that had open book quizzes or tests.

There's a lot of reasons why not having the textbook is just going to hurt you in a lot of classes.
I don't buy textbooks unless I intend to keep the book as a reference, which is very rare. If I absolutely need to know something that isn't in the course notes (and I for some reason can't just derive it myself), then I'll do the obvious thing and just go to a library.
I tried that when I forgot my Linear Algebra book at home. The library didn't have any linear algebra books.
 
  • #13
People use pirated electronic copies a lot.
 
  • #14
One time in chemistry our professor said at the start of the class that this textbook was so good and everyone *must* have it. Lots of people bought it...and not a single person ever used it that I know of, he never assigned homework from it (that was online) and never made any reference to it in class. Eventually I looked at who wrote it, and his name just happened to be listed as one of the editors. Coincidence? I think not.
 
  • #15
leroyjenkens said:
The library didn't have any linear algebra books.

Is that the library of a university that offers any math course ?

I am usually very careful when I buy textbooks. Most of the textbooks that were required in my courses were not that useful so now I only buy books that I know I want to have and will be useful later.
 
  • #16
InvalidID said:
That's *censor*ed up.

Tell me about it.
 
  • #17
leroyjenkens said:
I tried that when I forgot my Linear Algebra book at home. The library didn't have any linear algebra books.

That's surprising.

Does your university perhaps have a separate library for mathematics textbooks/journals?

My math department had its own library.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top