Speed of Wire faster than Speed of Light?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on whether pulling a wire taut between Mars and Earth could result in observable movement on Mars faster than the speed of light. It is clarified that the speed at which a tug travels through a wire is limited to the speed of sound in that material, which is significantly slower than the speed of light. Even with an infinitely stiff material, the fundamental laws of physics, particularly relativity, would still apply. Therefore, no matter the conditions, the movement observed on Mars would not exceed the speed of light. The conclusion emphasizes that the transmission of movement is constrained by the physical properties of the wire.
ooloo
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Speed of Wire faster than Speed of Light?

Question:

All planetary motion and gravity effects, etc. aside... if I had the capability of pulling a wire taut from Mars to Earth, keeping it in tension, and then pull on that wire while I stood on Earth, wouldn't the resulting movement of that wire viewed on Mars be faster than the speed of light. Is there anything which would limit the amount of time it would take to observe the resulting movement on Mars?

Thanks in advance for your replies.

John in Brooklyn, NY
 
Science news on Phys.org


The stiffness of the wire, there are lots of ways of violating elatively if you allow infinitely stiff materials.
The speed a tug travels through a wire is the speed of sound in the wire, this is high ( a few km/s in steel) but lessthan the speed of light.
 


The transmission of movement along your wire would be at the speed of sound for whatever material your wire was made from.
 
Back
Top