Understanding Hydrides of Group 5 and 6 for Chemistry Exam

  • Thread starter Thread starter leena19
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Group
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the acidity and oxidation states of hydrides from Group 5 and 6 elements, particularly focusing on NH3, AsH3, SbH3, and BiH3. It is noted that acidity increases from NH3 to AsH3, while the trend reverses for SbH3 to BiH3. The oxidation state of bismuth (Bi) in BiH3 is clarified as +3, while in BiH2-, it is +1. The participant seeks further clarification on the behavior of these hydrides and their acidity, especially regarding the metallic and metalloid nature of the elements involved. The conversation highlights the complexities of hydride acidity and oxidation states in preparation for an upcoming chemistry exam.
leena19
Messages
184
Reaction score
0
Hello everyone,
this is a question I've asked at another chemistry forum,
and has been bothering me for awhile .
http://www.chemicalforums.com/index.php?topic=34742.0"

And ... the only only reason I'm posting it here aswell,is causeI have my chem exam on Thursday(the day after tomorrow) and...I'm the kinda idiot(also a blabbermouth) who can't skip a problem unless I'm absolutely sure I've understood it,so... I would really appreciate it if I could find a solution to this before my exams...


And oh...I know I ask a lot of stupid questions ,so if you think this is one of those,just tell me & i won't bother you guys.
(well,i might pester your'll with other questions,but no more pestering after my exams,for atleast a week,promise. :) )

thx.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
You say that the acidity of the hydrides increases from top to bottom (from NH3 to AsH3) and that the reverse is seen if you go backwards from BiH3 to SbH3! Wouldn't the reverse also be seen if you go from AsH3 to NH3?

Sounds like someone is asking you a trick question...
 
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR REPLYING!

chemisttree said:
You say that the acidity of the hydrides increases from top to bottom (from NH3 to AsH3) and that the reverse is seen if you go backwards from BiH3 to SbH3! Wouldn't the reverse also be seen if you go from AsH3 to NH3?

Er...is that a trick question ?
Sorry if my problem isn't clear,but this is basically what my question is,

\stackrel{\leftarrow}{}
Arranged in increasing order of acid strength
AsH3 > PH3 > NH3 > SbH3 > BiH3

The acidity increases from NH3 to AsH3,then the acidic strength decreases from SbH3 to BiH3 .
What makes the group5 hydrides react this way?
 
What is the oxidation state of Bi in the BiH3 compound? What about BiH2-?

Acidity reaction would be:

BiH3 <--------> BiH2- + H+
 
chemisttree said:
What is the oxidation state of Bi in the BiH3 compound?
All group 5 hydrides are trivalent,so the oxidation state of Bi would be -3

What about BiH2-?
The same. -3 ?

Not sure how to proceed from here.
 
Thanks for the very useful link.
Ok so the oxidation state of Bi in BiH3 is +3 and in BiH2-,it is +1 .
Then,since it's a metal it has to be more basic(i.e less acidic) than SbH3.
But SbH3 and AsH3 are metalloids...?

Can you tell me what I should do next?

thx.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top