Solving a Circle Equation: Where Did I Go Wrong?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DeanBH
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Circle
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving the circle equation x^2 + y^2 + 2x - 12y + 12 = 0 and the challenges faced in rewriting it in the standard form (x-a)^2 + (y-b)^2 = r^2. Participants clarify that to complete the square, the correct constant terms must be added, specifically 37, to balance the equation. The center of the circle is identified as (-1, 6) with a radius of 5, derived from the adjustments made to the equation. The conversation emphasizes the importance of correctly manipulating the equation to find the center and radius without confusion.
DeanBH
Messages
82
Reaction score
0
x^2 + y^2 + 2x -12y + 12 = 0

(x-a)^2 + (y-b)^2 = r^2 in that form.

why doesn't this work.


(x+1) + (y-6)

this gives you your x^2 your 2x and a +1 Gives you y^2 and -12y and a +36

so (x+1) + (y-6) + 49 = 0?

that would make r^2 negative which is impossible, what am i screwing up here?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Your constant term is wrong. The center is right, but I got 5 as the radius. Try again and show your work.
 
accidental post
 
Last edited:
i have shown my working, i just tried to factorize in a way that would give me the co-efficients of x and y properly,

x^2 + y^2 + 2x -12y + 12 = 0

(x-a)^2 + (y-b)^2 = r^2 in that form.

why doesn't this work.


(x+1) + (y-6)

this gives you your x^2 your 2x and a +1 Gives you y^2 and -12y and a +36

i did (x + 1) because it gives you the 2x and the x^2 of the equation, but it also gives +1, i kept this on the left side of the equation so i ended up with +13 there. i then did the same for (y-6) and ended up with 36+13 on the left side of the equation which is 49.
 
when i multiply out the numbers in the brackets, do i have to put them over the right side of this equation, without changing the sign? as it were
 
DeanBH said:
i have shown my working, i just tried to factorize in a way that would give me the co-efficients of x and y properly,

x^2 + y^2 + 2x -12y + 12 = 0
which is the same as x^2+ 2x+ y^2- 12y= -12

(x-a)^2 + (y-b)^2 = r^2 in that form.

why doesn't this work.


(x+1) + (y-6)
?? Did you mean (x+1)^2+ (y- 6)^2?

this gives you your x^2 your 2x and a +1 Gives you y^2 and -12y and a +36

i did (x + 1) because it gives you the 2x and the x^2 of the equation, but it also gives +1, i kept this on the left side of the equation so i ended up with +13 there. i then did the same for (y-6) and ended up with 36+13 on the left side of the equation which is 49.
Did you notice that you never do say what equation you wound up with?

Okay, (x+ 1)^2+ (y- 6)^2= x^2+ 2x+ 1+ y^2- 12y+ 36= what?
Since, in order to "complete the square" with x^2+ 2x, you have to add 1, and, in order to "complete the square" with y^2- 12y, you have to add 36, you have to add add a total of 37.
You started with x^2+ 2x+ y^2- 12y= -12. Adding 37 to both sides of that gives
(x+ 1)^2+ (y- 6)^2= 37-12= 25. You have -12+ 1+ 36, not 12+ 36+ 1, because they are on the right side of the equation.

The other way you have done this was, with your original equation, x^2+ y^2+ 2x- 12y+ 12= 0 is to recognize that you need a total of 36+ 1= 37 on left side. Since you already have 12, you need to add 37- 12= 25 to both sides:
x^2+ y^2+ 2x- 12y+ 12+ 25= 25 or (x^2+ 2x+ 1)+ (y^2- 12y+ 36)= (x+1)^2+ (y- 6)^2= 25.
 
cant i do this without completing the square.

im just going to factorize, and whatever numbers i get move to the right side of the equation. lol.

that way it works even if i don't understand it
 
Last edited:
nvm i understand it now
 
DeanBH said:
cant i do this without completing the square.

im just going to factorize, and whatever numbers i get move to the right side of the equation. lol.

that way it works even if i don't understand it

OR you could recall that the equation of a circle with centre (-f,-g) and radius,r,r^2=f^2+g^2-c is x^2+y^2=2fx+2gy+c=0.
Then put your equation in that form and you'll get the centre and radius.
 
Back
Top