Surface Integral (two different answers?)

6 replies · 3K views · last reply
unscientific
Messages
1,728
Reaction score
13

Homework Statement


Typeset exam question: part (a) defines the Jacobian J = ∂(x, y, z)/∂(q1, q2, q3) for Cartesian and curvilinear coordinates and asks for volume elements in spherical and cylindrical coordinates; part (b) asks for the surface integral I = ∫∫_S (x² + y²) dS over the paraboloid z = 2 − (x² + y²) where z > 0.



Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



Not sure what's wrong with mine or the provided solution..both seems to be right.

My Solution:
Handwritten derivation for a surface integral over the paraboloid x^2 + y^2 = 2 - z, with a small 3D sketch of the surface, cylindrical coordinates (r, φ, z), and ds = r dφ dz; the integral is evaluated as 2π times the integral of (2 - z)^(3/2) dz from 0 to 2, giving 4/5 times 2^(5/2) times π.


Provided Solution:
Handwritten-style worked solution to a surface integral over a paraboloid z = 2 - (x^2 + y^2), z > 0, converted to polar coordinates with substitution u = sqrt(1 + 4r^2), ending at I = (149/30)π.
 
unscientific said:

Homework Statement


Exam question text: part (a) defines the Jacobian J = ∂(x, y, z)/∂(q1, q2, q3) for Cartesian and curvilinear orthogonal coordinates; part (b) asks for the surface integral I = ∫∫_S (x² + y²) dS over the paraboloid z = 2 − (x² + y²) for z > 0.



Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



Not sure what's wrong with mine or the provided solution..both seems to be right.

My Solution:
Handwritten solution to a surface integral over a paraboloid z = 2 - (x^2 + y^2), using cylindrical coordinates with ds = r dphi dz, ending with result (4/5)(2)^(5/2) pi.


Provided Solution:
Handwritten-style worked solution to a surface integral over a paraboloid z = 2 - (x^2 + y^2), with dS = [1 + (dz/dx)^2 + (dz/dy)^2]^(1/2) dxdy, polar substitution, and final result I = 149/30 pi.

I don't know why you just decided to use ##dS=r d\phi dz## instead of calculating it like the book did. Your solution is wrong. The dS you are using looks more like a dS for a cylinder than a paraboloid.
 
Dick said:
I don't know why you just decided to use ##dS=r d\phi dz## instead of calculating it like the book did. Your solution is wrong. The dS you are using looks more like a dS for a cylinder than a paraboloid.

But it shouldn't matter what coordinates you choose, right? It's not exactly a cylinder, as r is changing with z; r = √(2-z) and the equation x2 + y2 = 2 - z
is in the form of x2 + y2 = r2..
 
unscientific said:
But it shouldn't matter what coordinates you choose, right? It's not exactly a cylinder, as r is changing with z; r = √(2-z) and the equation x2 + y2 = 2 - z
is in the form of x2 + y2 = r2..

You must use the correct dS for your parameterization. You can either calculate dS in terms of x and y like they did or directly from your parameterization. The parameterization of that surface in cylindrical coordinates is$$
\vec R(r,\theta)=\langle r\cos\theta,r\sin\theta,2-r^2\rangle$$If you use that approach, the formula for dS is$$
dS = |\vec R_r \times\vec R_\theta|drd\theta$$
 
LCKurtz said:
You must use the correct dS for your parameterization. You can either calculate dS in terms of x and y like they did or directly from your parameterization. The parameterization of that surface in cylindrical coordinates is$$
\vec R(r,\theta)=\langle r\cos\theta,r\sin\theta,2-r^2\rangle$$If you use that approach, the formula for dS is$$
dS = |\vec R_r \times\vec R_\theta|drd\theta$$

Hmm that makes sense. In my geometric derivation of dS, did I assume that R is constant somewhere?

is Rr = ∂R/∂θ

and

Rθ = ∂R/∂r ??
 
unscientific said:
Hmm that makes sense. In my geometric derivation of dS, did I assume that R is constant somewhere?

is Rr = ∂R/∂θ

and

Rθ = ∂R/∂r ??

No, it's the other way around ##\vec R_r## is the derivative with respect to r. And, yes, if you imagine r constant (like a cylinder) you might write a dS like that down. But it would be wrong.
 
unscientific said:
Hmm that makes sense. In my geometric derivation of dS, did I assume that R is constant somewhere?
yes, the equation dS=r d(theta) dz only works for a surface of constant (cylindrical) radius. For a general surface, the equation will be different. Also, it doesn't matter which coordinates you use, in the sense that you could use
[tex]dS = |\vec R_r \times\vec R_\theta|drd\theta[/tex]
Or you could use
[tex]dS = |\vec R_z \times\vec R_\theta|dzd\theta[/tex]
Either of these equations would give you the correct answer. The second one is the 'correct way' to do the surface you were thinking of (i.e. integrating over theta and z). The main thing is that you need to substitute your 'parameterisation' into [itex]\vec{R}[/itex] before you do the partial integration. i.e. if you do the second equation for dS, then you will need to replace r with a function of z, then differentiate the position vector with respect to z.

Or, I guess equivalently, you can say that the partial derivative with respect to z is done, while only holding theta constant (i.e. r is allowed to vary).