Unknown Transformation Machine

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the unknown transformation machine T that maps vectors from R^4 to R^3. It is established that with only two known vectors U and V, which span a subspace of dimension 2, it is insufficient to fully determine T. To completely characterize the transformation, additional information about T's effect on two more independent vectors is necessary. The transformation matrix T is a 3x4 matrix, and without knowing its action on a complete basis of R^4, the transformation cannot be fully resolved. The conversation emphasizes the limitations of the provided data in calculating T.
JoelN
Messages
6
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement



You have a unknown Transformation machine T. that transforms from R^4 --> R^3

Vectors U and V are known and the output from T is also known.

Can You calculate the values of T?

Homework Equations


[/B]
What values/information is needed to calcuate T ?

The Attempt at a Solution



I can solve any Vector that is a linear combination of vectors U and/or V but the book doesn't say how to solve what T is and the problem doesn't need it either only to see if you can solve given vectors using linear comb of U and/or V but I am still curious.
Maybe it cannot be solved or if it can its higher mathematics.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The question you posed under "relevant equations" is not a relevant equation. How would you get the transformed vector if you knew the matrix components of the transformation? What are the dimensions of the transformation matrix T?
 
  • Like
Likes JoelN
ehild said:
The question you posed under "relevant equations" is not a relevant equation. How would you get the transformed vector if you knew the matrix components of the transformation? What are the dimensions of the transformation matrix T?

a R^4 --> R^3 Transformer is a 3X4 Matrix, i only know 2 values of 2 linearly independent vectors after going through T. Can i calculate T or do i need more information?
 
How many equations do you have for those 3x4 unknowns?
 
  • Like
Likes JoelN
ehild said:
How many equations do you have for those 3x4 unknowns?

only 2 vectors before and after going through T
 
You know what the transformation does with the subspace spanned by the given U and V vectors, but do not know what happens with the other vectors. Can you fully determine T?
 
  • Like
Likes JoelN
R^4 has dimension 4 and u and v, even if they are independent can only span a subspace of dimension 2 (dimension 1 if they are dependent). You need to know what T, applied to two more independent vectors would give in order to completely determine T.
 
  • Like
Likes JoelN
ehild said:
You know what the transformation does with the subspace spanned by the given U and V vectors, but do not know what happens with the other vectors. Can you fully determine T?

HallsofIvy said:
R^4 has dimension 4 and u and v, even if they are independent can only span a subspace of dimension 2 (dimension 1 if they are dependent). You need to know what T, applied to two more independent vectors would give in order to completely determine T.

thanks to both.
 
Back
Top