Unanswered thread not on UAT list?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Merlin3189
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
A new poster's homework question was removed from the unanswered list after they added more information, which hindered visibility for potential help. The original poster is struggling with the math involved and seeks a way to get the thread back on the unanswered list without reposting. They express concern that initial responses often lead to threads being overlooked, despite the need for clarification in many questions. The discussion highlights the challenge of balancing helpfulness with maintaining a thread's visibility for expert assistance. Ultimately, the community is encouraged to consider alternative methods for keeping questions accessible to mathematicians.
Merlin3189
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Messages
1,733
Reaction score
824
A new poster has put up a homework question, but managed to knock it off the unanswered list by adding further info. I've been trying to help via private conversation, but although I'm convinced an analytic solution is possible, the maths is temporarily defeating me! (Only basic calculus, derivative of function of function, but I'm very rusty.)

Is there any way, other than reposting in a new thread, that it can get back on the UAT list, so that real mathematicians can see it and maybe help. Post referred to is: in Introductory Physics HW, by Makonia,
" How to chose the angle and initial speed to hit two objects "
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
I was curious and merged the three posts. The thread appeared in the list of unanswered threads again.
Then I wrote an answer, now it is not on the list any more of couse.
 
Thanks. Sorry if I was a bit hasty. I was feeling guilty about encouraging him to add more info, then not being able to help myself.
I did look up a formula like the ones appearing in the thread now, but have still not been able to derive it myself even having the result to guide me!

I often feel the first response to a post needs to be to ask for more info, especially as many questions are poorly explained. But it does worry me that, as soon as you make any sort of response, the post leaves the unanswered list, where it would normally be much more likely to be noticed.

I expect you have considered these problems a lot and I can see drawbacks to any alternatives I've yet thought of.

Unless I think I'm going to be able to offer a full answer, I generally reply via a conversation leaving the thread unanswered to attract further attention.
 
I want to thank those members who interacted with me a couple of years ago in two Optics Forum threads. They were @Drakkith, @hutchphd, @Gleb1964, and @KAHR-Alpha. I had something I wanted the scientific community to know and slipped a new idea in against the rules. Thank you also to @berkeman for suggesting paths to meet with academia. Anyway, I finally got a paper on the same matter as discussed in those forum threads, the fat lens model, got it peer-reviewed, and IJRAP...
This came up in my job today (UXP). Never thought to raise it here on PF till now. Hyperlinks really should be underlined at all times. PF only underlines them when they are rolled over. Colour alone (especially dark blue/purple) makes it difficult to spot a hyperlink in a large block of text (or even a small one). Not everyone can see perfectly. Even if they don't suffer from colour deficiency, not everyone has the visual acuity to distinguish two very close shades of text. Hover actions...
About 20 years ago, in my mid-30s (and with a BA in economics and a master's in business), I started taking night classes in physics hoping to eventually earn the science degree I'd always wanted but never pursued. I found physics forums and used it to ask questions I was unable to get answered from my textbooks or class lectures. Unfortunately, work and life got in the way and I never got further the freshman courses. Well, here it is 20 years later. I'm in my mid-50s now, and in a...

Similar threads

4
Replies
163
Views
20K
Replies
32
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
5K
Replies
0
Views
2K
Replies
22
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
3K
Back
Top