- #1
Blue Scallop
- 290
- 17
We laymen and newbies are taught the Schrodinger equation was deterministic. So we tend to picture it’s like a classical thing.. some forever thinking it that way where the idea is etched deep in the mind. Yet when we are home with the idea it is deterministic (that is.. when not measured).. some scolded us and told us quantum state is not like classical state at all where there is one to one correspondence. In fact, you need to use operators to get the quantum state. For 80% of laymen. It’s too late as we thought the Schrodinger equation was deterministic and most can’t forget it and unable to get any analogy right.
To illustrate the point. Can you explain to laymen what occurs in the following.
Let’s say you have a c60 buckyball in superposition. Then you descramble its wave function (meaning make the deterministic evolution sporatic by let’s say perturbing it with a wave function disruptor).. what would happen to the buckyball.. would it become descramble too.
We laymen reason that since the wave function is deterministic. It’s like being in one to one classical correspondence with the object. So we can’t get why you need operators for example to get the momentum or spin of the particle. Using laymen explanations that only laymen can understand. Please explain what it means the schrodinger equation is deterministic yet you need operators to compute for the momentum. 95% of laymen don’t know this. Thank you.
To illustrate the point. Can you explain to laymen what occurs in the following.
Let’s say you have a c60 buckyball in superposition. Then you descramble its wave function (meaning make the deterministic evolution sporatic by let’s say perturbing it with a wave function disruptor).. what would happen to the buckyball.. would it become descramble too.
We laymen reason that since the wave function is deterministic. It’s like being in one to one classical correspondence with the object. So we can’t get why you need operators for example to get the momentum or spin of the particle. Using laymen explanations that only laymen can understand. Please explain what it means the schrodinger equation is deterministic yet you need operators to compute for the momentum. 95% of laymen don’t know this. Thank you.