Thermal Probability and Trig integrals <3

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
3 replies · 7K views
sugar_scoot
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Given the number of molecules hitting unit area of a surface per second with speeds between v and v +dv and angles between [tex]\theta[/tex] and d[tex]\theta[/tex] to the normal is

[tex]\frac{1}{2} v n f(v)dv sin \theta cos \theta d\theta[/tex]

show that the average value of cos [tex]\theta[/tex] for these molecules is [tex]\frac{2}{3}[/tex].

I have convinced myself the answer is 4/3 instead. Can anyone show me where I am wrong?
I used P(cos [tex]\theta[/tex]) = sin [tex]\theta[/tex] cos [tex]\theta[/tex]

Then I normalized:
1 = c [tex]\int^{\pi}_{0} sin \theta cos \theta d\theta[/tex]
so that:
c = 2

<cos [tex]\theta[/tex]> = 2 [tex]\int^{\pi}_{0} sin \theta cos^{2}\theta d \theta[/tex] = 2 (2/3) = 4/3
 
Physics news on Phys.org
sugar_scoot said:
Given the number of molecules hitting unit area of a surface per second with speeds between v and v +dv and angles between [tex]\theta[/tex] and d[tex]\theta[/tex] to the normal is

[tex]\frac{1}{2} v n f(v)dv sin \theta cos \theta d\theta[/tex]

show that the average value of cos [tex]\theta[/tex] for these molecules is [tex]\frac{2}{3}[/tex].

I have convinced myself the answer is 4/3 instead. Can anyone show me where I am wrong?
I used P(cos [tex]\theta[/tex]) = sin [tex]\theta[/tex] cos [tex]\theta[/tex]

Then I normalized:
1 = c [tex]\int^{\pi}_{0} sin \theta cos \theta d\theta[/tex]
so that:
c = 2

<cos [tex]\theta[/tex]> = 2 [tex]\int^{\pi}_{0} sin \theta cos^{2}\theta d \theta[/tex] = 2 (2/3) = 4/3

Integrating from 0 to [tex]\pi[/tex] overcounts the number of particles by a factor of 2. You only integrate from the normal to the plane, which is 0 to [tex]\pi/2[/tex]. Your normalization integral actually vanishes as written.
 
Thank you.

Is there an intuitive reason why normalization is unnecessary in this case? Should I continue to attempt normalization as a first step in problems like these?
 
Actually I just did the problem over again with the new integration limits and although my <cos[tex]\theta[/tex]> is now correct, I still found a normalization constant of 2.