Strangest thing happened to me tonite

  • Thread starter Thread starter pentazoid
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
A driver experienced a sudden loss of their front fender while traveling at 50 mph, initially suspecting a collision but finding no damage or injuries. The fender appeared intact upon inspection, but some screws were missing. Discussions revealed that fenders are designed to detach easily during low-speed collisions to minimize pedestrian injuries, held on by weak plastic clips. The possibility of the fender falling off was attributed to worn or missing fasteners, especially after potential impacts in a parking lot. The age of the vehicle, which is four years old, was noted, along with concerns about stress corrosion in fasteners due to environmental factors. Overall, while such incidents are rare, they can occur under specific circumstances, particularly if the fender was previously compromised.
pentazoid
Messages
142
Reaction score
0
While I was driving my car, all of a sudden my front fender falls off. At first , I thought I had hit something or someone, but my front fender was not dented up , and there were no traces of blood on my fender. I think my airbags would have activated had I hit a car or someone. I got out of my car to see if I hit anyone, there was no one around my car.Miraculously , as I drove my car home , the front part of my fender did not drag under my car. I placed my fender back on the front of my car and it looks as if the car was never hit. I noticed some screws were missing . I know this kind of thing doesn't happen everyday , but is it possible that you can be driving on a road and your front fender suddenly fall down?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The fenders are designed to crumple and fall off in low speed collisions (especially with pedestrians) so they are only held on with a couple of easily breakable plastic bolts or clips. It could be that yours are missing or have perished.
 
mgb_phys said:
The fenders are designed to crumple and fall off in low speed collisions (especially with pedestrians) so they are only held on with a couple of easily breakable plastic bolts or clips. It could be that yours are missing or have perished.

low speed collisions? I was going 50 mph.
 
They are designed to break off easily (as in low speed collisions) so are only held on weakly. So going over a small bump at 50mph might do it if the bolts are missing/worn.
 
pentazoid said:
While I was driving my car, all of a sudden my front fender falls off.
The whole bumper or just the plastic fascia?

mgb_phys said:
The fenders are designed to ... fall off.
Why? How does this facilitate pedestrians getting less hurt?
 
DaveC426913 said:
Why? How does this facilitate pedestrians getting less hurt?
The plastic bumpers are supposed to crumple in a low speed impact to stop the pedestrian hitting the boy of the car (or at least slow them down) so the bumpers are made of easily breakable plastic - including the clips that hold them to the boy.
 
mgb_phys said:
They are designed to break off easily (as in low speed collisions) so are only held on weakly. So going over a small bump at 50mph might do it if the bolts are missing/worn.

I have a question. Once the fender is broken off, how long do you think it will take to fix it?
 
pentazoid said:
I have a question. Once the fender is broken off, how long do you think it will take to fix it?
It would depend on why the fender fell off. If the part that holds the screws/bolts to the car is damaged to the point that it is useless, a new fender may be needed. If it's just a matter of bolting it back on, that shouldn't take long at all.
 
mgb_phys said:
The plastic bumpers are supposed to crumple in a low speed impact to stop the pedestrian hitting the boy of the car (or at least slow them down) so the bumpers are made of easily breakable plastic - including the clips that hold them to the boy.

:smile: What the heck?! :smile:

Where the heck do you live? Up in the North woods, a lot of people drive around with deer strapped to their cars, but... :smile:

Is this a UK-US difference in language?

And as to the original post, do you mean the front bumper? Or some sort of plastic trim on the fender? (I can't really envision either the entire front bumper or the entire fender falling off). Post a pic of what you're talking about.
 
  • #10
BobG said:
:smile: What the heck?! :smile:

Where the heck do you live? Up in the North woods, a lot of people drive around with deer strapped to their cars, but... :smile:

Is this a UK-US difference in language?

And as to the original post, do you mean the front bumper? Or some sort of plastic trim on the fender? (I can't really envision either the entire front bumper or the entire fender falling off). Post a pic of what you're talking about.

No , I just mean my whole front fender. My headlights work just fine and are intact, my front fender is busted.
 
  • #11
pentazoid said:
No , I just mean my whole front fender. My headlights work just fine and are intact, my front fender is busted.

No, I've never heard of anyone's fender falling off. Is this a used vehicle that might have been in an accident? Some shoddy repair work might be at fault. Perhaps they stripped the screws/bolts when taking the fender off, but still replaced them even though they were no longer doing anything?

Normally, it's very easy to dent a fender and have a small dent bend the entire fender in odd places since it's designed to crumple and absorb energy. Even in an accident, it's rare for the fender to just fall off. To come off, it usually has to be ripped off during the accident because it caught on the other car or on some stationary object (tree, guardrail, etc).

The normal repair nowadays is to order a brand new fender (or get an undamaged one from the junk yard and repaint it). The old method of removing the dent seems to be archaic since the fender can bend and warp in spots pretty far removed from the initial damage. That also means an accident could also stress the bolts/screws in an unusual way.
 
  • #12
pentazoid said:
While I was driving my car, all of a sudden my front fender falls off. At first , I thought I had hit something or someone, but my front fender was not dented up , and there were no traces of blood on my fender. I think my airbags would have activated had I hit a car or someone. I got out of my car to see if I hit anyone, there was no one around my car.Miraculously , as I drove my car home , the front part of my fender did not drag under my car. I placed my fender back on the front of my car and it looks as if the car was never hit. I noticed some screws were missing . I know this kind of thing doesn't happen everyday , but is it possible that you can be driving on a road and your front fender suddenly fall down?
How old is the car? If one uses a car in the north or northeast where roads are salted, some fasteners (aluminum or steel) are susceptible to stress corrosion cracking (SCC), usually at the base of the head where is joins the shank.

Could someone impacted the car in a parking lot recently? That might fail some fasteners by shear, especially if they were already damaged by SCC.
 
  • #13
Where do you live? In sub zero temps, cars hitting snow balls on the road and knocking off bumpers aren't exactly unheard of.
 
  • #14
Astronuc said:
How old is the car? If one uses a car in the north or northeast where roads are salted, some fasteners (aluminum or steel) are susceptible to stress corrosion cracking (SCC), usually at the base of the head where is joins the shank.

Could someone impacted the car in a parking lot recently? That might fail some fasteners by shear, especially if they were already damaged by SCC.

my car is only 4 years old. Just bought it last year, so its used. I am think that while I was in a parking lot , somebody possibly could have hit front bender and displaced the screws that were holding my fender together. I think as I continued to drive my car, the screws that were loosely holding my front fender together displaced completely and then the fender just fell off. The fender fell off my car while I was driving.
 
  • #15
The weirdest thing happened to me today. I was walking my dog along the side of the road when all of a sudden this car doing about 50 mph ran right into me. I was knocked into a thick bunch of bushes and it took forever for anyone to find me. I've got two broken legs, my dog is dead and if I ever find that sob that hit me...
 
  • #16
tribdog said:
The weirdest thing happened to me today ... it took forever for anyone to find me.
Not 'today'. You were lying in that bush in a coma for seven days.
 
  • #17
mgb_phys said:
The plastic bumpers are supposed to crumple in a low speed impact to stop the pedestrian hitting the boy of the car (or at least slow them down) so the bumpers are made of easily breakable plastic - including the clips that hold them to the boy.
"Boy"?
tribdog said:
The weirdest thing happened to me today. I was walking my dog along the side of the road when all of a sudden this car doing about 50 mph ran right into me. I was knocked into a thick bunch of bushes and it took forever for anyone to find me. I've got two broken legs, my dog is dead and if I ever find that sob that hit me...
oh THAT boy.
 

Similar threads

The Physics of a Fender Bender: Rotating a 4000 lb Van
Replies
1
Views
2K
Hitting a Deer: My Story and Princeton's Solution
Replies
20
Views
4K
Three Car Collision - Can physics help clarify twin impact?
Replies
3
Views
16K
I Car Accident Physics - Are Wheels/Tires Good or Bad Energy Absorbers?
Replies
1
Views
2K
Did I Accidentally Cause Harm to a Fox While Driving?
Replies
13
Views
7K
I Motorbike vs Football: Is It Possible?
Replies
6
Views
1K
Book Review: Invisible Women: Data Bias in a World Designed for Men
Replies
19
Views
7K
Bad Evening: Dealing With Car Accident Aftermath
Replies
17
Views
3K
Not going to get much sleep tonight
Replies
18
Views
2K
Determine speed of car from result of impact?
Replies
3
Views
2K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top