Curiosity_0
- 6
- 2
We know that if a projectile is thrown vertically, there will be a brief time when it momentarily stops. Can we calculate this brief moment?
The discussion revolves around the moment a vertically thrown projectile stops at its highest point. Participants explore the nature of this moment, questioning whether it can be considered a period of time or merely an instantaneous event.
Participants generally agree that the velocity of the projectile is zero at the highest point, but there is disagreement on whether this moment can be considered a period of time or if it is purely instantaneous.
The discussion touches on the limitations of measuring instantaneous events and the philosophical implications of defining velocity at a point in time, without resolving these complexities.
It's zero seconds. It's the same for any other velocity on its trajectory.Curiosity_0 said:We know that if a projectile is thrown vertically, there will be a brief time when it momentarily stops. Can we calculate this brief moment?
As others have said, the velocity is zero only instantaneously. These plots of the vertical motion of a projectile should help. See how the acceleration due to gravity is a constant negative value (-g)?, and how the velocity decreases linearly from the initial ##v_0## down through zero to end up being ##-v_0## when the projectile impacts the ground?Curiosity_0 said:We know that if a projectile is thrown vertically, there will be a brief time when it momentarily stops. Can we calculate this brief moment?
It will stop at a particular clock-reading, but that clock-reading lasts for zero time.Curiosity_0 said:We know that if a projectile is thrown vertically, there will be a brief time when it momentarily stops. Can we calculate this brief moment?
We 'think' we know that. Reasonable enough because things happen pretty slowly at the high point it would really boil down to how quickly and accurately we could actually measure that velocity. Zero velocity is actually no more special than +1m/s or -1.05m/s. This was a problem for the old Physicists until the concepts involved in Differential Calculus were introduced. The theory is that you consider a smaller and smaller interval between two (imagined) measurements the limit as the interval approaches zero is the 'true' value of the velocity.Curiosity_0 said:We know that if a projectile is thrown vertically, there will be a brief time when it momentarily stops. Can we calculate this brief moment?