Solved: Help with a block sliding down an Inclined platform

  • Thread starter Thread starter member 744828
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Phyiscs
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the kinetic coefficient of friction for a block sliding down an inclined platform. Two different calculations yield coefficients of 0.35 and 0.23, leading to confusion about which is correct. The correct approach involves recognizing that the net force (Fnet) is derived from the difference between gravitational force and frictional force, specifically Fnet = 25 N - Ff. Participants emphasize the importance of using proper units and understanding the relationships between forces, suggesting that a free-body diagram would aid in visualizing the problem. Ultimately, clarity in the concepts and direct communication with the student are highlighted as crucial for resolving the confusion.
member 744828
Homework Statement
A 5 kg block slides down a 30° incline with an acceleration of 3.0 m/s. a) How much of a resistive force up the ramp must there be? b) What is the kinetic coefficient of friction between the block and the ramp
Relevant Equations
Fy = 50cos30 = 43.3N
Fgx= 50 sin 30 = 25 N

a=Fnet/m
Fy = 50cos30 = 43.3N
Fgx= 50 sin 30 = 25 N

a=Fnet/m
3.0 = Fnet/5
Fnet=15

Ff = m Fn
15=m (43.3)
m=0.35
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What is your question?
 
Orodruin said:
What is your question?
Is part b right? .35 for kinetic coefficient of friction.
Or should it be
Ff = m Fn
(25-15) = m (43.3)
m=0.23
 
galibe said:
Is part b right? .35 for kinetic coefficient of friction.
Or should it be
Ff = m Fn
(25-15) = m (43.3)
m=0.23
Which do you think, and why?
Think about the relationship between ##F_{net}, F_f ## and ##F_{gx}##.

Please don't use the same symbol (m) to mean different things. Write mu, or, better, use LaTeX.
 
haruspex said:
Which do you think, and why?
Think about the relationship between ##F_{net}, F_f ## and ##F_{gx}##.

Please don't use the same symbol (m) to mean different things. Write mu, or, better, use LaTeX.
I am trying to help my daughter. I think it is:
Ff = mu *Fn
15 = mu * 43.3
mu=0.35

She believes it is the other answer.
Ff = mu*Fn
(25-15) = mu* 43.3
mu=0.23
 
That doesn’t really answer the question of why you think your answer is correct.
 
galibe said:
I am trying to help my daughter. I think it is:
Ff = mu *Fn
15 = mu * 43.3
mu=0.35

She believes it is the other answer.
Ff = mu*Fn
(25-15) = mu* 43.3
mu=0.23
Your daughter should be helping you!
 
Orodruin said:
That doesn’t really answer the question of why you think your answer is correct.
I don’t know, I haven’t done physics in many years.
 
PeroK said:
Your daughter should be helping you!
So she is right? I have not done this in a long time and trying to relearn with her notes.
 
  • #10
galibe said:
I don’t know, I haven’t done physics in many years.
If in need of guidance, your daughter is very welcome here. It is better to have a direct connection to helpers than having a go-between that may misinterpret or misrepresent.
 
  • #11
galibe said:
So she is right? I have not done this in a long time and trying to relearn with her notes.
Yes, she is right. Fnet is the net force, not the friction force. The relation is Fnet = 25 N - Ff. (Always use units in equations!!)
 
  • #12
Orodruin said:
If in need of guidance, your daughter is very welcome here. It is better to have a direct connection to helpers than having a go-between that may misinterpret or misrepresent.
I won’t misrepresent. By reading on the internet and her notes I am not sure if it should be 25-15 or 15. I would generally have her brother help but he is away at college.
 
  • #13
galibe said:
So she is right? I have not done this in a long time and trying to relearn with her notes.
Yes, she's right.
 
  • #14
Orodruin said:
Yes, she is right. Fnet is the net force, not the friction force. The relation is Fnet = 25 N - Ff. (Always use units in equations!!)
Thank you, that was the piece I was unsure of. Fnet = 25N- Ff
I copied and pasted from the picture and some units didn’t come over.
 
  • #15
galibe said:
I won’t misrepresent.
Not consciously obviously. However, if the underlying understanding of the concepts is lacking, there is always a risk of misrepresentation. For example, you misrepresented the material from the book by assuming Ff = 15 N. I am sure that was not your intention, but it occurred.

We are here to help, but it is always easier to help the student directly.
 
  • Like
Likes member 744828
  • #16
I don't see any drawing of a free-body diagram (FBD). You may copy and paste your own sketch on pen and paper. Better still, there are excellent drawing softwares.
I think an FBD is essential for problems of this sort, specially if you're a beginner.
 
  • Like
Likes PeroK and member 744828
  • #17
1706252556506.png
There you go @galibe, I draw for you the diagram of the problem using MSWord. You need to find the resistive force ##\color{red}{f_R}##. It took a little more than ten minutes.

Please note that I haven't shown all the forces. Can you complete the diagram by showing them?
 
  • Like
Likes Lnewqban and Delta2
  • #18
galibe said:
I am trying to help my daughter. I think it is:
Ff = mu *Fn
15 = mu * 43.3
mu=0.35

She believes it is the other answer.
Ff = mu*Fn
(25-15) = mu* 43.3
mu=0.23
If you have some reasoning behind your answer, please state it. If you don't, why are you hampering your daughter?
 
Back
Top