Struggling Engineering Student Needs Help with Tension in Cable Homework

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a first-year engineering student's struggle with a statics homework problem involving tension in a cable. The student initially attempts to apply the equation for moments but finds difficulty in identifying the moment arm and understanding the forces involved. After receiving advice to sum the torques about the pin and consider the direction of the torques, the student realizes the importance of the moment arm for both the tension and the weight of the beam. Ultimately, the student clarifies that the weight acts from the midpoint of the beam, leading to a breakthrough in understanding the problem. The student expresses gratitude for the guidance received, indicating a successful resolution to their confusion.
CheesyPeeps
Messages
36
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


2013-Q4.jpg


Homework Equations


∑MA = 0, where A is the pin.
Tx = Tcos150
Ty = Tsin150

The Attempt at a Solution


I've drawn in the 100kN force of the beam's weight, and identified that ∑MA = 0. I attempted to find the moment arm, but really wasn't sure how do to it, or if it would even help.

I'm a first year engineering student who's struggling with statics. Any help is appreciated, but please do your best to keep it as easy to understand as possible.
 

Attachments

  • 2013-Q4.jpg
    2013-Q4.jpg
    14.3 KB · Views: 775
Physics news on Phys.org
CheesyPeeps said:

Homework Statement


View attachment 232980

Homework Equations


∑MA = 0, where A is the pin.

Tx = Tcos150
Ty = Tsin150

150?

The Attempt at a Solution


I've drawn in the 100kN force of the beam's weight, and identified that ∑MA = 0. I attempted to find the moment arm, but really wasn't sure how do to it, or if it would even help.

I'm a first year engineering student who's struggling with statics. Any help is appreciated, but please do your best to keep it as easy to understand as possible.

Try summing the torques about A.

The mass of the beam creates a clockwise torque. The wire must create an anticlockwise torque. It's not accelerating so these torques must sum to zero.

Perhaps temporarily replace the diagonal wire with a vertical wire?
 
CWatters said:
150?
Try summing the torques about A.

The mass of the beam creates a clockwise torque. The wire must create an anticlockwise torque. It's not accelerating so these torques must sum to zero.

Perhaps temporarily replace the diagonal wire with a vertical wire?

Thank you very much for your advice.
I replaced the wire with a vertical wire equal to Tsin30, and then wrote that Tsin30-100kN = 0. That means T = 200kN, but I checked the answer to the question, and it's T = 100kN. Have I missed something? I have the moments/torque chapter of my textbook open in front of me, but it's not helping much :confused:
 
Where does the weight of the beam act? If you were to draw its force vector, where would you place it on the diagram?
 
  • Like
Likes CheesyPeeps
gneill said:
Where does the weight of the beam act? If you were to draw its force vector, where would you place it on the diagram?

Thank you so much! I got it!
I drew the weight's force vector down from the middle of the beam, and when I did that, it finally clicked that the moment arm of the weight would be half the moment arm of Tsin30. I had been stressing over this question since yesterday - I'm so glad I understand it now. Thank you again!
 
  • Like
Likes gneill
CheesyPeeps said:
Thank you very much for your advice.
I replaced the wire with a vertical wire equal to Tsin30, and then wrote that Tsin30-100kN = 0.

Those aren't torques they are forces.
 
CWatters said:
Those aren't torques they are forces.

Yeah, I see that now. I wasn't thinking at all about the moment arm, but once I spotted the fact that Tsin30 and the weight have different moment arms, I got it. Thank you again for your help! Statics has been driving me mad, so I'm really glad I understand this now :oldbiggrin:
 
Back
Top