What are your thoughts on the Black Panther movie?

  • Thread starter Thread starter phinds
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Movie Thread
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around opinions on the "Black Panther" movie, with mixed reviews on the performances, particularly criticizing the lead actor's portrayal while praising the villain and supporting characters. Viewers appreciated the strong female roles and the film's unique elements, such as the concept of vibranium and the depiction of a technologically advanced African nation. Some expressed disappointment in the film's focus on political themes rather than superhero action, suggesting a desire for future sequels to explore broader global interactions. The cinematography received positive remarks, highlighting memorable scenes. Overall, the film sparked varied reactions, with some eager for a sequel while others planned to watch it later on streaming platforms.
phinds
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
2024 Award
Messages
19,359
Reaction score
15,545
I'm interested to see what folks think about the BP movie. I just saw it this evening. Personally, I was very impressed by all of the actors except the Black Panther, whom I thought was meh. The general, the little sister, and the bad guy were all particularly outstanding to me.

The CGI was good, but one sort of expects that these days.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I have to say I agree. The Black Panther himself was disappointing. Normally, I wouldn't call an actor's performance disappointing, but when the villain, and other side characters have an immensely superior performance, I feel let down that the main actor performed sub-par.

The villain has probably some of the best acting I've seen, a good conveyance of the emotions in his life. I would've liked for him to have a little more story, maybe a little more about the boy as a prologue, but I can see why they cut it out.

The cinematography was tremendous as well. One of my favorite scenes would be the shot of the villain walking upside down and the villain surrounded by fire.

Hope I didn't give any spoilers...

Have fun when you watch it!
 
So ... no Black Panther fans?
 
phinds said:
So ... no Black Panther fans?
To be honest, the current climate in Hollywood has reduced my desire to see this movie. When I go to see a superhero movie, I want to turn off my brain and watch superheros do superhero things and not put a lot of thought into it. A superhero movie that I feel like I'm supposed to judge (and worse, is judging me!) just doesn't sound fun.

I'll probably watch it on Netflix.
 
I thought it was fantastic. Great to see women in strong and scientific roles. It's not a particularly deep movie or different than other Marvel super hero movies outside of the majority black cast (which was refreshing). @russ_watters
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
phinds said:
The general, the little sister, and the bad guy were all particularly outstanding to me.
I loved the cast. Michon from Walking Dead. Smeagol and Frodo from LOTR. The main guy from Get Out and the main bad guy was Wallace from The Wire.
 
phinds said:
So ... no Black Panther fans?

I loved the sassy sister character in the movie and liked some ideas in it (the concept of vibranium was pretty cool and the hidden high-tech world beneath the surface of a regular African nation was interesting), but I didn't enjoy it as much as most people I know. I'm not sure why.

I know I wasn't that interested in the king challenges that much. But I did like the concept of this secret element in vibranium that could do amazing things and how the world could be potentially changed by it...and the decision-making that went into whether or not to help others with it or not.

If a sequel moves the plot away from the inner-politics of who rules Wakanda and the kingship and focuses more on the uses of the Wakandan people's powers and how they interact with events around the world using it, then I'd be more interested. It looks like the ending might have hinted at that.

So, I'll probably see a sequel too.

Maybe I'm in the minority, but I loved the Black Panther's acting (don't know his name). Really, I thought there was great acting from lots of folks.
 
kyphysics said:
I loved the sassy sister character in the movie and liked some ideas in it (the concept of vibranium was pretty cool and the hidden high-tech world beneath the surface of a regular African nation was interesting), but I didn't enjoy it as much as most people I know. I'm not sure why.

I know I wasn't that interested in the king challenges that much. But I did like the concept of this secret element in vibranium that could do amazing things and how the world could be potentially changed by it...and the decision-making that went into whether or not to help others with it or not.

If a sequel moves the plot away from the inner-politics of who rules Wakanda and the kingship and focuses more on the uses of the Wakandan people's powers and how they interact with events around the world using it, then I'd be more interested. It looks like the ending might have hinted at that.

So, I'll probably see a sequel too.

Maybe I'm in the minority, but I loved the Black Panther's acting (don't know his name). Really, I thought there was great acting from lots of folks.

The actor who played T'Challa (i.e. the Black Panther) is Chadwick Boseman. Among his other roles include portraying US Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall in the film Marshall and singer James Brown in the film Get on Up.

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1569276/?ref_=fn_al_nm_1
 
russ_watters said:
To be honest, the current climate in Hollywood has reduced my desire to see this movie. When I go to see a superhero movie, I want to turn off my brain and watch superheros do superhero things and not put a lot of thought into it. A superhero movie that I feel like I'm supposed to judge (and worse, is judging me!) just doesn't sound fun.

I'll probably watch it on Netflix.

I'm puzzled why you think Black Panther is somehow judging you in any particular way. From what I've heard of the film thus far (please note: I haven't seen the film yet, primarily because of my dislike of many of the local multiplex theatres in my area), the Black Panther film doesn't differ all that significantly from other MCU films with the exception of the predominantly black cast.
 
  • #10
StatGuy2000 said:
I'm puzzled why you think Black Panther is somehow judging you ...
You might want to read his post a little more carefully.
 
  • #11
phinds said:
You might want to read his post a little more carefully.

Perhaps I need to rephrase -- why should the current climate in Hollywood make one iota of difference in appreciating Black Panther (assuming one is even into superhero films to begin with)?
 
Back
Top