Suffering from Kidney Stones: My Story

  • Context: Medical 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Jimmy Snyder
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    stones
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around personal experiences with kidney stones, including symptoms, treatments, and dietary considerations. Participants share their stories of pain, management strategies, and various remedies, reflecting on both medical and anecdotal approaches to dealing with kidney stones.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes passing multiple kidney stones over the years, including a recent experience with a half-centimeter stone.
  • Another participant suggests dietary changes, such as avoiding certain foods and increasing water intake, as potential preventive measures against kidney stones.
  • Several participants recount their own experiences with kidney stones, including surgical interventions and the use of pain medications like oxycodone, noting the side effects they experienced.
  • A participant shares a personal story of suffering from kidney stones while traveling and discusses their dietary adjustments that led to a reduction in occurrences.
  • One participant mentions the different types of stones they have had and the corresponding medical advice received, including medication and dietary restrictions.
  • There is a humorous exchange about the relative nature of pain, with participants joking about how passing a stone might change one's perspective on other pains.
  • A participant introduces an old remedy involving boiled potato skin, claiming it can alleviate pain and dissolve stones, sharing anecdotal success from their family.
  • Another participant discusses the physical characteristics of stones and the pain associated with their passage, emphasizing that even small stones can cause significant discomfort.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of personal experiences and opinions regarding dietary management and pain relief for kidney stones. There is no consensus on the best approach to prevention or treatment, as various methods and remedies are discussed without agreement on their effectiveness.

Contextual Notes

Some participants mention specific dietary changes and medical treatments they have undergone, but the discussion does not resolve the effectiveness of these approaches or the underlying causes of kidney stone formation.

  • #91
Hey Jimmy or any of the stone sufferers, just a curiosity question for you. Have any of you had your cystine levels measured or has any doctor ever used the word "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cystinuria" " with you?

A bit about cystinuria from the above link;

"Cystinuria is an inherited autosomal recessive[1] metabolic disorder that is characterized by the formation of cystine stones in the kidneys, ureter, and bladder. Cystinuria is a cause of persistent kidney stones. It is a disorder involving the defective transepithelial transport of cystine and dibasic amino acids in the kidney and intestine, and is one of many causes of kidney stones. If not treated properly, the disorder could cause serious damage to the kidneys and surrounding organs, and in some rare cases death. The stones may be identified by a positive nitroprusside cyanide test. The crystals are usually hexagonal, translucent, white. Upon removal, the stones may be pink or yellow in color, but later they turn to greenish due to exposure to air.Cystinuria is characterized by the inadequate reabsorption of cystine in the proximal convoluted tubules during the filtering process in the kidneys, thus resulting in an excessive concentration of this amino acid in the urine. Cystine may precipitate out of the urine, if the urine is neutral or acidic, and form crystals or stones in the kidneys, ureters, or bladder. It is one of several inborn errors of metabolism included in the Garrod's tetrad. The disorder is attributed to deficiency in transport and metabolism of amino acids."

I don't think much is known about the occurrence and epidemiology of the disease, as many of the amino acid transporter genetic defects are relatively new to science (thus could easily be over looked by a nephorlogist or urologist not up to date on their literature).

Anyway, since you seem have no cause for your stone problems, just possibly another avenue you could look into (this is not a diagnosis). Maybe you could even try an experiment with a low protein diet and see if that helps alleviate the formation of the stones (forgive me if this has been brought up or tried, I didn't read the whole topic).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #92
bobze said:
cystinuria
I'll bring this up with the urologist. I doubt that he hasn't heard of it though and he is seriously looking at all possibilities. I have harvested a large number of stones that I keep in a little jewel box. None of them has turned green.
 
  • #93
I passed a 2mm stone about two weeks ago and another 2mm one today. There are stones in my kidney now that are too big to pass and so on Feb 4th I'm going to have ultrasound lithotripsy to smash them up. I want them out of me before the 15th because I intend to change insurance companies at that time and I don't want these stones to be a pre-existing condition. Ultrasound lithotripsy doesn't remove stones, it just smashes them up into smaller smoother pieces which then hopefully pass out of the kidney. My stones tend to be jagged and the smoothing action will be appreciated. The idea is to smash them into pieces so small that if they leave the kidney and start down the ureter, they will not get stuck along the way. If they fail to leave the kidney, then I assume they will become the seeds of new large stones.
 
  • #94
Jimmy Snyder said:
I passed a 2mm stone about two weeks ago and another 2mm one today. There are stones in my kidney now that are too big to pass and so on Feb 4th I'm going to have ultrasound lithotripsy to smash them up. I want them out of me before the 15th because I intend to change insurance companies at that time and I don't want these stones to be a pre-existing condition. Ultrasound lithotripsy doesn't remove stones, it just smashes them up into smaller smoother pieces which then hopefully pass out of the kidney. My stones tend to be jagged and the smoothing action will be appreciated. The idea is to smash them into pieces so small that if they leave the kidney and start down the ureter, they will not get stuck along the way. If they fail to leave the kidney, then I assume they will become the seeds of new large stones.

You have my most sincere sympathy... visceral pain is miserable. Hang in there man.
 
  • #95
Jimmy,

I cringed when I read your post, hope the sonic waves make the little critters small enough to pass easily, if you don't mind me asking, have you changed your diet, lifestyle habits during this horrible ordeal, or are you one of the few rare folks who is more "prone" genetically to develop them ? I drink water in the middle of the night, every night, and never become dehydrated, have long since given up on any artificially sweetened soda, etc... It seems to keep them at bay, for me at least. I wish you the best, the pain is hard to bear. Stress seems to play a factor in me getting them as well, not that any of us can control all the stress in our lives.

Rhody...
 
  • #96
Thanks, but these last two weren't painful at all. I have a dilated ureter due to a really bad stone a while back. Stones that pass on my right are actually hard to detect until they hit the bladder. I had some extensive tests to determine why I make so many stones, but they was inconclusive. Most of my family has passed at least one stone, but no one passes them like I do, I average about two a year in a quiet year, and 9 in one year.
 
  • #97
Jimmy Snyder said:
Thanks, but these last two weren't painful at all. I have a dilated ureter due to a really bad stone a while back. Stones that pass on my right are actually hard to detect until they hit the bladder. I had some extensive tests to determine why I make so many stones, but they was inconclusive. Most of my family has passed at least one stone, but no one passes them like I do, I average about two a year in a quiet year, and 9 in one year.

Well, I'm glad you're in no pain!
 
  • #98
nismaratwork said:
Well, I'm glad you're in no pain!

nismara, Jimmy,

That kind of blows my mind, imagine having enough stones over the years for the urters to either adapt or be gouged to a larger diameter, quite remarkable I must say, and good for you which means little, no pain.

Rhody...

PS I hope you don't mind, but is their a correlation between passing more stones in a given year and your overall stress level being higher than normal, the science geek in me is curious ?
 
Last edited:
  • #99
rhody said:
nismara, Jimmy,

That kind of blows my mind, imagine having enough stones over the years for the urters to either adapt or be gouged to a larger diameter, quite remarkable I must say, and good for you which means little, no pain.

Rhody...

PS I hope you don't mind, but is their a correlation between passing more stones in a given year and your overall stress level being higher than normal, the science geek in me in curious ?

It's at times like that that I'm really pleased I'm a head man... :blushing:

I'd guess that the formation of stones is related to either some basic way that calcium is being metabolized, or more likely, there is some other source of sediment that serves as a nucleation site for NORMAL blood levels.

I'm just glad to see someone on top of their condition, and to adapt so well that you can pass stones without pain? I'm sorry you've had to pass so many, but that's definitely a decent 'super power'.

Actually, you should just tell people that this is your "mutant power"; you pass kidney stones without wincing, and often!
 
  • #100
rhody said:
imagine having enough stones over the years for the urters to either adapt or be gouged to a larger diameter

...

PS I hope you don't mind, but is their a correlation between passing more stones in a given year and your overall stress level being higher than normal, the science geek in me is curious ?
What happened about 10 years ago was that a fairly large stone left the kidney and started down the ureter but got stuck about 2/3 of the way to the bladder. It blocked up the tube so water could not pass and as a result the ureter, which is about the diameter of a pencil lead, dilated to about the diameter of a pencil. It never contracted and so stones that pass on my right are difficult to detect. By the way, the blockage of water is what causes the worst stone pain.

I don't know if there is a correlation between stress and the passing of stones.
 
  • #101
I've been through the mill with these stones, but now I am experiencing a new phenomenon. There is a pile of 5 or 6 stones in my bladder all trying to get out at the same time. My prostate gland is enlarged and restricts the passage to the outside. As a result of this combination of conditions, even though a stone in the bladder would normally pass without event, nothing is moving. Next week the urologist is going to catheterize me and pull the stones out.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 45 ·
2
Replies
45
Views
14K
  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
8K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 47 ·
2
Replies
47
Views
10K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K