Tidal forces acting on planet NGTS-10b

In summary, the tidal forces cause the NGTS-10b planet to fall towards it's star. This effect depends on the distance of the planet from the star. If the orbital spin direction of the planet about the star is in the opposite direction of the rotational spin direction of the star, this effect can happen. The same effect is causing Phobos to spiral in on Mars.
  • #1
Buzz Bloom
Gold Member
2,519
466
TL;DR Summary
NGTS-10b, illustrated generically, is the closest and fastest-orbiting giant planet yet discovered, circling its home star in only 18 hours. NGTS-10b is a little larger than Jupiter, but it orbits less than two times the diameter of its parent star away from the star’s surface. When a planet orbits this close, it is expected to spiral inward, pulled down by tidal forces to be eventually ripped apart by the star’s gravity.
https://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap200226.html
I am hoping a PF participant can help me understand why the tidal forces cause the NGTS-10b planet to fall towards it's star. I more-or-less understand why our moon's tidal forces on the Earth cause the Earth's rotation period to decrease, and the conservation of angular momentum of the Earth-moon system causes the moon to move away from the Earth. The only ideas I can think of are probably wrong.
(1) If the orbital spin direction of NGTS-10b about it's star is in the opposite direction of the rotational spin direction of it's star, that might explain this effect.
(2) If the orbital spin direction of NGTS-10b about it's star is in the opposite direction of the rotational spin direction of NGTS-10b, that might explain this effect.

The quoted text says the phenomenon depends of the distance of the planet from it's star. I do not understand this at all.
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
You will also get the spiral in result if the period of the orbit is shorter than the period for the rotation of the star (with both orbiting in the same direction). A closer planet has a shorter orbital period. This same effect is causing Phobos to spiral in on Mars.
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50 and Buzz Bloom
  • #3
Expanding on the answer above, look at the picture:
1583081208132.png

Row one shows how the smaller body rises a tidal bulge on the larger one. The tides on the smaller one are ignored. Likewise ignored are the forces due to the far end of the tidal bulge, as they're symmetrical but lower, so the nett effect is as shown above.

Rows two and three show what happens if we take into account that the larger body is rotating, with angular velocity ω1, while the smaller one orbits with angular velocity ω2. Both are in the anti-clockwise direction.

It takes some finite time for the tidal bulge to be raised and lowered, so depending on which ω is larger, the tidal bulge gets displaced from the line connecting the centres of the two bodies.

The displaced bulge acts gravitationally on the orbiting body along a direction that is no longer purely radial, so the force will result in torque on the orbiting body either pro- or retro-grade. This causes the orbit to be raised/lowered respectively (adding/removing orbital energy).

notes:
1) at the same time, the force vector acting on the larger body, and its tangential component causes torque, retarding/accelerating its rotation
2) since the orbiting body follows Kepler's laws, being initially located at lower R means the orbital period is faster, so for any omega ω1 there is a R where ω2 becomes higher than ω1 and the orbiting body is doomed to crash into the larger one
3) a special case is where the orbiting body orbits in a direction opposite of the direction of rotation of the larger body, in which case the forces are like shown in row 2, but the direction of orbital motion V is opposite, so the orbital torque is always retrograde - the orbiter will eventually fall into the central body regardless of the magnitude of its orbital speed.
4) another special case is when ω1=ω2, i.e. it's the tidal lock scenario, in which case the bulge remains aligned along the radial direction and no torques are present.
5) analogous effect works on the other body, i.e. the larger raises a bulge on the smaller, with all the same relations involved.
 
  • Like
Likes Lord Crc, Klystron and Buzz Bloom

1. What are tidal forces?

Tidal forces are the gravitational forces that occur when two objects are close enough to each other that their gravitational pull affects each other. In the case of NGTS-10b, the tidal forces are caused by the planet's orbit around its host star.

2. How do tidal forces affect planet NGTS-10b?

Tidal forces can cause the planet to experience tidal heating, which is the increase in temperature due to the friction created by the planet's tidal bulges as it orbits its host star. This can also lead to tidal locking, where the same side of the planet always faces its host star.

3. How does the strength of tidal forces on NGTS-10b compare to other planets?

The strength of tidal forces on a planet depends on its mass, distance from its host star, and the mass of its host star. NGTS-10b is a gas giant with a mass similar to that of Jupiter, and it orbits very close to its host star, resulting in strong tidal forces compared to other planets in our solar system.

4. Can tidal forces cause changes in the shape of NGTS-10b?

Yes, tidal forces can cause the planet to become slightly elongated in the direction of its host star. This is known as tidal bulging and is a common occurrence for planets that experience strong tidal forces.

5. Are tidal forces the only factor affecting the evolution of NGTS-10b?

No, there are many other factors that can affect the evolution of a planet, such as its composition, atmosphere, and distance from its host star. Tidal forces are just one of the many factors that can shape the characteristics of a planet like NGTS-10b.

Similar threads

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
14
Views
504
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
1
Views
804
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
5
Views
2K
Back
Top