Special Relativity vs General Relativity: T_{\mu\nu} = 0

[quasar987]

Does SR appear as the special case of GR when T_{\mu\nu}=0 in which case the solution of Einstein's equation is the Minkowski metric?

And what are the Ricci tensors and scalar curvature like in the case T_{\mu\nu}=0?

 

[robphy]

Does SR appear as the special case of GR when T_{\mu\nu}=0 in which case the solution of Einstein's equation is the Minkowski metric?

And what are the Ricci tensors and scalar curvature like in the case T_{\mu\nu}=0?

Using the field equations (with zero cosmological constant), a zero stress tensor yields a zero ricci tensor and ricci scalar. You'll need more than requiring "vacuum" (zero stress tensor) to get SR.

You'll need a zero Weyl Tensor as well.
Strictly speaking, to get "SR", you'll need the right manifold, R^4, to start with.

 

[pervect]

The analogy to Maxwell's equations might be helpful here to clarify some of the reasons why a zero stress tensor doesn't guarantee a Minkowski (SR) metric.

Consider asking "Suppose you have no charges - are the E and B fields zero everywhere?". The answer is no, you could have electromagnetic radiation. Usually one specifies boundary conditions as well as a charge distribution to get a unique solution to Maxwell's equations. For Maxwell's equations, having E and B zero at infinity is a standard boundary condition, for GR the analogous boundary condition would be "asymptotic flatness".

 

[robphy]

Are you suggesting that, for GR, vacuum and asymptotic flatness imply that the Riemann curvature is zero everywhere?

 

[country boy]

Does SR appear as the special case of GR when T_{\mu\nu}=0 in which case the solution of Einstein's equation is the Minkowski metric?

And what are the Ricci tensors and scalar curvature like in the case T_{\mu\nu}=0?

SR is the special case of GR where the metric components g_{\mu\nu} are all constants. This corresponds to a zero Riemann tensor, which is more restrictive than setting the Ricci tensor equal to zero. T_{\mu\nu}=0, which gives a zero Ricci tensor, corresponds to empty space. Empty space can be curved, of course.

 

[pervect]

Are you suggesting that, for GR, vacuum and asymptotic flatness imply that the Riemann curvature is zero everywhere?

No, not really.

 

[pmb_phy]

Does SR appear as the special case of GR when T_{\mu\nu}=0 in which case the solution of Einstein's equation is the Minkowski metric?

And what are the Ricci tensors and scalar curvature like in the case T_{\mu\nu}=0?

I've used T_{\mu\nu} in SR myself. In fact I learned more about it in an SR text than any GR text that I have. In my cases it was used to analyze things like the non-proportionality of energy density and inertial mass density. As far as T_{\mu\nu}= 0, this can lead to the Minkowski metric once you transform to an inertial frame. Otherwise the components of the metric (i.e. the set of ten gravitational potentials g_uv) may net be constant in space, i.e. there could be gravitational forces/accelerations still present.

Pete